Mafiascum.net

In post 1297, humaneatingmonkey wrote:Anyway, we're not in MYLO. If this was fake guilty, we can still go after A50. Otherwise, I've resolved all my hesitations. VOTE: boxxy

Think again. Like, what if it's a fake guilty from a monkey?? You'd be executing a TPR and then losing a townie overnight, and then executing the other TPR (that's be me) and then lose another townie at night, and you would be in a 3-2 EyLo already. Wouldn't you??

Let me give you a tip on how to go from here: You use the fact that I didn't even vote my own guilty against me. You push for my lim (and believe me you would have had support from most townies). Then you shoot boxxy at night.

VOTE: HEM

@DWlee: Does this answer your question in 1284??

?

Then why would you, as town, commit to a fake guilty?

So you did you actually target?

What's true is I do believe nom died protecting me (and I feel grateful for it).

Other than that, I checked HEM and got a clear (reminder: my clears are NOT AT ALL clears, and HEM himself outlined why that is).

I believe the plan was to kill me then use my outlined logic (about boxxy being still alive) to push him today. boxxy is still is dangerous for scum to keep alive any longer.

Also true: I don't even remember Kerset having claimed anything, and I can't find it. Did Bambi mean boxxy in VOTE: 1242 or am I going blind?

In post 1303, humaneatingmonkey wrote:So you did you actually target?

Of course I did, but I already knew no matter whom I target I will get a negative. Nobody in this game is capable of killing but has yet to shoot somebody.

Right. UNVOTE: I'll go back to re-reading the game.

In post 1303, humaneatingmonkey wrote:So you did you actually target?

EBWOP: *So who did you actually target?

Even more proof the cannibal is opportunistic. Ready to kill the Detective (The USEFUL PR) based off of Almost. That wasn't even a good lie he did this time.

Honestly the only clear we got is his clear today since scum probably did believe Almost's probable lie of being a PR.

Is there even a question that I'm not absolutely ready to elim boxxy? Because I'm absolutely ready to elim boxxy. I've been clear about that since Day 1. I don't know what you're trying to prove with this. It was a guilty, and if it was a fake guilty, town!A50 will always retract it.

How is there no question to you that boxxy could be fakeclaiming? He claimed Roaming Detective, as you say the "useful PR", and he's still alive today. And if you really think that is, why would scum kill A50 — the invest PR that could easily be evaded? Does that not give you any pause, as town? Sure, he could be left alive because he's gonna get elimmed anyway. But what if he isn't? What do you know about this slot that makes you locktown it so hard?

He wouldn't. That's who he is. He most likely isn't even a PR. Just a VT that tried to bait the shot like I tried with Nom. He claimed a useless PR role so people don't bother him about it. I've done that before too.

He genuinely might've taken the NK last night and was saved by Nom, but he's just a VT. Our actual PR is still in hiding, so don't bother with his claim.

Well, the fourth PR.

We've been so loud yesterday that boxxy and A50 has the same alignment. Why would you think that scum!me would be in a team that would kill A50 — making boxxy a useful confirmed town in our progression?

Wait a50s claim was serious?

scum!me will never belong to a team that would kill A50 because I will never be able to push boxxy, the "useful PR". scum!me will never belong to a team that would kill nomnomnom because I would have him on my pocket.

enough with this narrative.

In post 1308, Bambi Jay wrote:Even more proof the cannibal is opportunistic. Ready to kill the Detective (The USEFUL PR) based off of Almost. That wasn't even a good lie he did this time.

Honestly the only clear we got is his clear today since scum probably did believe Almost's probable lie of being a PR.

Oh, shut up! I've put more effort into this one than the previous one. I've even got the role name right (and without referring to my role PM. mind you)

You didn't kill Nom on purpose. His role literally means he had to die protecting someone.

In post 1313, T3 wrote:Wait a50s claim was serious?

The role: Yes. The result: No.

In post 1316, Bambi Jay wrote:You didn't kill Nom on purpose. His role literally means he had to die protecting someone.

And in this world, Nom would protect A50, right? That's what I'm talking about.

What scum team would want to kill a50 over anyone else? It only makes sense to me if boxxy is evil, but unless mafia is informed of the psychologist, claiming detective would be way too lucky to guess.

again, if the narrative is that I'm trying to line up boxxy for elim today, scum!me will never belong to a team that would kill A50 because I will never be able to push boxxy, the "useful PR". nomnomnom will never protect boxxy either, because he doesn't believe in boxxy either.

Bambi Jay's POV is too non-paranoid for my tastes — almost TMI.

BambiJay, give me your town case on boxxy and Almost50.

HEM why are you so sure a50 was the protect? Or at least not boxxy?

Maybe we should ignore the target because it is very possible nom decided on something overnight that he didn't agree with before he was bodyguard.