Posted: Mon Jul 26, 2021 9:03 pm
In post 1297, geraintm wrote:FN is friendly neighbour i think
It’s starting to feel weird sir, vote me quickly! Then being busy
In post 1297, geraintm wrote:FN is friendly neighbour i think
In post 1299, ManateeDude wrote:In post 1102, ssbm_Kyouko wrote:In post 980, ManateeDude wrote:i can be friendly if need beIn post 982, ManateeDude wrote:@kyouko i trust your judgement here, so give me a little longer to be friendly and it'll do both of us a lot of favoursIn post 998, Roden wrote:I was damn near town locking DGB due to Looker, but that is a good point about DGB's posts. Last game I was with DGB I ended up tunneling them to the point I tried to Vig them, but they also played way differently in that game. They've been extremely inactive and not really trying to make any waves this time around, possibly just coasting on the town read Looker forged for them. Re-evaluating Looker again, I also remember thinking they were trying to look scummy on purpose. It made me think they were either too scummy to be scummy and maybe had a PR, or they were gambitting we would assume TSTBS. I should've had them null in my reads list tbh.
I think I'm actually fine with this wagon.
VOTE: DrippingGoofballWonderfriends unite!In post 1015, MathBlade wrote:VOTE: DGB
Ditto.
Oh and not sure if anyone saw a recent WWF ad? It’s so cute I just have to share it.
Show love to people <3
Not sure if dwlee or omo comes first.
Wonderfriend manatee, what do you think?
In post 1302, ManateeDude wrote:targeting babysitter is dangerous no matter what and im of the belief mafia missed my soft
I'm not sure if they make sense - not because I suspect her answer, but because I don't understand the conversation that was going on with the Demi Lovato songs, even with the explanation. I'm assuming the one you posted was meant to be some kind of question, but I don't understand the question, even with the context of Titus's explanation of what her answers meant.In post 1230, MathBlade wrote:Well I kinda have to touch at what I was saying and it does involve Manatee but only what she has already claimed not what I think she likely did.In post 1229, ssbm_Kyouko wrote:I did not find what you showed Titus, but I dont want anything more out because i thought it was to do with Manatee, but I think if I didnt find it that it wasn't to do with her so let's leave it alone.In post 1227, MathBlade wrote:Off topic:In post 1224, ssbm_Kyouko wrote:Not a reads list no, not really. And that's fair enough, I know we all 3 were voting Titus and I think saudade was first to it, but I dont recall which of us went there first.
4-5 pages is hardly "a couple posts", but what do you think that means for marci?
1139 feels like a start from you at least. Why dont you think omo will flip scum as of your 1106?
I just clocked out and am heading to my personal PC. I was abrupt earlier with some answers because lunch break. I have some questions for you when I get there did you want me to expand further or did you get what you needed?
On topic:
Iirc it was you (will double check in a moment) you were suspicious of Titus’s babysit claim but it makes sense to me. Can you expand on that? I am trying to figure out if Titus’s recent answer unsettled me because she’s scum or it unsettled me because of a misunderstanding in the moment.
Yes it was me. Do you want me to expand on my suspicion, or what I thought of Titus's answer? Or something else?
What I want to ask is if you think her responds with the songs etc make sense in combination with babysitting Manatee or not.
So both? Expand on the suspicion and Titus’s answer.
I want to combine that with some of Dwlee’s responses. I think what they are saying is incongruent and I kinda wanna see what’s what.
The protect was about the day play. I don't recall there being anything spectacular about Manatee's day play. To my recollection, she didn't ever make her own case, always built on others's cases. Not sheeping, but never making something entirely new either. She was also flexible it seemed. I've heard of protects being useful on town players that are hard to persuade, because the only thing scum can do to stop those players is night kill them, but this doesn't resonate with me. I feel like, for the risk to seem worthwhile, there has to be something particular that stands out about the day play, given the situation.In post 1186, Titus wrote:Manatee was a widely suspected slot. I wanted it to be alive to correct the beliefs about themselves or worst case he'd die and it would be dispelled.In post 1152, ssbm_Kyouko wrote:@Titus, why did you choose to babysit Manatee? What was the thought process?The protect was about the day play. I knew the risk and did it anyway.
