Mafiascum.net

Yes.

Do you have a townread on OGML?

Guys, I'm pretty much ready to throw in the towel and let a replacement take over this slot. I'm apathetic town, but just really struggling to read through this game and focus past the hydra banter ("is this X?", "remember that game we played 3 years ago LOL you are scum because of that", etc).

I'm about 15 pages in now. I know I said I'd read it during the night phase, but I didn't hide and thought maybe the zombies would eat me. From what I've read so far just skimming through pages and pecking here and there, my top two scumreads are probably Sugar Cain and pitoli. Townreads are saulres, mastin, Amrun, and Desperado.

Do y'all want me to stick around or would you rather have another person in this slot that would be less curmudgeony and more carefree?

In post 1426, sangres wrote:Do you have a townread on OGML?

I've been incredibly subtle about it, but, yes, I'm leaning that way.

In post 1427, RedCoyote wrote:Do y'all want me to stick around or would you rather have another person in this slot that would be less curmudgeony and more carefree?

If you can be active I am happy to have you.
If you can't, then you should replace out.

In either case; a quick breakdown of why saulres = teh townz would be awesome to hear, that sounds like a unique consideration.

@Red Coyote - oh, wait, does saulres = sangres - that's less exciting.

How about a quick Mastin = teh townz instead? I don't think I've heard much about him either.

In post 1410, Toogeloo wrote:I nearly had an aneurysm

Urghmmm argghmmm delicious aneurysm ommmh nomm

In post 1427, RedCoyote wrote:Do y'all want me to stick around or would you rather have another person in this slot that would be less curmudgeony and more carefree?

If you can, stay. I love playing with you even when you're town.

In post 1428, Thor665 wrote:I've been incredibly subtle about it, but, yes, I'm leaning that way.

Could you be a little less subtle and tell me why you're reading him town?

Also, who would you vote if you weren't voting Sugar Cain?

Oh, yeah, sangres. I mixed him up with another scummer.

mastin's formation and cheering on the StupendousKey wagon was sincere and town motivated, I think. I had the exact same impression of SK. Hence my vote for him yesterday. Like I said, I hadn't got too terribly far into the game, but it's becoming a real struggle for me. The town may be better served with a scummer like TheIrishPope (assuming he is still interested in replacing it), someone that is much more inclined toward an environment of rapid posting.

In post 1431, sangres wrote:Could you be a little less subtle and tell me why you're reading him town?

From the bygone era of Page 55;
http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 3#p5194433

In post 1432, sangres wrote:Also, who would you vote if you weren't voting Sugar Cain?

Probably Matt.
Or any wagon on anyone I didn't have a town read on that had at least 1 vote - which is surprisingly difficult to find at the moment.

In post 1433, RedCoyote wrote:someone that is much more inclined toward an environment of rapid posting.

I personally would like to think it's dying down. Heck, get through one more Day Phase and we're probably going to lose another 3+ players.
The game really isn't that big, people are just being ludicrous.

In post 1434, Thor665 wrote:Or any wagon on anyone I didn't have a town read on that had at least 1 vote - which is surprisingly difficult to find at the moment.

Who are your non-townreads?

Let's see;

2. RedCoyote
8. PeregrineV
9. Mastin2
11. Aj the Epic
12. No Brains Here ( DrippingGoofball / Pirate Mollie )
15. Ellibereth *
16. Actiondan
17. Mattp
22. GuyInFreezer
23. Sugar Cain ( Nero Cain / Ms Marangal )

There.

I won't vote RedCoyote, NBH, ActionDan, MattP, and Sugar Cain in that list meaning our pool is looking more like:

PV, mastin2, AJ, Ellibereth, GiF. Don't want to vote Ellibereth that much today but he has to do something soon. I'll talk it over with ffery later and get back to you with a nice healthy wagon.

When you do, telling me why you think Sugar looks town would be nice.

VOTE: Thor

I have three big problems with you mister

In post 1408, MattP wrote:Both are fine. Pitoli is more useful

I disagree at this point - OGML has said things about more of the slots in the game than pitoli has and I think people generally have stronger opinions about OGML's alignment than they do pitoli's (I don't recall seeing a single person calling pitoli town yet, for example). I think that makes OGML more useful.

I had pretty strong reasons for Sugar Cain town D1 and I want to bring those to the table when I get a chance.

Please link me to any previous game where you tried to legitimize a pirate mollie lynch as a policy lynch

In post 1439, MattP wrote:I have three big problems with you mister

You done told me.

In post 1441, MattP wrote:Please link me to any previous game where you tried to legitimize a pirate mollie lynch as a policy lynch

[Ongoing]
But if you are willing to expend even minor effort you ought to be able to find it.

@Matt - also, where do you think Mollie's old whiny saw of 'Thor don' understand mah leet scumhunting skillz and likes ta argue wit me!' came from?
I mean, seriously now.

And yet, I have a confirmable power role

So Im done with the irritating exchange you've sucked me into

It's ok I respect you enough as a person to think you would not have a pathetic lynch list

I think your conversation with me is you running me in circles, I don't actually see any legitimate reason you're asking me the questions you're asking other than to make me jump through hoops, your questions are trying to make me admit I'm illogical and wrong on every count of this game so far and to make me admit my scumread on you is hypocritical but who te fuck cares if it is? If it is is it scummy for me to have a hypocritical read? It's like you're bombarding me with pointless technicalities for no discernible reason I can find

You're trying to make me agree that something a player did was town oriented when I already have a townread on him! Why are you wasting my time other than to try to look productive and to put me in my place

"Matt, brains and sugar are the three most vocal players besides me so they're all scumreads that should be disregarded!!"

That's not convenient!

Oh oh oh also if you try to turn this conversation around and attack me with technical questions I'll be ignoring them

So figure out a way to rephrase any questions you have into statements tia

In post 1437, sangres wrote:I won't vote RedCoyote, NBH, ActionDan, MattP, and Sugar Cain in that list meaning our pool is looking more like:

PV, mastin2, AJ, Ellibereth, GiF. Don't want to vote Ellibereth that much today but he has to do something soon. I'll talk it over with ffery later and get back to you with a nice healthy wagon.

why are you staying away from us nacho?