Posted: Tue Apr 29, 2014 2:58 am
scouts honor?
https://forum.mafiascum-staging.net/
Here's my issue. This role is like the ultimate in role fishing. The role is hardly believable with such a tracker/role cop part built it. You were getting strung up by the time it was brought out so I can't help but wonder if your role is an absolute last ditch effort to get more information for your team.In post 1230, SMP wrote:Correct. All I got was that he's a vanilla who didn't do anything last night.In post 1229, Antihero wrote:jake actually would have been a better one
@mara: because kdub already claimed non-vanilla. but actually, now that jake mentions it, he would have been better; if SMP got a "non-vanilla, no action" result, that would have cleared jake.
p.edit: well, wait a second, doesn't your "result" just say that he's vanilla? according to that, he could still be a scum goon and just not have done the kill.
I dislike the attempt at mod meta-ing as well, seeing as in every game with bork I've come across some different styles of roles, especially for scum.In post 1304, Antihero wrote:i'm trying to play the game, jake.In post 1285, Jake from State Farm wrote:stop trying to guess or out guess the mod and play the game, that's twice now and it never works.
i blocked SMP because i figured scum would send their most heavily suspcted scumbag to do the kill (so that they wouldn't lose much if they were caught out by a tracker/watcher/roleblocker).
assuming 10 town vs 3 scum (standard for minis), there was a 1/9 chance that a hypothetical scumroleblocker targeted me (additionally, we have to assume that the scum's roleblock resolves before mine).
SMP is scummy and, even assuming a mafia roleblocker, i like my 8/9 odds. i'm going with it.
because i've never faked a guilty on someone just to get them lynched and faking guilties on people just because of "suspicion" is stupid. and given that i've never done that in my time on the site, it's scummy you would suggest that.In post 1352, Aj The Epic wrote:Anti, since your claiming a blocker role, why SHOULD we believe this is any more than a ploy to get him lynched? All I've gotten from you so far is you'll do anything you can to get the people you have the slightest suspicion on lynched. Why wouldn't you have RB'd me or Kdub, the two you were vehemently against?
So vote me big boyIn post 1353, Mac wrote:yesIn post 1346, zMuffinMan wrote:is mac scum
so is everyone not named Jake
In the early part of day 1 we thought Mac was town. His late day 1 shook that.In post 1357, zMuffinMan wrote:i think AJ and mac are scum
should i read the first 48 pages to confirm this?
In post 1359, sangres wrote:In the early part of day 1 we thought Mac was town. His late day 1 shook that.In post 1357, zMuffinMan wrote:i think AJ and mac are scum
should i read the first 48 pages to confirm this?
AJ yeah. Everything he posts reads a little bit awkward somehow.
Aegor's lolnoreasons trolling on day 1 was pretty disturbing.
I think 2 scum in that bunch. Aegor is probably playing too dont-give-a-fuck to be scum though.
oh, so antihero's not totally full of shit and AJ is scum?In post 1361, Jake from State Farm wrote:Aj bothers me because he posts every couple of days and says just enough to get by but doesn't really involve himself in the game or interact with anyone on a continuous basis. For example his last post looks like filler and I don't see anything pro-active from him.
i'd be ok with an AJ lynch for the simple fact that he doesn't look like he's helping anyone find scum
I generally agree with this.In post 1362, zMuffinMan wrote:SMP is probably a smarter lynch today. maybe. dunno
btw if SMP is actually town, i'm pretty near conf-town unless you think (a) i'm a goon (which seems rather unlikely if this is 10:3 given how power-heavy town seems to be), and (b) i performed no action last night (which would mean one of the other scum players - who would probably have a PR of sorts - performed the kill instead)
so SMP lynch either results in scum flip or me near conf-town so yeah
the fact SMP isn't really doing anything probably means scum flip though but whatevs