Mystery Box Mafia - Game Over

[DeathNote]

I have always liked MOI's dedication to his games. He gives such long and well quoted posts.

[MagnaofIllusion]

And now a large catch-up post for recent events –

So my Sekrit partner and I have mostly been slacking in the QT. Meh, what can you do?

And I promised myself I would do a real VC Analysis of Day 1 and Day 2 soon. Maybe I can get that done today.

--

I absolutely detest “Lulz, Gambitz” like what Junox tried. The fact that you claimed once again to have ‘shot’ Neruz and he survived when the actual Mod provided facts said differently is annoying as hell.

I’ve had a Town read on Neruz and the continual attacks on him are baffling me. Anyone want to provide an outline that doesn’t revolve around invalid ‘Cop’ results?

--

CoolDoG continues to be Town as his catch on the blatant inconsistency (aka not actually scum-hunting but just creating filler that looks like scum-hunting to the naked eye) of Rikana’s VC Inhim reads is solid Town investigation.

--

Funnily I am just now reading Lobster’s Rikana ISO. I’m seeing many of the same elements from the review I just did. Lobster is Town.

--

Empking’s vote on Neruz from an obviously busted Cop claim looks very scummy.

Secondly, semi-cop results.

No. Just absolutely fucking NO!!!!!

Because the second ‘Semi-Cop’ result was so obviously incorrect that you didn’t even stop to question it makes my scum-dar ping madly.

Vote: Neruz - The "Who's Rhinox?" discussion.

Pop quiz … what does Neruz as scum have to gain from pushing a technically correct but pointless issue like that?

--

In the mid 30s, Lobster is looking like a really good lynch from her day 1 play around xvart and ReaperCharlie, and Deathnote looks like a decent lynch from his uselessness day 1 and being on RC's top 3 scumlist with the dead jester and a kondi (who looked like he was only on the list for calling RC scum).

Why don’t your provide some examples of why Lobster’s play around xvart and RC is suspect. Because I have a pretty good Town read on LC.

Um, are you relying on a Dead Person’s list as a reason to vote someone? Really? Because I thought that was prime-time scum play in your book.

--

Rikana’s 1199 ‘VC Analysis’ is so craptasticly butchered words don’t even ….

[inHimshallibe]

YamiChan

(4) - Rikana,

CSL

,

Toon Fighter

, danakillsu

CSL

(6) -

Lady Lambdadelta

,

YamiChan

,

ReaperCharlie

, CooLDoG, Sathoris, inHimshallibe

hohum

(1) - MagnaofIllusion
Gammagooeyjmj3000(1) - Empkingkondi2424
Rikana(3) - SpyreX,

xvart

, LobsterCatapult
Neruz(2) - DeathNote, JunoxJuls

Lady Lambdadelta

(1) -

Mastermind of Sin

ReaperCharlie

(5) -

Hoopla

,

Primate

, Neruz,

DeityKabuto

,

hohum

Not Voting(2) -

bvoigt

, Gammagooeyjmj3000

YamiChan

(4) - Rikana,

CSL

,

Toon Fighter

, danakillsu

CSL

(5) -

YamiChan

,

ReaperCharlie

, CooLDoG, Sathoris, inHimshallibe

hohum

(1) - MagnaofIllusion
Gammagooeyjmj3000(1) - Empkingkondi2424
Rikana(2) - SpyreX, LobsterCatapult
Neruz(2) - DeathNote, JunoxJuls

Lady Lambdadelta

(1) -

Mastermind of Sin

ReaperCharlie

(6) -

Hoopla

,

Primate

, Neruz,

DeityKabuto

,

hohum

,

xvart

Primate

(1) -

Lady Lambdadelta

Not Voting(2) -

bvoigt

, Gammagooeyjmj3000

YamiChan

(3) - Rikana,

Toon Fighter

, danakillsu

CSL

(6) -

ReaperCharlie

, CooLDoG, Sathoris, inHimshallibe, MagnaofIllusion, LobsterCatapult
Rikana(1) - SpyreX
Neruz(2) - DeathNote, JunoxJuls

