Mafiascum.net

In post 1401, Menalque wrote:I think if we really did want to investigate there again after notscience flipping scum would be a (datisi, norwee) pool

What are you even basing this on?

In post 1417, Umlaut wrote:

In post 1415, Radical Rat wrote:Okay, absolutely bonkers idea here, buuuut

Iconeum/NK15/notscience scumteam.

I'm happy to entertain bonkers ideas, but I really can't imagine the PA not outing if this were the case.

See, I agree with this, but I also can't imagine Ico not outing when it ALREADY CLAIMED. The only explanation is that Ico fakeclaimed, which would have been suicidal if NK actually were the PA. And if Ico is Town, it can't know that NK was fakeclaiming. Scum!Ico also can't know that Town!NK was faking.

But a crazy scum Gambit in which no matter which one of them gets branded the fake and lynched, the other looks Town??? Might just work.

In post 1422, Something_Smart wrote:I don't see what was towny about Moment if NK is town.

?

Is this like GL’s logic or something else?

Or do you mean if NK is scum?

I think NK15 looks a lot worse on a notscience scum flip than he does on a moment scumflip.

I mean if NK is town. It's not exactly GL's logic just I don't see why scum-Moment would not defend town-NK like that.

In post 1428, maxwell wrote:I think NK15 looks a lot worse on a notscience scum flip than he does on a moment scumflip.

This is like, broadly the opposite of what I think

In post 1429, Something_Smart wrote:I mean if NK is town. It's not exactly GL's logic just I don't see why scum-Moment would not defend town-NK like that.

Whereas scum!moment wouldn’t defend scum!NK because..?

In post 1431, Menalque wrote:Whereas scum!moment wouldn’t defend scum!NK because..?

That's an awful lot of faith in the town to not inspect/execute them if NK goes down anyway.

Mena, your blatant ignoring has been logged.

In post 1431, Menalque wrote:

In post 1429, Something_Smart wrote:I mean if NK is town. It's not exactly GL's logic just I don't see why scum-Moment would not defend town-NK like that.

Whereas scum!moment wouldn’t defend scum!NK because..?

It's white flag and hard defending a teammate who had runaway momentum as the day's wagon is tantamount to suicide.

Still vla.



I think Moment is town. Notscience is likely scum by vca.

If we hit scum, we should investigate another pool of three to four.

If we hit town, we should investigate within the pool as I doubt any are the TD is in the pool. (Why would the PA suggest a pool that flips tea?)

Quelle surprise, tea was found.

There are a great number of reasons why I am upset at Iconeum, but perhaps the one most worth mentioning is that he had the option to shorten the night to 24 hours and chose not to.

VOTE: Notscience

For the record, I never stopped townreading Maki. I said that I retracted my townread on her because I wondered if perhaps the fact that she could get townread despite her low content would allow her to coast by if scum, and so I wanted to give even a small nudge towards her producing more content.

Going to be low-activity until Monday, btw, though that's short enough I shouldn't need to V/LA

What did I tell ya guys. This is why I had utmost confidence in that pool.

Let's investigate a new group of 3 while lynching notscience.

[Norwee, Umlaut, maxwell] ?

This is firing from memory so I may end up having to revise later but

I feel pretty good about these people being town: menalque, username, guiltylion, radical rat
I feel like these people are town but not as strongly: alisae, something_smart
I don't know how I feel about: norwegian, umlaut (recall some townish things about norway but probably need to re-read there)
People I lack any feeling of towniness from: titus, not known 15, hel

In post 1440, Hel wrote:What did I tell ya guys. This is why I had utmost confidence in that pool.

Let's investigate a new group of 3 while lynching notscience.

[Norwee, Umlaut, maxwell] ?

i like this pool

I think notscience is a good execution for today.

NK15 needs to be in the investigation pool though, remember all that talk about how we can't let him live to endgame? That's what's going to happen if we keep putting off dealing with the slot.

Also, I have no intention of following Iconeum's direction from now on. As far as I'm concerned, by failing to identify in the report, it's forfeited its claim to the role.

icon not revealing himself was likely dumb and him not knowing tbh

I wouldn't be surprised
we have a PA who doesn't know how to think mechanics through

In post 1445, Alisae wrote:icon not revealing himself was likely dumb and him not knowing tbh

How? It's in the setup post. It's in the role PM. It's been talked about in thread several times. I don't see how it could possibly be unaware of that unless it just... Literally is not reading the game, in which case what the hell was the deal with dictating the execution and inspection yesterday?

In post 1447, Radical Rat wrote:It's in the role PM.

it is?
tell me where it is in there