Mafiascum.net

I unlocked the thread to be able to edit the OP.

The night felt longer than usual, but that might have had something to do with the town's inability to sleep. Sometime right around sunrise, a scream was heard. Everyone came out of the safety of their houses, but it was too late to save Sotty7 or to catch the perpetrator of the evil act which had claimed her life. She was stabbed repeatedly, notably once through the heart, which was probably the first wound as only one scream was heard... the rest must have been out of some sick twisted pleasure from her murderer. Anybody could be next... even you. If that's not some motivation to get things right... I don't know what is.

Sotty7 killed night 3.

Day 4 Phase 1 begins.

Not Voting: (Equinox, I Am Innocent, Percy, Furcolow, JasonT1981, Thor665, Benmage)

With 7 alive it's 4 to lynch

Deadline for both phases of day 4 is Tuesday, January 11th at 10am CST

And I am out of suspects after this one.

I'm not

It was entirely plausible Percy from the getgo sought to bus Baby Spice, a horrendously weak player, for easy town cred....The whole LRDvsBS is his #1 suspect he unvotes crap was him messing up going "oh god just me on D2".... Then he realized he couldn't logically switch with all the crap I was giving him and he went back, knowing BS was gonna go eventually and he'd have to pull this out on his own nonetheless.

I'm town. You're out of suspects.

Constructing the voting spreadsheet for this game was no small feat. I never knew that one person could hop votes so damned much. Grumbling aside, I spent too many hours on this thing, so I actually haven't done any reading here. I'll get to that momentarily.

A bit of irony: Someone on Day 2 or so complained that the wagon on Percy built too fast. For all of the phases following that, you guys couldn't get Percy lynched. That wagon is the most difficult wagon I've ever seen.

For what it's worth, I don't think it's Percy. From what I gathered while skimming for votes, Percy's been getting plenty of hate. Scum needs to manipulate 4 lynches; that's plenty intimidating for anyone. I don't think Percy would kill one of the few players who supported him.

I'll decide once I've caught up, I suppose.

Equinox wrote:I don't think Percy would kill one of the few players who supported him.

Damnit, why does that have to make sense...Okay so Sotty called thor scum..I never like the Nikspot, I just couldn't imagine my buddy Nik replacing out on a scum role.

Also the elmo/nul/equinox slot...i'm sorry can't imo be scum...So his vote is bad.

Sigh*

Thor665 wrote:And I am out of suspects after this one.

This does not feel like the last scum to me. They would be setting up multiple lynches, not cornering themselves with one last suspect.

Equinox wrote:I'm town. You're out of suspects.

First of all, hi Equinox!

Second of all, this still seems more relevant to me...

Equinox wrote:For all of the phases following that, you guys couldn't get Percy lynched. That wagon is the most difficult wagon I've ever seen.

...than this:

Equinox wrote:Scum needs to manipulate 4 lynches; that's plenty intimidating for anyone. I don't think Percy would kill one of the few players who supported him.

Who should scum Percy have lynched? Me? The only other person constantly pushing his lynch. WIFOM imo.

KD died, and he strongly felt Percy should be the next lynch. Now that he is gone, I am the lone player "constantly" pushing it now. Jasont and Ben have been off and on it, but I don't think scum Percy would be scared of just me right now.

gonna go with my gut instincts here with Percy, I have been on and off him all game. this time he cant live.

L-1

So I have a chest infection and nowhere near enough mindspace to do this shit all over again.

I'm town, and I hate every single one of you on my wagon. Please go die in a fire.

My strongest town reads are on jason, Furcolow and Benmage. That leaves Equinox, Thor and IAI.

I just flicked through IAI and still think he's town. Something about his attitude towards the two known scum seems genuine.

. Elmo/Nul seemed town to me, and Thor is left over by PoE.

I'm still willing to vote thor...I'm happy with either...if we miss on Percy I'll be gunning for Thor, and vica versa...They are MY final two suspects.

sorry, percy, but we have another phase... and if you make it to lylo town will pretty much auto-lynch you if you're town
which would suck

i just found sotty7 being way more suspicious of thor than percy
i don't see why percy would have killed sotty
well, i can see a few reasons:
1) sotty is a good player
2) WIFOM

but the problem is that someone recently said something similar to "why would percy get rid of someone who won't lynch him and is town"... it just doesn't make sense.
After reading this, I expect a town flip.


I am town, but lynching someone like me or jason next cycle really wouldn't be that bad of an idea. I am fairly certain we can win this, but it could potentially be lylo tomorrow..

The problem is, though, with 6, the voting is going to be klunky.
5v1 -> lynch
4v1 -> nightkill
3v1 -> lynch
2v1 -> lylo

5v1 -> no lynch
5v1 -> night kill
4v1 -> no lynch
4v1 -> no lynch
4v1 -> nightkill
3v1 -> lynch
2v1 -> lynch (lylo)

i know this is a weird suggestion, but what if we just continue talking for deadlines upon deadlines, no lynching
i know we would lose a lynch in the bottom scenario, but we could gain over an extra month of deliberation

p.s. hoping percy flips scum tho

Final vote count of day 4 phase 1



Percy is shocked as the town quickly points their fingers at him and rush him onto the CONTRAPTION OF DOOM, and quickly push the button before he can even so much as get off a "It's not me." He goes screaming to his death, with the ensuing search of his home and belonging confirming his innocence.

Percy lynched day 4 Phase 1

BEGIN PHASE TWO!

Not Voting: (Equinox, Thor665, I Am Innocent, JasonT1981, Benmage, Furcolow)

With 6 alive it's 4 to lynch

Deadline for both phases of day 4 is Tuesday, January 11th at 10am CST

Furcolow wrote:

sorry, percy, but we have another phase

... and if you make it to lylo town will pretty much auto-lynch you if you're town
which would suck

this is interesting.. if he was scum we would NOT have had another phase....

percy has been a town read all game, he is just a liability at this point

yeah, i'm gonna hammer him as scum durrrrr
scum are way more cautious than that
town are generally more reckless
i guess you weren't aware of that

Baby Spice wrote:

Elmo is so obv town that he should be in the dictionary for it.

i just re-read all of babyspice
she even had dry-fit in her scum suspects early on
the way she continued with him, i have a few potential suspects for the last scum

I give up.

I've tried to write this post times now. Each attempt resulted in something that would break General Rule 7, go against my win condition, and/or result in language unfitting for a PG-13 rating. This post probably still violates the third condition, but I'm done trying to edit.

Therefore, I'll settle for this.



Please and thank you.