Lady Lambdadelta

(1) -

Mastermind of Sin

ReaperCharlie

(8) -

Hoopla

, Neruz,

DeityKabuto

,

hohum

,

xvart

,

CSL

, Empkingkondi2424,

YamiChan

Primate

(1) -

Lady Lambdadelta

Not Voting(3) -

bvoigt

, Gammagooeyjmj3000,

Primate

YamiChan

(3) - Rikana,

Toon Fighter

, danakillsu

CSL

(8) -

ReaperCharlie

, CooLDoG, Sathoris, inHimshallibe, MagnaofIllusion, LobsterCatapult, JunoxJuls,

YamiChan

Rikana(1) - SpyreX
Neruz(1) - DeathNote

Lady Lambdadelta

(1) -

Mastermind of Sin

ReaperCharlie

(7) -

Hoopla

, Neruz,

DeityKabuto

,

hohum

,

xvart

,

CSL

, Empkingkondi2424

Primate

(1) -

Lady Lambdadelta

Not Voting(3) -

bvoigt

, Gammagooeyjmj3000,

Primate

YamiChan

(3) - Rikana,

Toon Fighter

, danakillsu

CSL

(10) -

ReaperCharlie

, CooLDoG, Sathoris, inHimshallibe, LobsterCatapult, JunoxJuls,

YamiChan

, DeathNote,

Lady Lambdadelta

, Empkingkondi2424
Rikana(1) - SpyreX

ReaperCharlie

(5) -

Hoopla

,

DeityKabuto

,

hohum

,

xvart

,

CSL

Neruz(1) -

Mastermind of Sin

Not Voting(5) -

bvoigt

, Gammagooeyjmj3000,

Primate

, MagnaofIllusion, Neruz

YamiChan

(2) -

Toon Fighter

, danakillsu

CSL

(12) -

ReaperCharlie

, CooLDoG, Sathoris, inHimshallibe, LobsterCatapult, JunoxJuls,

YamiChan

, DeathNote,

Lady Lambdadelta

, Empkingkondi2424,

Hoopla

,

hohum

Rikana(1) - SpyreX

ReaperCharlie

(3) -

DeityKabuto

,

xvart

,

CSL

Neruz(1) -

Mastermind of Sin

inHimshallibe(1) - Rikana

Not Voting(5) -

bvoigt

, Gammagooeyjmj3000,

Primate

, MagnaofIllusion, Neruz

YamiChan

(3) - Rikana,

Toon Fighter

, danakillsu

CSL

(13) -

ReaperCharlie

, CooLDoG, Sathoris, inHimshallibe, LobsterCatapult, JunoxJuls,

YamiChan

, DeathNote,

Lady Lambdadelta

, Empkingkondi2424,

Hoopla

,

hohum

,

Mastermind of Sin

Rikana(1) - SpyreX

ReaperCharlie

(3) -

DeityKabuto

,

xvart

,

CSL

Not Voting(5) -

bvoigt

, Gammagooeyjmj3000,

Primate

, MagnaofIllusion, Neruz

ReaperCharlie

(2) -

xvart

, inHimshallibe
CooLDoG(1) -

Primate

Neruz(1) -

ReaperCharlie

nHimshallibe(1) - Sathoris
Not Voting(14) - MagnaofIllusion, Junox, Rikana, danakillsu, Empkingkondi2424, DeathNote,

DeityKabuto

, SpyreX, LobsterCatapult,

Kublai Khan

,

hohum

, CooLDoG, Neruz, Gammagooeyjmj3000

ReaperCharlie

(4) -

xvart

, inHimshallibe,

hohum

,

DeityKabuto

CooLDoG(1) -

Primate

Neruz(1) - Empking
inHimshallibe(1) - Sathoris

xvart

(3) -

Kublai Khan

, MagnaofIllusion, Junox

Primate

(1) - Rikana

Not Voting(8) - danakillsu, DeathNote, SpyreX, LobsterCatapult, CooLDoG, Neruz, Gammagooeyjmj3000,

ReaperCharlie

Neruz(5) - Junox, Rikana, CooLDoG,

DeityKabuto

, LobsterCatapult

hohum

(2) - SpyreX, MagnaofIllusion

DeityKabuto

(1) - Empking
DeathNote(1) - danakillsu

Not Voting(7) - Sathoris,

hohum

, inHimshallibe, Neruz, Gammagooeyjmj3000,

Primate

, DeathNote

[inHimshallibe]

PERSONS OF INTEREST:
Rikana |||||||| = 8
dana |||||||| = 8
MoI ||||| = 5
Empking ||||||| = 7
DeathNote ||||||| = 7
Junox |||||||| = 8
SpyreX |||||| = 6
LobsterCatapult |||||| = 6
Gammagooey | = 1
Neruz | = 1
Sathoris || = 2



Right now, the ones to stick out to me most are {Rikana, dana}, Empking, and SpyreX

[inHimshallibe]

Ooh, LC too.


