FGO: Mafia in the Lostbelt (Game Over!)

[Servant Avenger]

I would like it if you could share your reasons for scum reading archer. If I agree It will make your win condition easier to achieve. If I don't, it probably won't budge my read anyway.

[Servant Moon Cancer]

I assume the two things I'm conflating are lying and misleading?

You're conflating the fact that I said I'm doing you a favour not spilling my every thought in thread with my stance on not sharing reasoning.

These are two entirely separate things.

But I also really, really don't care about your read on me, so where do you think this conversation is going to go? Are you going to try to stop the Archer wagon going through if I don't talk about it?

[Servant Avenger]

I think this conversation will eventually result in you giving me a ~single reason~ why Archer is scum. Because I asked really nicely.

[Servant Avenger]

It's my new dream now that having a master is dashed against the cobblestones of the universe.

[Servant Berserker]

Dude I'm kind of honoured that my name has been used as a verb twice on the last page by two different people.

I'm so official.

[Servant Berserker]

So we're organizing this vote because Avenger has a vote prediction ability and we want to activate it?

Can I get details on the mechanics of this ability? Not what it does, but how we activate it? Like... how long before the death do you need to submit it?

[Servant Avenger]

I worded it exactly as specified.

Within the first 48 hours of the day phase I have to PT Cabd a message with the name of a player that is going to die by elimination within that particular day phase.
If it's not within the first 48 hours it doesn't work. But they can be eliminated whenever during the day phase.

[Servant Berserker]

I worded it exactly as specified.

Within the first 48 hours of the day phase I have to PT Cabd a message with the name of a player that is going to die by elimination within that particular day phase.
If it's not within the first 48 hours it doesn't work. But they can be eliminated whenever during the day phase.

God....

Is Cabd insane enough to do....

[Servant Berserker]

No I gotta put that out of my mind for now.

[Servant Avenger]

That's so cheesy.

[Servant Moon Cancer]

Wait, you only want one reason? Lemme see...

I legitimately thought his use of "hmm" in #188 was the scummiest "hmm" I've seen in a long time.

Good enough?

[Servant Berserker]

That's so cheesy.

Look I'm really tired and my brain is going "RED FLAGS EVERYWHERE".

I have you as solid town, LET ME BE PARANOID OKAY

[Servant Moon Cancer]

As sad as it may seem, I am not joking about that either.

If you just want a boring macro reason, I'm just going to echo Saber's point about signal:noise ratio.

[Servant Avenger]

Wait, you only want one reason? Lemme see...

I legitimately thought his use of "hmm" in #188 was the scummiest "hmm" I've seen in a long time.

Good enough?

Good enough, thanks for making my dream come true.

[Servant Avenger]

So you have no objections to archer, Berserker?

[Servant Berserker]

So you have no objections to archer, Berserker?

My objection is that I prefer Caster first, and am less certain about Archer, but I think that given

every player but Caster has marked Archer as scum

(minus Moon Logic and Ruler) I feel as if this may tell us more information ANYWAY?

So.... yeah I'm chill.

[Servant Berserker]

My rage meter is RECHARGING.

ME ONLY PROTECC ONE PLAYER EACH DAY GRRR

[Servant Moon Cancer]

Oh, actually I should have gone with: I thought you made a good point in #202 but you seemed to fail to reach the obvious conclusion about how genuine Archer was being at the time.

[Servant Avenger]

Submitted.

[Cabd]

Servant Saber has requested replacement.

[Cabd]

Servant Saber has requested replacement.

Servant Saber has been replaced and may resume posting.

[Servant Archer]

Submitted.

Who?

[Servant Moon Cancer]

Do these read like the words of someone whose scum read was potentially about to win the master vote? (Caster made it to M-2, if you'll recall). No, they are loose, relaxed, unconcerned. There is not a hint of Berserkerishness to them. The most words they can muster against Caster is that they do not "inspire confidence". I do not know how this progresses to a GTH scum read. A town player who is suspect of one of the leading master wagons would be much, much more vocal. So that's one more point in the pile of them against Archer.

This reminded me. I actually did write something about Archer recently. It was that he was, at least according to previous reads he'd given, not town reading either Avenger or Caster but made no concerted effort to push Assassin over either of those two (while I partially attributed this to just a much lower activity level, I do think it stood out qs odd).

And fhatr further reminds me that he had exactly two scum reads and two town reads not thar long before the end of the master phase. Ending uo with precisely 4 scum gun to heas scum

[Servant Archer]

That doesn't sound scummy to me.

[Servant Moon Cancer]

Well that was a partial thought that ended up being fat fingered and accidentally submitted but uh... whatever. Gist of it is clear and I'm tired so that'll do.