In post 1411, Drew-Sta wrote:Can you guys just lynch me so we can move on with life? It’s clear noone cares any more.
If you’re town this is a shitty attitude.
If you’re Scum then someone needs to go at your bluff.
Agree it is a shitty attitude.
I’m sorry. I’m just frustrated.
Posted: Thu May 14, 2020 12:54 pm
by Drew-Sta
@trollie
Are you saying bob white knighted iDany?
Posted: Thu May 14, 2020 11:34 pm
by geraintm
so, I have been stuck with the mindset the last few days trollie being scum. just couldn't shake it.
this claim is good. if it is fake then the set up to coming out with it has been excellent. I buy it, and it makes trollie's game actions make much more sense to me. if it is fake, then bravo.
I think so far in this game I have been targeted by no one. why?
I am trying to work this out. my (hopeful) suspiscion is that I have come across as very townie who has been been trying to push a lynch of trollie the entire game. if I am seen as "town", then townies have better places to go at night,
and scum, well I think they are happy to leave a deluded townie in the game.
Posted: Fri May 15, 2020 1:28 am
by geraintm
In post 1407, Drew-Sta wrote:I won't have time to really work through this until Sunday AU time. So, frankly, I'm just keen to move on with this game and forget it ever happened.
I believe it's trollie. I believe I got it wrong about trollie before, and I vastly fucked up iDany and likely bob. I'm somewhat believing Ger is the other based on 1403 as how would he know scum can hammer the no lynch now (there are two left) if he didn't know bob was town.
Thus. I'm going with gut and I'll probably get my pants pulled down but fuck it - life's too short to agonise over this.
VOTE: TheTrollie
In post 1403, geraintm wrote:Trollie, scum.can end the day at any point they want by voting no lynch. If you have useful info you need to say now. Dancing like this is just....not good
when I wrote this, there were 2 votes on my lynch wasn't there? me and bob. only takes 3 votes to no lynch so scum could hammer the no lynch at any point, and it didn't matter what bob's alignment was as we have 2 scum left in the game.
going to go over Drew now to see how they stack up as scum
Posted: Fri May 15, 2020 1:41 am
by geraintm
so drew - I had them as the second most likely to be scum when I last did this, behind trollie.
obv that has changed now on trollie
Ditto. Seems weird for the PR to stay quiet for so long, only to come out in MyLo. Unless your claiming it Drew. But I guess you would've claimed it before you got hung, so... Eh.
Because mafia has killed each night but last night they did not.
Not claiming the role BTW.
I need to go do some serious reading. I royally fucked up iDany and I clearly need to go fix my reads.
here. "not claiming the role btw". but he had already claimed here
In post 1283, Drew-Sta wrote:It’s fine Bambi. I totally understand. Trollie, please do the honours and get this done. I’ve failed in trying to help town and I’d like to keep things moving.
Claiming VT. If scum are not in iDany and bob (one at least) then I really have fucked this up.
Goodnight.
back when he was sure scum was within idany and bob
posys 1407 and 1410, feels like he was angling to lynch trollie (and then me), but trollie inbetween their issues with drew and drew has to back off, but I think the damage has alredy been done. I think drew has switched his scum reads from idanny/bob way back when trollie and me
there was the "please hammer me, might do it myself" phase they had too.
other things
In post 1155, geraintm wrote:oh man, drew's post 1125 ending with avote for idany is bad.
In post 1137, Drew-Sta wrote:TLDR - iDany first scum choice. bob second scum choice. Trollie third scum choice. Bambi fourth scum choice but I find less likely.
this read list is terrible, excepting that I am not on it, that part I like.
Posted: Fri May 15, 2020 3:10 am
by Bambi Jay
It's raining and I'm at work. But when I get home I feel like at that point we can make up our minds within the next 24 hours. No point stalling and second guessing ourselves after all.
In post 1403, geraintm wrote:Trollie, scum.can end the day at any point they want by voting no lynch. If you have useful info you need to say now. Dancing like this is just....not good
Why would trollie care about ending the night ealier if he is scum?