Did we get a claim from Rikana yet?

[MagnaofIllusion]

Did we get a claim from Rikana yet?

Why are you worried about him claiming? Boxes are randomly distributed so any ability he may have is Null regarding his alignment.

Lynch

or don't lynch him

for his play.

[inHimshallibe]

Did we get a claim from Rikana yet?

Why are you worried about him claiming? Boxes are randomly distributed so any ability he may have is Null regarding his alignment.

Lynch

or don't lynch him

for his play.

There may be redeeming qualities about his use of Box power. That's part of his play as well, yes?

[Gammagooey]

I didn't start anything.>_< People need to stop. I know what you're trying to do. I want to play this game in peace.

mafia is anything but peaceful

You're really not helping with this quandary.

I am delighted to hear that my posts are obscure. It really helps lift the atmosphere of hate off my shoulders.

Are you an alt? Are you trying to start a fire to derail the day?

Do I sense the wonders of opportunity in your text? Why yes, yes I do.

Unvote, Vote: Xvart

Vote Hohum

Speed lynch?

But the words of opportunity also come from this one's ideas as well.

Interesting. I am at a T-Junction in which both paths end the same.

I shall go to the left, and follow the road.

It shall make a circle.

please god lets not let robert frost be a posting restriction.

why is xvart's vote more "opportunistic" than deathnotes?

you sure this isn't a thinly veiled omgus?

mine is so opportunistic it hurts. You should vote me instead of him. I am simply bwing without a cause.

True, but the xvart was trying to make a cause up.

Which one do you think is worse? Making some really bad excuse up, or not having an excuse at all?

Let's put this in real life perspective.

You get held off on a date.

Would you be more pissed if your date...
A)Sent you a really crappy "We're breaking up message", ending all discussion there
B)Sent you a "It's not you, it's me" message.

It seems that B is most probably the better choice of the two.

i dont think xvart was really making up a case he was asking questions. one of which was loaded. still no case here.

if you were voting based on opportunism, the correct vote would have been DN, his reasoning was weakest, and was third on a wagon, rather than 2nd.

More people should vote for either Reaper or CSL. Nothing is to be gained from voting randomly for people...unless you're Mafia.O_o

soo....just because my vote isn't on one of the 2 major wagons makes it random? or are you just talking about the vestiges of RVS? either way, ill be changing it, but i dont like your post.

i am willing to believe that post restrictions out there exist due to opening my box (no i dont have one myself)

RC's is by far the most distracting, and the most unreasonable of them all, but with the levels of boxes in play, i can see why his might be more difficult than LLD's or saths who cant use vowels.

im not sure if i believe sath's posting restriction, his reaction to it may have been a bit forced. im not gonna look too much more into it right now though.

Size is smallinated so it doesn't take up miles of space. Lobster defended xvart against Rikana early and points out RC's post restriction as the most distracting and unreasonable but not scummy and gives why he could still be town, while defending her lack of a Reaper/CSL vote to Yami.

And MoI Fate is the one that had the problem with you using a dead townie's list in the other game, not me.

I'd prefer a DeathNote lynch by given his useless and effortless play combined with being on RC's early scumlist with a "townie" (CSL) and a guy that's likely town for his early play and looked like he was only on the list for attacking RC. Rikana is pretty high up there on DeathNote's likely partners though and her more recent play is a lot worse than her early stuff with xvart so I don't think she's a terrible lynch.

[Sathoris]

UNVOTE:

VOTE: Rikana

Srr fr nt cntrbtng bt ths rstrctn rlly dscrgs m frm dng s. nthng mr thn n lnrs nd t's gng t b jst s nnyng fr y gys.

[inHimshallibe]

LC looks a bit worse with that Gamma. I feel like LC was softly defending xvart.

[kunkstar7]

Vote Count:

Rikana(6)

- LobsterCatapult, MagnaofIllusion, SpyreX, CoolDoG, danakillsu, Sathoris

DeathNote(1)

- Gammagooey

Neruz(4)

- inHimshallibe, Junox, Rikana, Empking

Empking(1)

- Neruz

Not Voting(1)

- DeathNote

With 13 alive, it is 7 to lynch.

Deadline is in

(expired on 2011-07-24 19:38:00)

To the best of my knowledge Seraphim is currently V/LA.

[Gammagooey]

Oh wow I thought deadline was way way farther away.

