Mafiascum.net

is it possible the mafia doctor is a JOAT with a gun?

Unless Johnny is scum, then all of this is wack, and it’s just Johnny/Mini.

Ydrasse could be a JOAT with a gun on another ability, which is essentially what we need to wait on, plus their action.

im 99% sure johnny is town. if johnny is scum then id have to say i bet youre scum too.

“There is comfirmed to be a Mafia Doctor in this set up, who may or may not have some number of modifiers.“

Modifiers doesn’t change the role, it would be a Mafia JOAT with a Doctor ability if that were the case, so I think it’s fair to assume that it’s a Mafia Doctor.

it feels like the game is too easy if you give town an informed that essentially clears 3 people. so lets assume for a moment that ydrasse has a gun. suddenly bob looks very scummy.

In post 1377, Tayl0r Swift wrote:im 99% sure johnny is town. if johnny is scum then id have to say i bet youre scum too.

It’s actually impossible for me to be scum here without you thinking I killed Golden as scum partners with him.

So yeah.

I’m confirmed town based on the claims alone.

scum gunsmith makes sense given town cop and vig and a joat with a gun.

In post 1380, Flavor Leaf wrote:

In post 1377, Tayl0r Swift wrote:im 99% sure johnny is town. if johnny is scum then id have to say i bet youre scum too.

It’s actually impossible for me to be scum here without you thinking I killed Golden as scum partners with him.

So yeah.

I’m confirmed town based on the claims alone.

i have a large supply of tin foil, and very much like making hats out of it.

In post 1372, Tayl0r Swift wrote:well we know a mafia member is a doc

We?

In post 1379, Tayl0r Swift wrote:it feels like the game is too easy if you give town an informed that essentially clears 3 people. so lets assume for a moment that ydrasse has a gun. suddenly bob looks very scummy.

Bob already looked incredibly scummy.

Mini had a really convenient claim, which might just be because it works in the setup, and I jumped the gun.

Regardless, if Mini is scum, they are not Doctor.

In post 1383, Creature wrote:

In post 1372, Tayl0r Swift wrote:well we know a mafia member is a doc

We?

It’s in the game specific knowledge.

In post 1373, Flavor Leaf wrote:We know 1 scum doesn’t have a gun

Are we sure there's a scum doctor or is it just setup speculation?

In post 1379, Tayl0r Swift wrote:it feels like the game is too easy if you give town an informed that essentially clears 3 people. so lets assume for a moment that ydrasse has a gun. suddenly bob looks very scummy.

I don’t think it always would do that, we just happened to hit the exact scenario because we mass claimed after hitting scum and a no kill.

In post 1383, Creature wrote:

In post 1372, Tayl0r Swift wrote:well we know a mafia member is a doc

We?

mhmm its in the OP

In post 1386, Creature wrote:

In post 1373, Flavor Leaf wrote:We know 1 scum doesn’t have a gun

Are we sure there's a scum doctor or is it just setup speculation?

It’s in the opening post that confirms there to be a Mafia Doctor.

It’s the pre game setup knowledge.

Next step is just waiting for Ydrasse, and maybe Bob.

Oh well then looks like the three fonky claims are all true

Maybe it's now more complicated if there's a chance Johnny is faking it

Assuming Johnny isn't fucking masterminding here:

osuka
Ydrasse
PookyTheMagicalBear
Creature
Battle Mage
Gamma Emerald
Tayl0r Swift

Could maybe remove Ydrasse as no other role explains the lack of a mafia kill

Ydrasse is actually confirmed town because nothing else could have prevented scum kill not going through Night 1

In post 1392, Creature wrote:Maybe it's now more complicated if there's a chance Johnny is faking it

while his slot didnt claim it and his crumbs are awful, the slot did crumb early day 1.

In post 1393, Creature wrote:Assuming Johnny isn't fucking masterminding here:

osuka
Ydrasse
PookyTheMagicalBear
Creature
Battle Mage
Gamma Emerald
Tayl0r Swift

you think im the most likely scum? interesting. elaborate?

Perhaps we can autowin in this spot.

Wouldn't count on it and we'd still need to not be incredibly unlucky.

oh i see thats just the order of the playerlist im assuming, since youre in the list