Mafiascum.net

Yep

Boon claimed a tracker guilty on his scum buddy in an old game
Lol

Claim is bullshit, no one should believe it and he needs to hang.

why shouldn't anyone believe it?

Because it is such a pedestrian claim that can't be proved. He could be protecting his buddies or setting up enough wifom to choke us in later days. Why do you believe it?

im not sure whether to believe it or not
it's just a claim that cant be proven, youre right

what do you think of his "crumb" or whatever it was that he was quoting that contained questions to Seo

I think crumbs can be manipulated to meet ones own ends. I softer an inno on someone last game just to fuck with town when I flipped scum.

Why just role info? Why not a full claim?

Hmm I could just hammer away but I won't until weekend ends at the earliest
Flames full claim now please

Pointing out I could hammer right now, but I'm probably not going to. Time for a boonie read list.

2-shot tracker no one targeted night 1, Seo targeted night 2, visited no one.

And Former that wasn't a crumb, I was trying to get info on Seo to see if he would pull out a lie.

Flames682 - I like how Flames has been playing. Mostly all of his posts are one liners and quick, and he hasn't been throwing his vote all over the place. When he voted Vettrock, he actually changed from his quick one liner posts and wrote a little more to explain his vote. He also has been generally posting longer posts when talking about vettrock, and this just seems like Flames trying to figure out the game. I'm leaning town.

Bert - I'm not exactly sure what Bert is doing. Sometimes I feel like he isn't doing absolutely anything, but other times I feel he's helping a lot. I don't know. He's my hardest to figure out. I feel like he's looking for reasons to mislynch someone, but he isn't coming off as scummy at all. I'm nervous to town read him as I don't want him to fall off the radar and just slip by if he actually is scum. This is my nullest read for now. I'm completely in the middle with him. I'll have to evaluate this more.

vettrock - I don't really like much about vettrock. There's been a few time where I thought he came across as town, like in 1274, but other times he is the scummiest thing ever. His reactions to my self-voting was super opportunistic, and he is voting Flames and saying he would prefer a Boon lynch, but he'll settle for Flames is him preparing for an excuse. I haven't looked over the Marquis slot much. I'm scum reading him.

Seohyun - I don't think scum would flat out say they are town reading everyone but one person in the game, and point that out. Everything he posts seems pretty town, including his psychic slip up. I'm town reading him.

pieguyn - I'm paranoid as all hell with her. She looks just like she did last game when her and I were scum partners, and I can't shake the idea that she is scum out of my head. Doesn't help that she replaced BlueBloodedToffee and I wasn't town reading BBT, one of the people I go out of my way to join a game with on the site, someone who I can usually town read pretty easily by early Day 2/late Day 1. Doesn't mean I was scum reading BBT, but yeah. I don't like the way she tried to conf town herself; she did that last game too. I also don't get why only 1 Psychic would be on the scum team. I don't like how she could be buddying herself up to Vettrock. She did that to Elbirn in the last game. Hard. This being said, i'm not stating they are scum together. I also don't like 1309. I'm scum reading her.

Formerfish - Fishy is hard for me to read, but if I'm not suspicious of Fishy, he's usually town. Nothing really shows as scummy to me. I don't have much to say on this. I'm leaning town.

TierShift - I feel Tier's just playing it safe. Hiding behind simple reads that he can change. Something is off for me. When just reading in the thread I felt a very scummy feel by him, but his ISO is making me actually see it from a more town perspective. That being said, that isn't hard to fake. I don't like how he's borderline flipflopping on some reads, and that he's not throwing a vote down on vett or flames, two people who have had voted today. It just feels like he's waiting so he doesn't look scummy. I'm leaning scum on him.

Updated Read List:

Boonskiies
Seohyun
Flames
Formerfish
Bert
Tiershift
Vettrock
Pieguyn

VOTE: Pie

↑ Bert wrote:

↑ Boonskiies wrote:Boon
Flames
Bert/Fish
Seo
Pie
Tier
Vett

is my town to scum read list. skimmed over ISO's. Subject to change when I figure out more of this game.

in comparison with

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 5#p6504335

hey boon im looking for something like this

How's that, Bert?

↑ Bert wrote:Yep

Boon claimed a tracker guilty on his scum buddy in an old game
Lol

I also ended up bussing my other partner 2 days later.

↑ Flames682 wrote:2-shot tracker no one targeted night 1, Seo targeted night 2, visited no one.

And Former that wasn't a crumb, I was trying to get info on Seo to see if he would pull out a lie.

Full claim means you claim everything. i.e. your flavor and stuff.

