1. NDMath
2. Taroumaru
3. Enchant
4. Titus
5. Skybird
6. Pooky
7. Yuki
8. Gamma Emerald
9. A50
10. Ari
11. Radical Rat
12. Dwlee99
13. Morning Tweet
Dwlee's posting EoD1 is something i liked which compounds with the role claim and their surprise at ppl thinking they would fakeclaim it. I've gone over that i agree with RR a ton and I want to say the wagons are +town for RR assuming my scumreads are closer to right than not
I find it more likely im missing something on skybird and they're town as opposed to titus being town
But I find ND/Tarou actively suspicious and Enchant i regularly forget is here and i at least have vouching for titus. ND i went over, Tarou is less actively bad per se more easily fakable. I also recall not liking their vote patterns
I have no idea how to read unwnd or pooky but he's so gosh darn cute so he has t hat going for him
Why am I middle-of-the-road if you think I’m outside my scumrange?
In post 1262, Morning Tweet wrote:
Tarou and ND are both a little below nullscum for me since i found their stances sort of convenient for scum although i obviously only put as much stock in that as i can for a D2 in a game like this.
In post 811, NDMath wrote:Am feeling better about the Ari vote than I was earlier but still would prefer RR.
I'll be back a little before deadline in case nothing's hammered by then but the situation appears it'll be under control.
it doesn't feel like you were particularly concerned which wagon died -- which fits with my idea that most or all were town. Which also makes sense with how most of the game is low impact, i expect scum could get away with leading wagons easier.
Hey we're to the fake Inno on Ari. Originally I was like "okay well scum followed the vote without caring, why?" -- I am thinking it's because there's scum in the voters and both wagons were town. I guess that's not an earth shattering conclusion though but it makes sense given it seems this game is super fucking slow and people can plausibly be like "Whatever we just need to get something thru" without questioning much
I think if there were more town on RR there'd be a "Bullshit no way" response. Or if Ari were town and RR!scum there'd also have been a bullshit no way. But.. there wasn't.
At that point in time it seemed like Ari was for sure gonna die, being at seven votes and deadline very soon. It didn't seem like an awful outcome I guess, and I'm just not someone capable of persuading half the game.
I'm not comprehending why "if there was more town on RR matters"? I also disagree with the town!Ari and scum!RR conclusion in that DotW was both the second largest wagon and the wagon people switched to.
In post 811, NDMath wrote:Am feeling better about the Ari vote than I was earlier but still would prefer RR.
I'm confused by this statement ND. You were voting RR at the time, not Ari. But the statement almost sounds like your vote was on Ari. Can you talk about this?
the Ari vote as in the wagon occurring on Ari.
Still prefer RR as in I'm not switching my vote from RR to Ari.
But at the time you made post 811, the Ari wagon was gone. Vote count 1.13 was posted 12 hours before your post and it shows there was no Ari wagon.
If I didn't know better I would consider this a malicious lie.
In post 1262, Morning Tweet wrote:
Tarou and ND are both a little below nullscum for me since i found their stances sort of convenient for scum although i obviously only put as much stock in that as i can for a D2 in a game like this.
In post 811, NDMath wrote:Am feeling better about the Ari vote than I was earlier but still would prefer RR.
I'll be back a little before deadline in case nothing's hammered by then but the situation appears it'll be under control.
it doesn't feel like you were particularly concerned which wagon died -- which fits with my idea that most or all were town. Which also makes sense with how most of the game is low impact, i expect scum could get away with leading wagons easier.
Hey we're to the fake Inno on Ari. Originally I was like "okay well scum followed the vote without caring, why?" -- I am thinking it's because there's scum in the voters and both wagons were town. I guess that's not an earth shattering conclusion though but it makes sense given it seems this game is super fucking slow and people can plausibly be like "Whatever we just need to get something thru" without questioning much
I think if there were more town on RR there'd be a "Bullshit no way" response. Or if Ari were town and RR!scum there'd also have been a bullshit no way. But.. there wasn't.
At that point in time it seemed like Ari was for sure gonna die, being at seven votes and deadline very soon. It didn't seem like an awful outcome I guess, and I'm just not someone capable of persuading half the game.
I'm not comprehending why "if there was more town on RR matters"? I also disagree with the town!Ari and scum!RR conclusion in that DotW was both the second largest wagon and the wagon people switched to.
In post 811, NDMath wrote:Am feeling better about the Ari vote than I was earlier but still would prefer RR.
I'm confused by this statement ND. You were voting RR at the time, not Ari. But the statement almost sounds like your vote was on Ari. Can you talk about this?
the Ari vote as in the wagon occurring on Ari.
Still prefer RR as in I'm not switching my vote from RR to Ari.
But at the time you made post 811, the Ari wagon was gone. Vote count 1.13 was posted 12 hours before your post and it shows there was no Ari wagon.
If I didn't know better I would consider this a malicious lie.
In post 1262, Morning Tweet wrote:
Tarou and ND are both a little below nullscum for me since i found their stances sort of convenient for scum although i obviously only put as much stock in that as i can for a D2 in a game like this.
In post 811, NDMath wrote:Am feeling better about the Ari vote than I was earlier but still would prefer RR.
I'll be back a little before deadline in case nothing's hammered by then but the situation appears it'll be under control.
it doesn't feel like you were particularly concerned which wagon died -- which fits with my idea that most or all were town. Which also makes sense with how most of the game is low impact, i expect scum could get away with leading wagons easier.
