X-Men: Age of Apocalypse (Game Over)

[Feu et Vol]

like I said, a caricature of myself, and poorly interpreted at that

Beast please quote this I'm running out of data

Gotta quote this too. Reading at this moment btw.

-Beast

[Speaker for the Dead]

Moldy dairy products goddamnit I fucked up the whole joke

is your milk scumread curdling?

it shld

[borkjerfkin]

Certainly there are no past games to see how the moderator chooses characters for roles, nonetheless I think it's valid as a supplemental argument (not a foundational one - I agree there).

What is your foundational argument then?

I'm not biting on flavor spec in general and in specific I'm not biting on it here: I skimmed the Earth-295 article for Nightcrawler and he's a member of the X-men and a pretty popular character in general. It's reasonable he's in the game, and I don't see how you can, in good conscience, make any argument that his minor influence in this universe is alignment indicative.

[Macaronis and Cheese]

Can we just put all of the outed claims in here so that the whole town can see them?


Speaker, cheese is town.
Cheese, speaker is town and unfamiliar with xmen. Most women are.

Macaronis and Cheese: Weapon X
Venmar: Magneto
Speaker for the Dead: Nightcrawler
Snowstorm: Jean Grey
Majiffy: Bishop

~Macaronis

[Majiffy]

Moldy dairy products goddamnit I fucked up the whole joke

is your milk scumread curdling?

it shld

Im not touching either of you today.

Im pretty happy with a cloud or aronis lynch today

[Majiffy]

Who did aronis replace cuz I dont remember a mod post

[Rogue]

Can we just put all of the outed claims in here so that the whole town can see them?


Speaker, cheese is town.
Cheese, speaker is town and unfamiliar with xmen. Most women are.

Fucking bs.

Mollie is not unfamiliar with xmen. At the reckoning we watched Xmen last stand together. In fact the last Jason game we played together she did the flavor as at the time I only knew like two characters.

[Rogue]

It's a hydra jiffy

[Majiffy]

Huh

[Titus]

Majiffy...cheese or macaroni is aronis...

Watching the movies doesn't make someone familiar with xmen. There are comics, tv shows, etc. I have seen the movies and they make me desperately want to lynch Venmar more as the brotherhood is evil.

[Majiffy]

Oh

Im ok with lynching the noodles.

[Majiffy]

Yeah the movies dont deal with this universe

[Majiffy]

Or at least not the first 3

[Feu et Vol]

I am this close to replacing out but then I see people starting to townread Toog after me saying he's town. So maybe just maybe I can prove everyone else is town so you'd lynch scum

I have no problem hammerring scum, Brian. That was a stunt by Eek to dissolve his wagon.

Time for updated reads

Can you read the neighborhood and tell me what you think?

Giving the short version

There is a chance, although remote, that Eek is town and Feu was pitting us against each other rather than being Eek's buddy. Feu'snon responses to my arguments made that clear. A big deal has been made about me wanting to see Marquis troll. I explain why. He plugs ears and just yells the meta is wrong, I'm obvtown. That's total shit. He's not obvtown. Brian and Bork are obvtown.

Eek has been doing this same song and dance which I am the only one who doesn't seem to get. Light bulbs are going off for everyone but me. If I am voting scum an we're in the best strategic posotion, what is their to be gained by unvoting? The risk of Feu unvoting? That does nothing. Everyone says Feu scum would be obvious. Well, immediately after the Eek wagon dissolves, Feu asks if Eek still wants to go through with the plan (literally asks for an excuse not to bus)? How many scumread Feu for this despite my predictions...that's right....maybe Eek who is still chiding me. Anyway, I agree that I would be willing yo unvote, if Brian or Bork was front and be whatever position necessary...isn't interesting then the wagon dissolves. If I immediately unvoted, I would be chided for cooperating with a scumread. No matter what I did, that wagon was planned to dissolve.

I have done this same song and dance of lynching threats before as scum. You don't lynch threats. You lynch scum. My arguments were shit and I was outed scum but I was able to get 2 or 3 mislynches out of it because of paranoia. (It's offsite with a setup I will host in a mini theme if anyone cares).

Second to last paragraph is what I will be addressing.

I asked if they still wanted to be sandwiched. It would make no sense if they still did since they were told it only works like that if they were scum. If they had said yes I would have thought it to be a scum claim at that point. Like they highly thought you were scum so they figured they would give us the sensor just so we could eventually figure out you were scum.

-Beast

[Majiffy]

Sandwich thing is dumb and only scum indicative of eek if anything cuz it implies pr when he claims vt can we stop using titus unwillingness to unvote as a scumtell? I agree wholeheartedly with her position on that

[Majiffy]

Her venmar scumread is still retarded though ven is conftown imo

[Titus]

Majiffy, if you want my trust on Venmar, you can't go after my townreads. It goes both ways. They are town. Let's compare notes and see who we agree on. Your hood may be scumless (if memory serves me right on who is in it)

Feu, well what player us rationally going to say "yup I am scum, I will just totally fuck my wincon day one when we can lynch Titus"? None. That question existed as a cover your ass question.

[Majiffy]

I made a post recently with all my reads iso me to compare. Put noodles in want dead instead of whatever I have them at

[Titus]

Her venmar scumread is still retarded though ven is conftown imo

Show me where Venmar has made a useful post in his last 15. Bonus if you can find one that doesn't mention me.

[Majiffy]

Useful is not alignment indicative. Venmar is giving me heavy meta reasons to townread I cant expound upon because ongoing

[Titus]

You have like 4 elugible to lynch and I literally don't want those 4 dead

They are
Mac
Ulf
Cloud
PV

[Titus]

Useful is not alignment indicative. Venmar is giving me heavy meta reasons to townread I cant expound upon because ongoing

Useful is alignment indicative and is the best way of determining.

Trolling is useful to generate reads.

Scumhunting is useful.

Venmar should be policied until people see he's scum.

[Majiffy]

You have like 4 elugible to lynch and I literally don't want those 4 dead

They are
Mac
Ulf
Cloud
PV

Tough cookies im not voting outside that pool

[Majiffy]

Useful is not alignment indicative. Venmar is giving me heavy meta reasons to townread I cant expound upon because ongoing

Useful is alignment indicative and is the best way of determining.

Trolling is useful to generate reads.

Scumhunting is useful.

Venmar should be policied until people see he's scum.

No its not. Town can be useless and scum can be useful. Its kind of a thing. Also why this game can be challenging.

Your push on venmar is dumb. Take off the blinders.

[Titus]

Majiffy you are going to mislynch if you vote in that pool with the outside chance of PV.



Of course town can be useless. That's the point of a pressure vote and asking questions. Town then shape up.

Scum can appear useful but talking scum get caught eventually as they run out of options. (Example: Fake claim on you in teen wolf). Talking scum are vulnerable to vca (Casso in NY 169).