Not both of you, but one of you, possibly.In post 1270, Salsabil Faria wrote:In post 1135, ssbm_Kyouko wrote:Nothing in particular right now, but you, geraintm, and Not_Mafia were notably distanced from the DGB wagon by a lack of interaction, and either of your self-votes, or geraintm's vote against you for self-voting, could be construed as ways to keep yourselves off of the DGB wagon because you hoped it would disband like the other wagons of the day.In post 1118, Salsabil Faria wrote:In post 1111, ssbm_Kyouko wrote:conftown
voters that were on the end of day DGB wagon and are not confirmed
confscum
Left myself yellow for everyone's convenience
Votecount 1:
DrippingGoofball(3):marcistar,ManateeDude,Titus
Titus(2):Roden,ssbm_Kyouko
omo(2):MathBlade, MaxTheFox
ssbm_Kyouko(1): Dwlee99
Salsabil Faria (1): geraintm
geraintm (1): Salsabil Faria
MaxTheFox (1):omo
Not_Mafia (1): Not_Mafia
Votecount 2:
DrippingGoofball(4):marcistar,ManateeDude,Titus,ssbm_Kyouko
omo(2): MaxTheFox, Salsabil Faria
MaxTheFox (2):MathBlade, Dwlee99
Titus(1);Roden
Salsabil Faria (1): geraintm
Not_Mafia (1): Not_Mafia
marcistar(1):omo
Votecount 3:
omo(4): MaxTheFox, Salsabil Faria,DrippingGoofball,MathBlade
Roden(4):ssbm_Kyouko,omo, Dwlee99,ManateeDude
DrippingGoofball(2):marcistar,Titus
Salsabil Faria (1): geraintm
Not_Mafia (1): Not_Mafia
ManateeDude(1):Roden
Votecount 4:
Dwlee99 (4): Salsabil Faria,ssbm_Kyouko,Titus,ManateeDude
ManateeDude(2):omo, Dwlee99
omo(2): MaxTheFox,DrippingGoofball
DrippingGoofball(1):marcistar
Salsabil Faria (1): geraintm
Not_Mafia (1): Not_Mafia
marcistar(1):Roden
Votecount 5:
marcistar(5):Roden,ssbm_Kyouko, Salsabil Faria,omo,DrippingGoofball
omo(3): MaxTheFox,ManateeDude,MathBlade
ManateeDude(1): Dwlee99
Dwlee99 (1):Titus
DrippingGoofball(1):marcistar
Salsabil Faria (1): geraintm
Not_Mafia (1): Not_Mafia
Votecount 6:
marcistar(4):Roden,ssbm_Kyouko, Salsabil Faria,omo,MathBlade(MathBlade added to the Marci wagon in this VC quote because they voted Marci shortly afterward and were on the wagon at its height)
omo(2): MaxTheFox,MathBlade
ManateeDude(1): Dwlee99
Dwlee99 (1):Titus
DrippingGoofball(1):marcistar
Salsabil Faria (1): geraintm
Votecount 7:
DrippingGoofball(4):marcistar,ssbm_Kyouko,ManateeDude,Roden
Salsabil Faria (2): geraintm, Salsabil Fariua
marcistar(1):MathBlade
omo(1): MaxTheFox
ManateeDude(1): Dwlee99
Dwlee99 (1):Titus
Not_Mafia (1): Not_Mafia
Roden(1):DrippingGoofball
Votecount 8:
DrippingGoofball(7):marcistar,ssbm_Kyouko,ManateeDude,Roden,Titus,MathBlade,omo
Roden(2):DrippingGoofball, Dwlee99
Salsabil Faria (2): geraintm, Salsabil Faria
omo(1): MaxTheFox
Not_Mafia (1): Not_Mafia
Key notes I take from this are that Titus and Marci were on DGB slot early in the day and that when Marci was a wagon, Titus was not on board. I think if there was a bus on D1, it was in omo/MathBlade. Titus was also on the dwlee wagon, and although this is pre-flip, I do think this points further toward town!Titus. MathBlade's reason to vote DGB was "Ditto" that of Titus'. Titus states she TRs everyone on the wagon. This is in line with her play throughout the day. MathBlade, however, was on the Marcistar wagon so I'm going to look back at how he got off of that wagon, because he did pile on to the Marci wagon late and with little reasoning iirc.
I'm locking Marci and Titus for now. Killing Roden could be trying to frame dwlee. Max, geraintm, Salsabil, and Not_Mafia all have weak voting histories D1 and should be inspected toMorrow at the latest. And the points against omo/dwlee/DGB voting patterns still stand.I've no problem, what do you want to know?
I was pissed of and wanted to replace out but also I didn’t want to take any decision out of rage, so to cool myself off, I took a break. And my self-vote meant f*** y'all.As scum, I usually look for towncred.
Do you really think me and the decorating guy are scums???
FN is friendly neighbor and in case you or anyone else missed it I received a pm last night confirming that Manatee is town.In post 1273, Salsabil Faria wrote:In post 1152, ssbm_Kyouko wrote:I'm not sure I agree with Titus's babysit. Not that it's scummy to defend manatee but I would be afraid that i would get shot because a) I'm a claimed babysitter and b) the target I was looking at babysitting was essentially a claimed FN. I would expect scum to shoot me and i wouldn't want to let scum kill 2 PRs with 1 shot.In post 1126, MathBlade wrote:Ditto with work.In post 1122, Titus wrote:I babysat ManateeDude last night. Got work. Will try to post tonight.
