Mafiascum.net

Ok, from the gist of the last two pages, we're picking between Archer and shielder. Who is defending which slot? How close are we to deadline? Why is each a topic of discussion?

I think it's interesting you ended up with exactly four given you were pretty unsure about a lot of the game was the point I was attempting to make. See for instance most people ending up with 3, 5 or 6.

Having exactly 4 suggests a greater level of comfort with how you're reading the game than previous posts from you suggested you actually had.

More of a random thought I had than a reason for calling you scum though.

Well Avenger apparently gets a buff if he correctly chooses who is hanged within 48 hours, so people have been rushing their decision. Apparently, he submitted me? Nobody is defending me, and Shielder seems to have some support. I don't think we actually have 48 hours to hang, but just that time period to decide a kill. Assassin wrote up why he thought I was scummy a couple pages back.

We're nowhere near deadline so take your time reading.

In post 1425, Servant Saber wrote:Ok, from the gist of the last two pages, we're picking between Archer and shielder. Who is defending which slot? How close are we to deadline? Why is each a topic of discussion?

Not a lot of defense going on. This is a double day and we have a confirmed town, and we have about 7+ days until Night Phase. I don't envy you having to get up to speed on an anon game, but you have time to do so.

In post 1426, Servant Moon Cancer wrote:Having exactly 4 suggests a greater level of comfort with how you're reading the game than previous posts from you suggested you actually had.

I don't think this is true because those are gun to head. I probably could not give great reasons for any of them to be scum. I don't give great reasons in general though.

In post 1424, Servant Moon Cancer wrote:Well that was a partial thought that ended up being fat fingered and accidentally submitted but uh... whatever. Gist of it is clear and I'm tired so that'll do.

Don't worry, I got it. I was rereading your ISO earlier because something caught my eye and I have a clearer idea of your views, now. I would like to ask you if you've managed to settle on a guess for a team yet? You don't have to name names or provide details, I am just curious as to where your process is at.

VOTE: Archer

Totally down for this.

Hi new Saber! Due to double day, we may end up deleting both of them, but for now it's almost certainly Archer thanks to Avengers cryptic power that's definitely a real thing that is going to help town win. I'm happy to let this happen.

I will miss old Saber. Even though they clearly were unable to keep pace with the game, I felt as though their contributions in their minimal posts were solid. They demonstrated great efficiency with their contribution. I wish them the best of luck.

That being said, greetings, ! I am your resident confirmed town. If you would like to receive a 100% accurate, trustworthy summary, you need look no further than me. Feel free to ask me anything.


, all I will say is that if I have erred and you are in fact aligned with the forces of good, that in spite of what I said in my wall, proclaiming your innocence is unlikely to be of much use to anyone at this point. What you should do is try to point us in the direction of who you believe to be scum. It doesn't really matter if you're not confident or able to explain well, I just want you to try your best. I realize you've been sort of straightaway buried here, and in all honesty it really sucks for you regardless of your alignment. These are somewhat unusual circumstances. I will try to make it up to you by giving you the opportunity to speak your part unhindered.

Everything I hoped a confirmed town could be. /extreme buddying

In post 1350, Servant Archer wrote:

In post 1344, Servant Caster wrote:Berserker is being given way too much credit for their entrance. A savvy scum player could very easily see from their fake claim PMs that ramming that angle as hard as possible would get them townread.

What do you think about how Berserker was defending Shielder?

It's a thing that happened. I'm sure avenger will call be a hedge wizard again, but I could see it as a chainsaw or a WK easily. The level of confidence would likely make me think Berserker is scum were it not for other factors.

In post 1381, Servant Assassin wrote:

In post 1379, Servant Avenger wrote:Okay. Should I send this in.
Do we have any objections or last minute berserkering to crash this wedding?

Who knows, maybe Caster wants to weigh in as the lone contrarian read.

The thing about the gun to head exercise is that my unsure reads became town because of math. Particularly after reading 1376, I have no objections to an Archer elim.

In post 1415, Servant Berserker wrote:

In post 1414, Servant Avenger wrote:So you have no objections to archer, Berserker?

My objection is that I prefer Caster first, and am less certain about Archer, but I think that given

every player but Caster has marked Archer as scum

(minus Moon Logic and Ruler) I feel as if this may tell us more information ANYWAY?

So.... yeah I'm chill.

I can foresee that you are going to use this flip to call me scum regardless of what flip it as, as I was either defending my buddy or knew Archer to be town. Could you do me a favor and pick one lane before he flips? Thanks.

In post 1427, Servant Archer wrote:Well Avenger apparently gets a buff if he correctly chooses who is hanged within 48 hours, so people have been rushing their decision. Apparently, he submitted me? Nobody is defending me, and Shielder seems to have some support. I don't think we actually have 48 hours to hang, but just that time period to decide a kill. Assassin wrote up why he thought I was scummy a couple pages back.

Are you gonna, like, do anything?

If we run up Moon Cancer do we think he'll stop being literally the worst?

