Mafiascum.net

Yes sometimes, no other times.

How is this not blatant spam?

In post 1400, MathBlade wrote:Yes sometimes, no other times.

How is this not blatant spam?

Repeating the same thing and hoping for a different outcome is insane spam jsyk.

Why do you even care about vca w no scum flip?

In post 1401, Titus wrote:

In post 1400, MathBlade wrote:Yes sometimes, no other times.

How is this not blatant spam?

Repeating the same thing and hoping for a different outcome is insane spam jsyk.

Why do you even care about vca w no scum flip?

It helps me find premises to figure out the overall vibe of the game.

BGC was the other wagon with two townies wanting it and instead went another way.

The scum team is likely different based upon whether BGC is scum or whether scum PR hunted.

Too many assumptions. 2 town were likely on all the wagons.

What do you see here based on play?

In post 1403, Titus wrote:Too many assumptions. 2 town were likely on all the wagons.

What do you see here based on play?

There’s 0 assumptions. Alisae and Kitty are flipped town.

Flipped town wanted a wagon that didn’t happen.

Game is not sorting that wagon.

Game is not actively pushing for any particular elim by play and no reason provided BGC is a bad elim.

Frog doesn’t want to vote his top “kill it with fire” elim and doesn’t explain how STD “tests” BGC.

After being asked many times it’s likely they are partnered.

So by play I want the BGC wagon.

That's just Frogsterking isn't giving you what you want....

Your assumption is solely vca.

In post 1405, Titus wrote:That's just Frogsterking isn't giving you what you want....

Your assumption is solely vca.

State the assumption.

I am working from known facts to reach a conclusion.

You’re objecting to the method I am using and calling it VCA to dismiss it.

Did I assume the game is not looking at BGC day two?

No. That’s a fact.

Did I assume Frog is not explaining why he wants to elim someone who is above Frog in terms of scuminess?

Did I assume that Frog is now sussing me despite being his town lock in 1009?

What “assumption” am I making?

Spell it out.

In post 1346, Cape90 wrote:

In post 1344, furtiveglance wrote:

In post 1342, Cape90 wrote:im just here wondering what happened to the WIM of furtive

That was Fennec, I'm me.

you were solving a lot when you came in, said you were gonna elaborate on your reads later, ended up kinda not doing so. Also marcistar is quite literally at the top of your readslist you posted day 1, AKA 922

you have explained your scumreads somewhat but never really touched on really anything else

I elaborated. You just said I never elaborated then linked to the post in which I elaborated.

Yeah my read on marci was wrong. I townread mediation and being reasonable again. I do it a lot.

In post 1407, furtiveglance wrote:

In post 1346, Cape90 wrote:

In post 1344, furtiveglance wrote:

In post 1342, Cape90 wrote:im just here wondering what happened to the WIM of furtive

That was Fennec, I'm me.

you were solving a lot when you came in, said you were gonna elaborate on your reads later, ended up kinda not doing so. Also marcistar is quite literally at the top of your readslist you posted day 1, AKA 922

you have explained your scumreads somewhat but never really touched on really anything else

I elaborated. You just said I never elaborated then linked to the post in which I elaborated.

Yeah my read on marci was wrong. I townread mediation and being reasonable again. I do it a lot.

Actually I never elaborated. You were right the first time.

Your assumption is two town = right.

In post 1409, Titus wrote:Your assumption is two town = right.

That’s not my assumption.

My assumption = two dead town = worth exploring = probable scum.

Absolutely right? No.

Enough to ask why the possibility isn’t considered? Yes.

So then Frogger or you who wish to be elsewhere need to provide reasoning why where your vote is, is more likely than that.

Something here no one has done except Marci who said “read an iso”

And that’s being generous.

You don't tell us what to do. *shrug*

Correct I don’t.

I can make a persuasive case and with the lack of anything against it people follow

Ok.

In post 1402, MathBlade wrote:It helps me find premises to figure out the overall vibe of the game.

No it doesn't.

In post 1360, MathBlade wrote:

In post 1346, Cape90 wrote:

In post 1344, furtiveglance wrote:

In post 1342, Cape90 wrote:im just here wondering what happened to the WIM of furtive

That was Fennec, I'm me.

you were solving a lot when you came in, said you were gonna elaborate on your reads later, ended up kinda not doing so. Also marcistar is quite literally at the top of your readslist you posted day 1, AKA 922

you have explained your scumreads somewhat but never really touched on really anything else

Cape you’re one of the top posters and I want to see a summary of where you’re coming from. I see an abscence of consolidation around you and you’re a hyper poster (comparatively) and I want to find out why.

I think my lack of consolidation has to do with my playstyle in combination with having like a lot of scum candidates all at once flying through my head.

As for you, I feel like I would struggle to read a playstyle like yours without meta knowledge and the last game we played together is kind of a blur in this regard. Though predecessor makes me lean town on you, as for Not_Mafia

When Frogsterking seems like one of the helpfulest players in the game, but I still see a world in which they are scum. This game is just kind of a struggle to solidify townreads for me, I mean, mafia legit just killed probably my strongest town candidate after day 1 so I suppose that part makes sense about the kill.

MariaR is a odd slot who's latest posts feel a bit tipsy? I think they handled the Gamma slot in a possibly towny progression type of way. I just wish they would come back and play.

Enchant I cannot even tell at all.

Furtive has been strange but I also feel eh about voting them, it feels like this game is also just really low WIM and it's kinda been draining me.

Not_Mafia I do not have a good reason to townread just yet, but for some reason I feel he is town.

The best way I can describe marcistar and how she has been playing is a bit confusing and has me on the fence.

I cannot tell on Titus either, she hasn't provided enough content wise to the table

Big Chungus Gaming more like Big Step Down from day 1. VOTE: Big Chungus Gaming

The fact I feel like StD has been relatively towny this day comparatively to some slots says a lot about the apathy of this game thread that I hope will change. I could see the frustration that StD has as towny and I feel like I may have exaggerated when I called him an antagonistic boogeyman LMAO.

Can we agree on Cape/Frog/Maria/STD/MathBlade as a towncore or ...actually maybe just Frog and me. No one else

In post 1417, furtiveglance wrote:Cape/Frog/Maria/STD/MathBlade as a towncore o

smells like scums in there

I would object to Frog
Cape I am pretty okay with
Don’t know enough about Maria

But Frog is a hell no from me atm

Don’t know enough about you either

Why this core?

Elaborating on thoughts on MathBlade since I suppose that was vague

Their solving so far has felt very direct and to the point, there isn't much in the way of "okay guys im backreading everything" or whatever, just kinda is just like

Oh well you post a lot, tell me stuff

Or something like, oh you are another high poster, you say we should get this slot, so lets do this, idk why ur not getting this. Kitty wanted it when they died.

Like I guess that's the TLDR of his treatment of me and Frog's slots

There is an absence of really wanting to solve immediately, to rush things presumably for info without really developing reads or what have you's at least not ones that are said out loud.

I think it is an atypical playstyle to I would say most players.

i could see it as scummy, I could see it as towny, hence my meta comment.

Also MathBlade, do check 871 and 734 from schadd when it comes to your concerns about BCG wagon.

While you could argue that the vote wasn't really "run up" no votes actually were day 1. They were kinda split up until the last second where Alisae died (Greeting)

purr cape

can we just kill malcolm that always works :/

oh titus replaced sirrhett

we should do that or malcolm

Why do you suggest them over BGC?

@Cape thank for for that. I am going to read back just multitasking while trying to get life back into a seemingly dead game