Why say trollie could end it. As if you were town wouldnt you say scum coudl ended it.
After all with you voting no lynch. If you were town and not scum. Wouldnt you see it that either scum could hammer as bob is town. Or that trollie could hammer as its bob and trollie.
You just say trollie.
Oh and at this stage i cant see town not have thoughts towards who the scum team is. So who do you think is trollies partner and why?
As all of last day you refused to say. You were not prepared to work with anyone.
You wouldnt vote drew. YOu wouldnt vote dannyi
You just sat on trollie.
If you dint want danny, drew.
the who did you think was scum?
Bambi, me or mala.
If you thought mala why were you voting with him.
If you thought me why didnt you work with drew when he poe me and dannyi
if you wanted danny why dint you talk with him to get me.
If bambi why did you never mention him?
you have talked about the no lynch but have not replyed to the last bit
Posted: Fri May 15, 2020 7:40 am
by bob3141
In post 1426, TheTrollie wrote:and yeah im still basically just not shaking my d1 mala read so realistically im saying bob and drew
Can you answer why you think there would be no nigth kill if you, germa and malla were all town.
As why wouldnt either one of mala or germa been killed. Or one of me, bambi and drew.
If me and drew were the nigth kill why no night kill?
Thus since there was no nigth kill there had to be reason scum did not kill. If they had two townies ready to lynch you why not kill one of me, drew or bambi.
If you think im scum why would scum me hard defend dannyi and only lynch vote for him when faced between a choice of two of my town reads at the time. If i was scum wouldnt teh move scum would always make is to simply hard push not wanting dannyi and trollie. And get the credit for defending the player after whom ever is flipped.
Posted: Fri May 15, 2020 7:45 am
by bob3141
Also i cant serously believe anyoen who has made any effort in this game can actual honestly say they scum read. As there is no way to anyone
If you look how mav kept framing danny interactions with tweet. You will see its the exact same as how he handles me. It should be quite clear he is treating us the same.
Although this is meta, look at my scum games. You will see dannyi is wagon i would never have joined as scum. In 2114 i pushed against my own counter wagon. As i knew it would go through. If i was scum i would have just sat on germa.
A
Posted: Fri May 15, 2020 1:13 pm
by Drew-Sta
bob, if you were to vote for someone, who would it be?
Posted: Sat May 16, 2020 5:49 am
by TheTrollie
I've sorta tuned out now that I claimed. I guess I'll catch up but I had hoped more than just Bob would join my claim party before end of day.
I think no vote is the way to go unless someone has a guilty verdict or reason to believe my night actions implicate anyone... Which we also couldn't know unless ppl agree to claim today
Posted: Sat May 16, 2020 6:43 am
by bob3141
trollie only person that hasnt claimed to date is germa.
bambi claimed vt.
and i think drew claimed vt sometime last day phase but not sure
Posted: Sat May 16, 2020 7:34 am
by geraintm
Oh, I thought I had been very clear throught out the game that I was vanilla townie.
Posted: Sat May 16, 2020 7:35 am
by geraintm
Drew had claimed VT, but then forgot that later. I pointed that out above.
Sorry for quick posts it's the weekend
Posted: Sat May 16, 2020 8:09 am
by SirCakez
Posted: Sat May 16, 2020 10:04 am
by bob3141
Germa can you answer my question?
Posted: Sat May 16, 2020 10:04 am
by bob3141
on who you think is the scum team and why
Posted: Sat May 16, 2020 10:05 am
by bob3141
As all of last day you refused to say. You were not prepared to work with anyone.
You wouldnt vote drew. YOu wouldnt vote dannyi
You just sat on trollie.
If you dint want danny, drew.
the who did you think was scum?
Bambi, me or mala.
If you thought mala why were you voting with him.
If you thought me why didnt you work with drew when he poe me and dannyi
if you wanted danny why dint you talk with him to get me.
If bambi why did you never mention him?
Posted: Sat May 16, 2020 10:07 am
by bob3141
In post 1439, Drew-Sta wrote:bob, if you were to vote for someone, who would it be?