Hey we're to the fake Inno on Ari. Originally I was like "okay well scum followed the vote without caring, why?" -- I am thinking it's because there's scum in the voters and both wagons were town. I guess that's not an earth shattering conclusion though but it makes sense given it seems this game is super fucking slow and people can plausibly be like "Whatever we just need to get something thru" without questioning much
I think if there were more town on RR there'd be a "Bullshit no way" response. Or if Ari were town and RR!scum there'd also have been a bullshit no way. But.. there wasn't.
At that point in time it seemed like Ari was for sure gonna die, being at seven votes and deadline very soon. It didn't seem like an awful outcome I guess, and I'm just not someone capable of persuading half the game.
I'm not comprehending why "if there was more town on RR matters"? I also disagree with the town!Ari and scum!RR conclusion in that DotW was both the second largest wagon and the wagon people switched to.
In post 811, NDMath wrote:Am feeling better about the Ari vote than I was earlier but still would prefer RR.
I'm confused by this statement ND. You were voting RR at the time, not Ari. But the statement almost sounds like your vote was on Ari. Can you talk about this?
the Ari vote as in the wagon occurring on Ari.
Still prefer RR as in I'm not switching my vote from RR to Ari.
But at the time you made post 811, the Ari wagon was gone. Vote count 1.13 was posted 12 hours before your post and it shows there was no Ari wagon.
If I didn't know better I would consider this a malicious lie.
1. NDMath
2. Taroumaru
3. Enchant
4. Titus
5. Skybird
6. Pooky
7. Yuki
8. Gamma Emerald
9. A50
10. Ari
11. Radical Rat
12. Dwlee99
13. Morning Tweet
Dwlee's posting EoD1 is something i liked which compounds with the role claim and their surprise at ppl thinking they would fakeclaim it. I've gone over that i agree with RR a ton and I want to say the wagons are +town for RR assuming my scumreads are closer to right than not
I find it more likely im missing something on skybird and they're town as opposed to titus being town
But I find ND/Tarou actively suspicious and Enchant i regularly forget is here and i at least have vouching for titus. ND i went over, Tarou is less actively bad per se more easily fakable. I also recall not liking their vote patterns
I have no idea how to read unwnd or pooky but he's so gosh darn cute so he has t hat going for him
Why am I middle-of-the-road if you think I’m outside my scumrange?
You're relatively kind of high. i dont have the familiarity others do and i wasnt yet sure my interpretation that you're obvious town was correct. RR has affirmed to me this is true though
I would probably put the cut-off line in between you and Yuki. Although Yuki is in a similar category so maybe above Yuki.
I think out of you/a50/yuki/mayyyybe ari i have max 1 wrong
In post 1262, Morning Tweet wrote:
Tarou and ND are both a little below nullscum for me since i found their stances sort of convenient for scum although i obviously only put as much stock in that as i can for a D2 in a game like this.
In post 811, NDMath wrote:Am feeling better about the Ari vote than I was earlier but still would prefer RR.
I'll be back a little before deadline in case nothing's hammered by then but the situation appears it'll be under control.
it doesn't feel like you were particularly concerned which wagon died -- which fits with my idea that most or all were town. Which also makes sense with how most of the game is low impact, i expect scum could get away with leading wagons easier.
Hey we're to the fake Inno on Ari. Originally I was like "okay well scum followed the vote without caring, why?" -- I am thinking it's because there's scum in the voters and both wagons were town. I guess that's not an earth shattering conclusion though but it makes sense given it seems this game is super fucking slow and people can plausibly be like "Whatever we just need to get something thru" without questioning much
I think if there were more town on RR there'd be a "Bullshit no way" response. Or if Ari were town and RR!scum there'd also have been a bullshit no way. But.. there wasn't.
At that point in time it seemed like Ari was for sure gonna die, being at seven votes and deadline very soon. It didn't seem like an awful outcome I guess, and I'm just not someone capable of persuading half the game.
I'm not comprehending why "if there was more town on RR matters"? I also disagree with the town!Ari and scum!RR conclusion in that DotW was both the second largest wagon and the wagon people switched to.
while you were voting Kop and RR got put to X-1 you were complacent with RR being lolhammered -- you also were fine with Dragon and I believe Ari. My point being that you don't seem to have a horse in the race. compare that to Dwlee end of day arguing with A50 and the dragon voters, I find it comes off better.
Whiteknighting is a thing too i suppose but that's usually something i invoke when i think the defense is bad or unfounded. Dwlee scrutinizing A50 was something i expected a lot more of and was understandable
Yeah I see the RR voters had already switched off now, I had that wrong.
Posted: Thu Oct 21, 2021 5:32 am
by Morning Tweet
oh yeah and Gamma i don't actually know for a fact you're out of scumrange im just taking other's words for it which puts you more on par with Yuki/A50 than with my higher reads
i guess if i were being more diligent i'd investigate but that's not happening. If down the line this game gets more serious i'll review the players whose posts i glossed over more and get stronger reads than "this is consensus"
Posted: Thu Oct 21, 2021 5:41 am
by Titus
VOTE: NDMath
Posted: Thu Oct 21, 2021 8:29 am
by Skybird
Titus, thoughts on NDmath?
Pooky's timer has runout. Next post will be my ranking list.