Rikana claim.

[Gammagooey]

Wait, shouldn't we have until the 24th?

1. The first day will have a deadline of twenty days. Ten days from the official beginning of the day is the default deadline for each day that follows. I don't want to move this, though I might if excessive flaking occurs to grab replacements.

[kunkstar7]

The deadline has been corrected in the previous three Vote Counts and now displays the proper deadline, which is in fact on the 24th.

[Gammagooey]

Cool.
Anyone up for a deathnote lynch since we have more time now? You know you want to murder a delicious useless lurkerscums.
If not I need to go over Neruz some before deciding between him and Rikana.

[MagnaofIllusion]

Cool.
Anyone up for a deathnote lynch since we have more time now? You know you want to murder a delicious useless lurkerscums.
If not I need to go over Neruz some before deciding between him and Rikana.

Actually lay out some posts of Deathnote that you feel are scummy. I'll be honest ... after looking at his ISO I see several posts that ring solid Town.

And Rikana I feel is pretty much claimed scum so unless you can provide a convincing case I'm not going 'Lurkerscum' hunting at this stage.

[Gammagooey]

Actually lay out some posts of Deathnote that you feel are scummy. I'll be honest ... after looking at his ISO I see several posts that ring solid Town.

And Rikana I feel is pretty much claimed scum so unless you can provide a convincing case I'm not going 'Lurkerscum' hunting at this stage.

Death has-

Grab box off shelf

Not sure if that is allowed but I know that we can have two boxes at a time so figured I would try it out. The mechanics of this game are going to be very interesting.

Vote: CD

For wifoming (RVS vote)

An explicit disclaimer that his vote is an RVS vote to avoid it being called out for something

Fastest... day... ever...

Wow...........

An utterly useless comment after CSL is lynched until after CSL claims jester that looks very much like scum thinking there's just been a stupid fast townie lynch, despite suggesting a speed lynch earlier that day with

Vote Hohum

Speed lynch?

Wow wagon...

Another pointless post for the sake of posting,
and he doesn't bother voting day 2 or today, with absolutely nothing he's done looking like scumhunting except his iso 5 on day 1.

I would very much like to see the posts you think he has that are townie by the way.

[DeathNote]

All of your quotes on me are based off my first posts of the game. Its the beginning of the game where people RVS, joke around, and get discussion going. If you are honestly saying you can catch scum based off the first 5 pages in day 1 then I am truly impressed.

[Gammagooey]

You haven't posted a SINGLE VOTE since day 1, you haven't even been Trying in this game since then you scumbargo.

[DeathNote]

You haven't posted a SINGLE VOTE since day 1, you haven't even been Trying in this game since then you scumbargo.

So has your case now changed because you didn't seem to acknowledge my defense. Just let me know what it is you actually want me dead for.

[Gammagooey]

Another pointless post for the sake of posting,
and he doesn't bother voting day 2 or today, with absolutely nothing he's done looking like scumhunting except his iso 5 on day 1.

READ MY POSTS NEXT TIME BEFORE TRYING TO DISPROVE THEM, PROTIPS.

[DeathNote]

Thanks for the tip.

So your case is I haven't voted except on day 1 and my lack of scumhunting. How is that scummy? That could just as easily be lazy town.

[Gammagooey]

It's scummy because you haven't put an ounce of effort into the game since then to try to lynch scum, which is the Entire Point of playing as town.

[DeathNote]

The point of playing as town is to eliminate all threats to town. You have no right to judge how I determine someone a threat to town. If I vote someone, then I vote them based on them being mafia in my eyes. If I dont vote, then that must mean I dont find someone worthy of my vote. Just because I have issues with catching scum tells does not mean I am instantly scum. Please rethink your vote and concentrate your efforts on someone playing scummy and not someone playing poorly.

[Gammagooey]

The point of playing as town is to eliminate all threats to town. You have no right to judge how I determine someone a threat to town. If I vote someone, then I vote them based on them being mafia in my eyes. If I dont vote, then that must mean I dont find someone worthy of my vote. Just because I have issues with catching scum tells does not mean I am instantly scum. Please rethink your vote and concentrate your efforts on someone playing scummy and not someone playing poorly.

No. If you want me to unvote then put some effort into the game. Tell me who you think is town and scum and what looks weird and what makes sense and give me SOMETHING to show that you're town who's having a hard time getting into the game instead of a scumbag who thinks he can get through another day without saying anything at all to link him to his scumbuddies later.