I have like 0.002% doubt of Titus’s claim and imho she should be treated as conf town even though she is not dead. I think she saw what I was trying to tell her and why Roden probably died. I am not sure how to explain it though without outing really nice snuggly PRs that you bring sugar and spice to.
I think Titus’s babysit was a really good move.
Btw I see what you’re getting at ssbm but as scum I 100% tunnel a certain player for cred here who is pretty much an open PR and force them to claim and then put Titus in a dilemma of if they protect the PR or not.
I had known that this other player was a PR for a while and had been trying not to talk about them.
I guess the idea is if manatee was lying she's scum and if I get shot I take scum with me, but its risky when manatee can clear herself the next morning anyways. If anything, I would wait to babysit manatee until N2, if the person manatee claims to have FNed N1 died N1, or if they FNed a possible buddy like marcistar.What is FN?
It seems that way but it could easily be scum thatIn post 1302, ManateeDude wrote:targeting babysitter is dangerous no matter what and im of the belief mafia missed my soft
I agree with like 90% of your prior wall post. I still think if there is a deep wolf they could kill Roden here. Saying more or why stops what I am hunting for.In post 1313, ssbm_Kyouko wrote:It seems that way but it could easily be scum thatIn post 1302, ManateeDude wrote:targeting babysitter is dangerous no matter what and im of the belief mafia missed my softignoredyour crumb to make it appear that they missed it.
Missed the crumb:
{Max (newb), Salsa (English as a second language), Not_Mafia (not_reading)}
Ignored the crumb:
{Dwlee, omo, Titus, MathBlade}
Marci/Geraint, I don't feel confident putting them in either category. Either way, I think if one scum missed the crumb they both did.
pedit: these wagons are giving me the spooks. omo and dwlee voting together, and Max and Salsa voting together, cross-voting
TvS wagons I think.
UNVOTE:
1. I already mentioned in the original post that if 1 scum missed the crumb, they both missed it. I thought it was implied that I understood that if 1 scum missed it and he other saw it that they would discuss the crumb in the pt.In post 1314, MathBlade wrote:I agree with like 90% of your prior wall post. I still think if there is a deep wolf they could kill Roden here. Saying more or why stops what I am hunting for.In post 1313, ssbm_Kyouko wrote:It seems that way but it could easily be scum thatIn post 1302, ManateeDude wrote:targeting babysitter is dangerous no matter what and im of the belief mafia missed my softignoredyour crumb to make it appear that they missed it.
Missed the crumb:
{Max (newb), Salsa (English as a second language), Not_Mafia (not_reading)}
Ignored the crumb:
{Dwlee, omo, Titus, MathBlade}
Marci/Geraint, I don't feel confident putting them in either category. Either way, I think if one scum missed the crumb they both did.
pedit: these wagons are giving me the spooks. omo and dwlee voting together, and Max and Salsa voting together, cross-voting
TvS wagons I think.
UNVOTE:
This post however I find very “off”.
I don’t really think there should be a “missed” or “ignored” category.
Assume Faria is scum. Their buddy could have seen the crumb and interacted with it and then Faria posts asking what a Friendly Neighbor is.
Two, assume I am scum (incorrectly) you can’t seriously tell me that I would be in the ignore column when I have a post telling Titus who claimed babysitter to look at post 45 (which has town buddies -> common FN crumb, page 40 the “friendly” and page 41 where I post a WWF video that has protecting Manatees midway through. Like you could argue I am in the ignore category but you really would need a third category for deliberate manipulation here.
Three, the more I think about it the more I don’t like this sort at all. We don’t know who the scum are or what they are thinking yet. Using the Roden kill I could paint almost anyone as scum. But I think we learn more from who scum push.
Four, why are these wagons that stalled TvS yet you’re treating the D1 wagons with Marci and Manatee as TvT?
Fifth, I am pretty unsatisfied with your answer. You seem like a deep player. I get gut vibes Titus is town but a lot better argument Titus is scum is that she argued protecting Manatee was about day claim yet she says she saw the FN crumbs after I pointed them out and was “taking a risk” making her answer about day play wrong or her answers about the video are wrong.
I think we have played before. Maybe you replaced into a game I was in. I can post my games when I get back to PC from a notepad I keep on them.In post 1315, MathBlade wrote:How much experience do you have Kyouko? And why do I get the feeling I have played with you before?
I am still trying to sort you so I'm engaging you as though you are town so we can talk through thought processes and I can decide if yours are real or not. I think Titus is town, but I think you are suspicious of her, so it behooves me to try to see it from your pov in case I am missing something. If you're both town, in doing this I can also hopefully get you to agree Titus is town and strengthen the core. I am seeing things from your POV that I did not notice the first time. I am concerned that you see my posting as shading though, when it is clear that 1) your questions are leading, and 2) I am having a discussion about the validity of her claim, not trying to case her or shade her. It would do us no good to have this discussion if we weren't going to explore the possibility that she was lying.In post 1316, MathBlade wrote:And also why are you continually shading Titus yet never voting her?
