Newbie 2006 | Words | Over

[piisirrational]

intriguing that Piisirrational showed up and didn't post anything. No comment on my vote or post at all? Suspicious!

Explain how this is suspicious. Me coming online about an hour after your post for several minutes and not responding is NAI. If I still didn't comment on your post after a few days then it would look suspicious. I have IRL stuff too; I don't need to respond to everything right when I see it.

I do have enough time now to respond, so:

-I don't like your attempt to push me/AGaR as the scumteam, especially AGaR as scum. 1) AGaR not posting anything meaningful up to now in this day phase is NAI because he specifically said that he was waiting for my catch-up post. 2) My question to AGaR was posted simply to get his thoughts on players. If we were the scum team I would be asking him if he wanted to bus me in the mafia chat. 3) Voting record doesn't matter. Just because someone voted someone who flipped town doesn't mean that they're scum. As long as they had a good case against the person, which AGaR did, then it's town-indicative.

[piisirrational]

Actually on second thought: Battle Mage you make a good point BM that AGaR replaced into the slot of Android/MLF, whom I was actually scumreading when reading the thread.

In addition, despite finding AGaR's posts townleaning, from my PoV it's basically impossible for AGaR to not be scum, thinking about associatives. It also isn't that much of a townlean for me to be hesitant to vote him.

clidd/HG: Probably not very probable as the HEM/HG interactions were definitely not SvS.
clidd/BM: Both of you were tunneling each other so you both are probably not scum.
HG/BM: Both seem to be wanting to solve LYLO. I get it if one of them wanted to solve LYLO and look busy, but bot? Very unlikely.

VOTE: AGaR

[clidd]

VOTE: AGaR

This is scum ^

[Plotinus]

Official Vote Count 3.01

μῆλον

, ancient greek pronounced "melon" or "milon" means "apple". The English word melon comes from Greek melonpepon, "ripe apple", via Latin.

Lynching

With 5 votes in play, it takes 3 to lynch.

AGar

(3): Battle Mage, piisirrational, clidd

<-- LYNCH

Not Voting

(2): HoldenGolden, AGar

Deadline:

(expired on 2020-06-18 22:15:00)

.

Mod notes:

piisirrational is the new baby0blue.

Battle Mage is V/LA until today

A lynch![/area]

[Plotinus]

Day 3 Lynch - AGar

---

AGar has been lynched day 3. He was a

vanilla townie.

This means that the mafia team of

piisirrational, mafia goon

and

clidd, mafia rolecop

have won Newbie 2006 | Words!

the vanilla townies, Battle Mage and HoldenGolden

, are endgamed.

[/area]

[Plotinus]

Game Events

day 1

• PermissibleFire
  is lynched with 1 scum on her wagon.

night 1

• word321
  is tracking
  votato
  . (success: votato went nowhere)
  
• 3bounty
  is informing
  votato
  . (success: votato learns that 3bounty is town)
  
• humaneatingmonkey
  is killing
  word321
  . (success: dies)
  
• humaneatingmonkey
  is rolecoping
  AGar
  . (success: AGar is a vanilla townie)

day 2

• votato
  is lynched with 0 scum on their wagon.

night 2

• 3bounty
  is informing
  Nobody
  .
  
• piisirational
  is killing
  3bounty
  .
  
• clidd
  is rolecoping
  Nobody
  .

day 3

• AGar
  is lynched with 2 scum on his wagon.

Links

Links

• Public thread
  
• Mod PT
  
• Mafia PT (The mafia have requested this be kept private)
  
• Dead thread

[Plotinus]

We had a lot of replacements this game. Thanks to those of you who stuck around or who replaced in. You'll usually find there are fewer replacements in non-newbie games because in newbie games, it is a bit common for people to try something out, not knowing if they'll like it or not, and discover that they don't. Outside of newbie games, people usually have a better idea of whether they enjoy mafia or not, or at least they're addicted by then.

This thread is open now for post game discussion. You can post here even if you were dead and even if you didn't play.

[humaneatingmonkey]

I'm sorry for replacing out. I'm sorry for handing this game to clidd, HG. Life got too busy, and I needed to deprioritize mafia. I also wasn't in the mood to play.

[AGar]

Whoof

[clidd]

It was a hemorrhagic pleasure accept the invitation of this illustrious game. I was able to enjoy the extent of my participation and I confess that you surviving with Holden alive before replacing out was surprising, given the history between the two of you.



The ad hominem I mentioned in the last pages was a tip that I had no reason to justify Scum!BM beyond the erradic vote at the end of D2.

[Battle Mage]

ah fuck! Well I don't think there's a chance in hell we'd have won that game anyway, so was worth a shot! I would either have been lynched myself, or have caused the mislynch at some stage as I definitely didn't see a HEM-Piiss pairing. For once, I shouldn't have bothered thinking, and just continued to tunnel-vision HEM today! My terrible run as town continues, but this one was a lost cause. Good game all!

[HoldenGolden]

Well at least I dont have to put effort into mylo anymore. Not quite sure why there was a vote that early into the start of actually discussion but blah. Shit happens.

