Posted: Sun Mar 16, 2008 8:34 am
unvote, vote:pooky
You didn't plan that one out too well. No way he's going to shoot the confirmed town. That's a pure unadultered scumtell.vollkan wrote:I didn't anticipate Pooky killing CKD and throwing up a 50:50.
because I'm sure that I'm going to lose this game because I was an idiot for killing Erg0. Frustration. Pooky did the same damn thing in Lost Boys mafia, and I consider lurking into the scum win to both be a powerful way to achieve victory as well as a cheap way to do it.shaft.ed wrote:Why do you seem so hurried?
The main policy arguments you made against me were that my tight playstyle and use of numbers would suit "volkscum". That doesn't demonstrate in any way that vollkan is scum - only that vollkan has a global playstyle which suits him as scum (and town).Pooky wrote: 1)I do argue against policies i believe to be pro-scum. I don't see what problem you have with that. I made it clear what I thought was scummy and why I thought it was scummy. I'm not sure how you expect me to play that.
I was aware you were not being serious. My point is that you explicitly declined to give reasons BUT when it came to CKD you insisted on more than "just a hunch".wrote: 2) This isn't hypocrisy, I wanted you to tell me why reasons are important day one when most of it is generally crap during day one. I certainly didn't think you'd take me seriously in my stance that reasons were unimportant. It was just one of those things were discussion lets me get an idea of where people are leaning on giving reasons/not giving reasons and the quality of the reasons necesarry for a bandwagon/lynch.
As to my CKD hunch vote thing, I'm always going to want more than just "a hunch" because a hunch is something fairly intangible. Anyone could just say "I had a hunch" or whatever. I want to know what hat hunch is based on, where did you first develop this hunch? was it in a bathroom stall? was it when you read up to line X? do you have anything beyond this hunch? When given the option, I am going to push for more, that's just basic play.
I was desperate for a circuit-breaker and, as I've said, I concocted this nice fantasy of the scum killing me and the town going on to glory. I was wrong, obviously (but, at least this will give me a really good meta rebuttal for any other time I make a mistake ).Pooky wrote: 8. Which is why I couldn't understand why you would fake a daykill in the first place. I didn't understand what type of information you could be fishing for, so I assumed you weren't fishing.
I didn't realize she set that argument up so far in advance. Interesting.vollkan wrote:First suggests that scum will want to concentrate themselves. This really isn’t convincing. I don’t buy the game theory argument she makes (this isn’t a RTS) and it seems to just be a shaky means of arguing that scum are elsewhere – making it a perfect deflective tactic for Adelscum