In post 1436, Servant Caster wrote:If we run up Moon Cancer do we think he'll stop being literally the worst?

I don't mean now, before someone accuses me of trying to distract from my buddy Archer.

Caster x Archer team confirmed?

You're one smart cookie.

Shit, you got me.

In post 1439, Servant Archer wrote:You're one smart cookie.

So... You're here enough to respond to my joke but not enough to give us any content that might help should you flip town? You just giving up as scum?

Caster, do you have thoughts about how the wagons built during the last couple days?

Also:

In post 1292, Servant Caster wrote:Something annoying has happened with regard to my role. >:/

When did this happen?

Should say last couple days of the master vote.

Archer, please, at least give some acknowledgement of what I have said to you. I do not wish to condemn you to a hasty elimination but further avoidance of the subject will force my hand for the purpose of avoiding game stagnation and irritation.

In post 1442, Servant Alter Ego wrote:Caster, do you have thoughts about how the wagons built during the last couple days?

Also:

In post 1292, Servant Caster wrote:Something annoying has happened with regard to my role. >:/

When did this happen?

I just went back to the end of day and I find Ruler to be the most suspicious voter. If we assume all 3 wagons were on town, and consider the idea that scum may have decided to support me as the least threatening, he is the prime candidate for having done so, as he voted me for no reason and his prior interaction with me seemed to consist mostly of disliking or scumreading me. I wish he had answered Assassin's question, as if he had scumread me there I would be able to lock in a scumread on him now.

It happened during Day 1. I don't think I can go much deeper without revealing too much. I just want it to be known now as a hedge against what happened potentially looking awfully convenient for me if I didn't mention it until days from now.

In post 1445, Servant Caster wrote:

In post 1442, Servant Alter Ego wrote:Caster, do you have thoughts about how the wagons built during the last couple days?

Also:

In post 1292, Servant Caster wrote:Something annoying has happened with regard to my role. >:/

When did this happen?

I just went back to the end of day and I find Ruler to be the most suspicious voter. If we assume all 3 wagons were on town, and consider the idea that scum may have decided to support me as the least threatening, he is the prime candidate for having done so, as he voted me for no reason and his prior interaction with me seemed to consist mostly of disliking or scumreading me. I wish he had answered Assassin's question, as if he had scumread me there I would be able to lock in a scumread on him now.

It happened during Day 1. I don't think I can go much deeper without revealing too much. I just want it to be known now as a hedge against what happened potentially looking awfully convenient for me if I didn't mention it until days from now.

Can you confirm if what happened was a third party action, or something unknown about your role that did it to itself, or possibly a mod correction.

In post 1324, Servant Ruler wrote:I was mostly interested in your thoughts on rider / foreigner since that's who bit on Caster being viable.

What the hell is this coming from someone who voted me right before rider & foreigner?

In post 1446, Servant Beast wrote:

In post 1445, Servant Caster wrote:

In post 1442, Servant Alter Ego wrote:Caster, do you have thoughts about how the wagons built during the last couple days?

Also:

In post 1292, Servant Caster wrote:Something annoying has happened with regard to my role. >:/

When did this happen?

I just went back to the end of day and I find Ruler to be the most suspicious voter. If we assume all 3 wagons were on town, and consider the idea that scum may have decided to support me as the least threatening, he is the prime candidate for having done so, as he voted me for no reason and his prior interaction with me seemed to consist mostly of disliking or scumreading me. I wish he had answered Assassin's question, as if he had scumread me there I would be able to lock in a scumread on him now.

It happened during Day 1. I don't think I can go much deeper without revealing too much. I just want it to be known now as a hedge against what happened potentially looking awfully convenient for me if I didn't mention it until days from now.

Can you confirm if what happened was a third party action, or something unknown about your role that did it to itself, or possibly a mod correction.

I think you're reading "my role got worse" which is not what happened.

Eh, whatever, here: I tried to do something, it did not work, and I don't know why, although I have a guess.

In post 1445, Servant Caster wrote:

In post 1442, Servant Alter Ego wrote:Caster, do you have thoughts about how the wagons built during the last couple days?

Also:

In post 1292, Servant Caster wrote:Something annoying has happened with regard to my role. >:/

When did this happen?

I just went back to the end of day and I find Ruler to be the most suspicious voter. If we assume all 3 wagons were on town, and consider the idea that scum may have decided to support me as the least threatening, he is the prime candidate for having done so, as he voted me for no reason and his prior interaction with me seemed to consist mostly of disliking or scumreading me. I wish he had answered Assassin's question, as if he had scumread me there I would be able to lock in a scumread on him now.

It happened during Day 1. I don't think I can go much deeper without revealing too much. I just want it to be known now as a hedge against what happened potentially looking awfully convenient for me if I didn't mention it until days from now.

Thanks, I was curious if it was something that happened at the start of day 1 or of it happened close to the time when you posted it. Not knowing for sure isn't the end of the world.

pedit Ah! Even more thanks!