I'm sorry for replacing out. I'm sorry for handing this game to clidd, HG. Life got too busy, and I needed to deprioritize mafia. I also wasn't in the mood to play.

I figured as much lol. Dont feel bad about it. It was hard to read into your slots interaction with BM whose playstyle is hard for me to read (no offense to BM. It just objectively is.)

At least I correctly read you as scum during day 1 haha

Also the scum team PoE works again!

[Battle Mage]

I probably should've switched to piissirrational when I saw they were lurking and watching the thread without posting. -.-

[HoldenGolden]

ah fuck! Well I don't think there's a chance in hell we'd have won that game anyway, so was worth a shot! I would either have been lynched myself, or have caused the mislynch at some stage as I definitely didn't see a HEM-Piiss pairing. For once, I shouldn't have bothered thinking, and just continued to tunnel-vision HEM today! My terrible run as town continues, but this one was a lost cause. Good game all!

Nah I think mindlessly tunneling wasn't the solution. Just more transparency and making posts like you did on the last page showcasing good analysis. Comparatively to Piis catchup which was pretty waffley, it was actually pretty good.

(Take a pinch of salt because I know the alignments now)

[Battle Mage]

Well at least I dont have to put effort into mylo anymore. Not quite sure why there was a vote that early into the start of actually discussion but blah. Shit happens.

I'm sorry for replacing out. I'm sorry for handing this game to clidd, HG. Life got too busy, and I needed to deprioritize mafia. I also wasn't in the mood to play.

I figured as much lol. Dont feel bad about it. It was hard to read into your slots interaction with BM whose playstyle is hard for me to read (no offense to BM. It just objectively is.)

At least I correctly read you as scum during day 1 haha

Also the scum team PoE works again!

No offence taken! I figured given I was probably the best bet for getting lynched today anyway I'd better make the first move.

[Battle Mage]

ah fuck! Well I don't think there's a chance in hell we'd have won that game anyway, so was worth a shot! I would either have been lynched myself, or have caused the mislynch at some stage as I definitely didn't see a HEM-Piiss pairing. For once, I shouldn't have bothered thinking, and just continued to tunnel-vision HEM today! My terrible run as town continues, but this one was a lost cause. Good game all!

Nah I think mindlessly tunneling wasn't the solution. Just more transparency and making posts like you did on the last page showcasing good analysis. Comparatively to Piis catchup which was pretty waffley, it was actually pretty good.

(Take a pinch of salt because I know the alignments now)

Hey it wasn't mindless. My fking "honestly" tell strikes again!

[HoldenGolden]

ah fuck! Well I don't think there's a chance in hell we'd have won that game anyway, so was worth a shot! I would either have been lynched myself, or have caused the mislynch at some stage as I definitely didn't see a HEM-Piiss pairing. For once, I shouldn't have bothered thinking, and just continued to tunnel-vision HEM today! My terrible run as town continues, but this one was a lost cause. Good game all!

Nah I think mindlessly tunneling wasn't the solution. Just more transparency and making posts like you did on the last page showcasing good analysis. Comparatively to Piis catchup which was pretty waffley, it was actually pretty good.

(Take a pinch of salt because I know the alignments now)

Hey it wasn't mindless. My fking "honestly" tell strikes again!

Oh no I was just saying that you said "dont think and tunnel" is what you should do. Which implies mindless tunneling lol.

I played bad this game.

[Battle Mage]

don't sweat it dude...when scum gets a cleansweep, the whole town played a bit bad.

[word321]

Oh, well
GGWP!
Congratulations ro the mafia for winning!

[word321]

No mafia chat?
BUH
Nah, its ok
I did want to check ir out at some point tho

[word321]

I did comment thorough the game on the deadchat, so u may want to check it out
Holden still dsnt set the score with Hem tho (hahahha)

[HoldenGolden]

I did comment thorough the game on the deadchat, so u may want to check it out
Holden still dsnt set the score with Hem tho (hahahha)

Yea I skimmed through it a little bit and will go through more deeply when at home.

It's hard to say if i would of caught scum day 3 after my demotivated day 2 play. I definitely gave blue too much credit during my catch up due to the similarities we had read wise which extended throughout the slot in later day phases. In hindsight, clidds declaration in his first deduction where he is town because "he likes replacing in to town" should of raised red flags as well.

Also, while my record against scum!hem is 1vs 3 now, at least I didnt break any eldritch pinkie promise pacts like he did. I have the moral high ground in our relationship.

[humaneatingmonkey]

Also, while my record against scum!hem is 1vs 3 now, at least I didnt break any eldritch pinkie promise pacts like he did. I have the moral high ground in our relationship.

still officially 1v2. i replaced out of the game. although i argue i would have won anyway.

[humaneatingmonkey]

at least I didnt break any eldritch pinkie promise pacts like he did

i spit on your eldritch pinkie promise pacts

[humaneatingmonkey]

It was a hemorrhagic pleasure accept the invitation of this illustrious game. I was able to enjoy the extent of my participation and I confess that you surviving with Holden alive before replacing out was surprising, given the history between the two of you.

did you really read me town before replacing in? i don't expect you to answer this honestly.