Machamp

Move is called Low Kick

How does that make sense with a tracker?

↑ Formerfish wrote:How does that make sense with a tracker?

I have to agree that Low Kick doesn't sound like track.

Basically it says I kick down the target and learn where they went. Doesn't make sense to me either but I didn't write the flavor for this game.

Right, but if you look at the dead and their roles each makes sense within the context of the move they actually have. Mine make sense for my character and make sense in the game as well. I also don't like having to pull this out of you like teeth. It gives me flashbacks to a very similar time in another game where you were scum if I remember correctly.

↑ Boonskiies wrote:
vettrock - I don't really like much about vettrock. There's been a few time where I thought he came across as town, like in 1274, but other times he is the scummiest thing ever. His reactions to my self-voting was super opportunistic, and he is voting Flames and saying he would prefer a Boon lynch, but he'll settle for Flames is him preparing for an excuse. I haven't looked over the Marquis slot much. I'm scum reading him.

Seohyun - I don't think scum would flat out say they are town reading everyone but one person in the game, and point that out. Everything he posts seems pretty town, including his psychic slip up. I'm town reading him.

pieguyn - I'm paranoid as all hell with her. She looks just like she did last game when her and I were scum partners, and I can't shake the idea that she is scum out of my head. Doesn't help that she replaced BlueBloodedToffee and I wasn't town reading BBT, one of the people I go out of my way to join a game with on the site, someone who I can usually town read pretty easily by early Day 2/late Day 1. Doesn't mean I was scum reading BBT, but yeah. I don't like the way she tried to conf town herself; she did that last game too. I also don't get why only 1 Psychic would be on the scum team. I don't like how she could be buddying herself up to Vettrock. She did that to Elbirn in the last game. Hard. This being said, i'm not stating they are scum together. I also don't like 1309. I'm scum reading her.


TierShift - I feel Tier's just playing it safe. Hiding behind simple reads that he can change. Something is off for me. When just reading in the thread I felt a very scummy feel by him, but his ISO is making me actually see it from a more town perspective. That being said, that isn't hard to fake. I don't like how he's borderline flipflopping on some reads, and that he's not throwing a vote down on vett or flames, two people who have had voted today. It just feels like he's waiting so he doesn't look scummy. I'm leaning scum on him.

So I have been mostly town, except for my reaction to you self-voting, which is something pretty much only scum does in my opinion. You've shown instances where you have done it as town, which just means you were just as anti-town in those games as well.

I'm agreeing with you on Seohyun. I think scum would have thought up a better plan with all of the mistakes he was making. Mostly town at this point.

I can partially agree with you on Tiershift as well. I see him sort of waiting to see what happens. Could be town, or could be scum.

reason you decided to leave out anything on pie?

↑ vettrock wrote:

↑ Boonskiies wrote:
pieguyn - I'm paranoid as all hell with her. She looks just like she did last game when her and I were scum partners, and I can't shake the idea that she is scum out of my head. Doesn't help that she replaced BlueBloodedToffee and I wasn't town reading BBT, one of the people I go out of my way to join a game with on the site, someone who I can usually town read pretty easily by early Day 2/late Day 1. Doesn't mean I was scum reading BBT, but yeah. I don't like the way she tried to conf town herself; she did that last game too. I also don't get why only 1 Psychic would be on the scum team. I don't like how she could be buddying herself up to Vettrock. She did that to Elbirn in the last game. Hard. This being said, i'm not stating they are scum together. I also don't like 1309. I'm scum reading her.

So I have been mostly town, except for my reaction to you self-voting, which is something pretty much only scum does in my opinion. You've shown instances where you have done it as town, which just means you were just as anti-town in those games as well.

I'm agreeing with you on Seohyun. I think scum would have thought up a better plan with all of the mistakes he was making. Mostly town at this point.

I can partially agree with you on Tiershift as well. I see him sort of waiting to see what happens. Could be town, or could be scum.

Forgot to address the Pie part. That she was in the neighborhood with Not_Mafia makes it unlikely for her to be scum. What would be the point of putting in a neighborhood with two scum members. I'm sure they already get to talk at night. The only point would be if there was a third member, and Seohyun's power doesn't seem to be that, despite the earlier mistake. In addition, I see her play as town, so I am putting her at my strongest town read at this point.

↑ Formerfish wrote:Right, but if you look at the dead and their roles each makes sense within the context of the move they actually have. Mine make sense for my character and make sense in the game as well. I also don't like having to pull this out of you like teeth. It gives me flashbacks to a very similar time in another game where you were scum if I remember correctly.

You don't like me claiming at L-1 is what you're saying.