Mafiascum.net

I still don’t really understand how you think Dunn pocketed me either that was really contrived

The scumteam lies within geraintm, stungun, dunnstral, bob, and tato.

part one is relationship between geraintm and stungun early day. There's a little banter, a little theory craft, and a little distancing. It connected them in my mind.

part two is stungun's terrible case on GC, which votato said "I AGREE VOTE" because it was in his favor to do so.

part three is Dunn does squat all day.

part four is that Stun and Gerain both (and fairly uniquely) defend (not just townread) Dunn. (bob is scummy on his own and also hops on the Dunn TR team)

part five is that Gerain only really started to play when Dunn was the leading wagon, and argued strongly against it at the expense of stungun. later, when Dunn was no longer likely to be lynched, grerain changed his stungun read to town.

It's a wide net, and I'm certain to be wrong on 2, I could even be wrong on 3, but I'll eat my hat if I'm wrong on 4 - there is two scum in this pile. Dunn is the worst of them.



p. edit it was just my read - you two had early beef it seemed to me, I thought you were scum reading him, nd then he called you town at some point. Since then things seem to be cool between you. very possible I'm reading too much into it.

I don’t think geraintm and stun can be scum together- either t/t or t/s

I don’t feel like he’s done squat? Like honestly this is more than I ever remember Dunn doing things lol

I don’t think geraintm professes a controversial read on his partner like that, but stun Dunn maybe?

I don’t think geraintm is playing unless directly prodded so I don’t think it’s reeevabt I just think he was getting called out more when Dunn was the leading wagon bc there’s actually stuff to analyze and he’s answering more

Tell me about that tinfoil team theory I’d love to hear that one too

tl;dr pigman scumreads me for lurking and then every other reason is something somebody else has done. Why don't you lynch that person instead?

Really? I'm the worst name on the list in 1376 when you can write about how every other person is scummy but you can't pull anything from my own posts to scumread me off of

AH so your Dunn read is akin to my Not Maf read.
"reeevabt"?

The hat case is silly; based largely on these:



Why go out of their way to defend Mal here? part of me says the simplest explanation is that they are scum together. LIKE I SAID ITS SILLY

In post 1380, Dunnstral wrote:Really? I'm the worst name on the list in 1376 when you can write about how every other person is scummy but you can't pull anything from my own posts to scumread me off of

your iso is fluff and bluff, there's nothing from which to pull I do not see how others don't see that.

In post 1379, Dunnstral wrote:tl;dr pigman scumreads me for lurking and then every other reason is something somebody else has done. Why don't you lynch that person instead?

like I said, you are the keystone - you link them all together.

How do you know it couldn’t be white knighting?

And it’s relevant autocorrect is selectively useful

Dunn didn’t I used to scumread you every game for lurking

lurking in itself isnt AI for dunn unfortunately.

No but his uncharacteristic doing things is townier iirc

In post 1384, notscience wrote:How do you know it couldn’t be white knighting?

And it’s relevant autocorrect is selectively useful

Can we establish a mutual understanding of "white knighting" before we follow this path of inquiry?

Scum defending town

Ie dunn town and then stun or geraintm defending him to look favorable after. A flip or buddy Dunn

well yes, in that case lynching Dunn would turn out kind of shit.

VC por favor

In post 1363, notscience wrote:DP I’m gonna need you to get your hands dirty you’re flitting around the outskirts of everything and it’s concerning me

TBH I am kinda demotivated because I've been busy irl with work and everytime I check back in I'm bombarded with 10 new pages on top of the 30+ I haven't gone back and read

In post 1340, stungun0404 wrote:

In post 1336, farside22 wrote:Yeah im not dealing with any more assholes

mod replace me.

farside, is there any way you can at least gut out the rest of this day phase? I only ask this because it's got 22 hours left, and we've already had the time extended 3 times, which is more than enough, and I sincerely don't want it to happen again.

If not, I understand, but it would just make things easier if we don't have to pause the game until night time searching for a replacement, and allowing the replacement to catch up during the night phase is also optimal.

Well the mod doesn't take in thread replacements apparently. So I will stay for the day leave at night phase.
Already went through a game like this and I don't need another like it.
I would think Dunn would have more to say. This game play is reminding me less and less of animal upick. His attack on pork reads pretty fake.
Still not trusting votato. He hasn't explained well or at all the response ns meta is town. I might actually agree with sg that ns is being pocketed but idk because my feelings on the spot are negative.

Farside did you read the quotes from him re me/Dunn? It’s literally all rvs and then one mid game post I legitimately don’t know where he got the pocketed thing from. The only other time before recently when I was townreading him was when I called him out for beetlejuicing and he never even responded to me.

I can understand saying I’m pocketed by mala or my darling little curling iron, but Dunn?

In post 1394, notscience wrote:Farside did you read the quotes from him re me/Dunn? It’s literally all rvs and then one mid game post I legitimately don’t know where he got the pocketed thing from. The only other time before recently when I was townreading him was when I called him out for beetlejuicing and he never even responded to me.

I only read the private message. After that I didn't really want to read much else. TBF I just felt best not to interact with you.
I don't see Dunn as pocketing anyone to be frank, I don't even know what is reads are at this point. He's been more active in games (at least he was in Animal Upick) so his lurking and providing nothing new this close to deadline reads more scummy to me.

Okay. I’m gonna keep tryharding just let me know if/when you feel up to chatting. I get I have a big uphill battle.

In post 1397, notscience wrote:Okay. I’m gonna keep tryharding just let me know if/when you feel up to chatting. I get I have a big uphill battle.

Well if it helps I don't think your scum any more my pool is more Dunn/Votato/Mala/GC

That's where I'm leaning on the most. If you are town I think 2 players pocket you. I saw it happen before where scum did that so I'm not buying what either are selling.
Also I find it odd that votato only uses meta as a town read on you but he knows my play and hasn't explained why he see's this as scum me. At this point i think he's faking stupid.
That's my head for the day. Won't be switching to pork if I can absolutely help it.

In post 1368, Porkens wrote:This is (was) farside’s town game and you are trying to compare her to Dunn. These pieces don’t go together.

I'm saying your suspicions of Dunn (voting HK as a vanity cw) are equally applicable to farside (voting GC as a vanity cw).

I'm not making the point to say you should read farside as scum.

I'm making the point because--as you read farside as town--it suggests your suspicion of Dunn on this basis manufactured rather than legitimate.