It’s giving me major pings.
I think you played with me once a long time ago. I took a long site break but I have only two accounts, this and an alt that I only played under the influence on, and as I don't smoke or drink anymore I haven't played the account since return from my site break. I suppose it doesn't matter if it's out at this point - "Big Lungs DK".In post 1315, MathBlade wrote:How much experience do you have Kyouko? And why do I get the feeling I have played with you before?
In post 1111, ssbm_Kyouko wrote:conftown
voters that were on the end of day DGB wagon and are not confirmed
confscum
Left myself yellow for everyone's convenience
Votecount 1:
DrippingGoofball(3):marcistar,ManateeDude,Titus
Titus(2):Roden,ssbm_Kyouko
omo(2):MathBlade, MaxTheFox
ssbm_Kyouko(1): Dwlee99
Salsabil Faria (1): geraintm
geraintm (1): Salsabil Faria
MaxTheFox (1):omo
Not_Mafia (1): Not_Mafia
Votecount 2:
DrippingGoofball(4):marcistar,ManateeDude,Titus,ssbm_Kyouko
omo(2): MaxTheFox, Salsabil Faria
MaxTheFox (2):MathBlade, Dwlee99
Titus(1);Roden
Salsabil Faria (1): geraintm
Not_Mafia (1): Not_Mafia
marcistar(1):omo
Votecount 3:
omo(4): MaxTheFox, Salsabil Faria,DrippingGoofball,MathBlade
Roden(4):ssbm_Kyouko,omo, Dwlee99,ManateeDude
DrippingGoofball(2):marcistar,Titus
Salsabil Faria (1): geraintm
Not_Mafia (1): Not_Mafia
ManateeDude(1):Roden
Votecount 4:
Dwlee99 (4): Salsabil Faria,ssbm_Kyouko,Titus,ManateeDude
ManateeDude(2):omo, Dwlee99
omo(2): MaxTheFox,DrippingGoofball
DrippingGoofball(1):marcistar
Salsabil Faria (1): geraintm
Not_Mafia (1): Not_Mafia
marcistar(1):Roden
Votecount 5:
marcistar(5):Roden,ssbm_Kyouko, Salsabil Faria,omo,DrippingGoofball
omo(3): MaxTheFox,ManateeDude,MathBlade
ManateeDude(1): Dwlee99
Dwlee99 (1):Titus
DrippingGoofball(1):marcistar
Salsabil Faria (1): geraintm
Not_Mafia (1): Not_Mafia
Votecount 6:
marcistar(4):Roden,ssbm_Kyouko, Salsabil Faria,omo,MathBlade(MathBlade added to the Marci wagon in this VC quote because they voted Marci shortly afterward and were on the wagon at its height)
omo(2): MaxTheFox,MathBlade
ManateeDude(1): Dwlee99
Dwlee99 (1):Titus
DrippingGoofball(1):marcistar
Salsabil Faria (1): geraintm
Votecount 7:
DrippingGoofball(4):marcistar,ssbm_Kyouko,ManateeDude,Roden
Salsabil Faria (2): geraintm, Salsabil Fariua
marcistar(1):MathBlade
omo(1): MaxTheFox
ManateeDude(1): Dwlee99
Dwlee99 (1):Titus
Not_Mafia (1): Not_Mafia
Roden(1):DrippingGoofball
Votecount 8:
DrippingGoofball(7):marcistar,ssbm_Kyouko,ManateeDude,Roden,Titus,MathBlade,omo
Roden(2):DrippingGoofball, Dwlee99
Salsabil Faria (2): geraintm, Salsabil Faria
omo(1): MaxTheFox
Not_Mafia (1): Not_Mafia
Key notes I take from this are that Titus and Marci were on DGB slot early in the day and that when Marci was a wagon, Titus was not on board. I think if there was a bus on D1, it was in omo/MathBlade. Titus was also on the dwlee wagon, and although this is pre-flip, I do think this points further toward town!Titus. MathBlade's reason to vote DGB was "Ditto" that of Titus'. Titus states she TRs everyone on the wagon. This is in line with her play throughout the day. MathBlade, however, was on the Marcistar wagon so I'm going to look back at how he got off of that wagon, because he did pile on to the Marci wagon late and with little reasoning iirc.
I'm locking Marci and Titus for now. Killing Roden could be trying to frame dwlee. Max, geraintm, Salsabil, and Not_Mafia all have weak voting histories D1 and should be inspected toMorrow at the latest. And the points against omo/dwlee/DGB voting patterns still stand.