Mafiascum.net

In post 1441, RadiantCowbells wrote:On some level, you do understand that Morality is not a player that you would correctly scumread, right?

Again- I have no delusions about my ability to play this game.

In post 1440, Shoshin wrote:What's your plan for winning this game, Vorkuta? How do you intend to find scum on D1? What're you looking for?

-Plan....? As in "follow RC as he lynches teh scums/leads town off a cliff"? Everyone has a plan until they get punched in the face

-I don't think we find scum on D1. Simple as that. We lynch the least common denominator, or the most anti-town player and see what the night PR's do/give us.
This isn't an open setup with X VT's and Y Goons with no powers, so let's see what happens. They've won games for me in the past, and if it ain't broken...

-As I've said waaay early on, I'm trying to get a read on your personalities and what's within/outside the realm of possibilities and everyone's scum range.
Later on when people begin claiming, when people will begin to point fingers, and when/if people begin to scum read me, I need to understand the true extent of the damage that scum!players are capable of doing and try and minimize that.
-I like shit like this.

In post 555, RadiantCowbells wrote:again

my townpool in this game is not wrong and i'll kill you if you try to go after it

this is the end of this discussion

It's a commitment that forces extreme leaps in logic and backtracking that will result in slipups from scum players.
I think Morality has similar ones as well (but less explicit).

For the record, Aurathebirb.
The 'reasons arent good enough to lynch Creature' thing that you townread I think is incredibly scummy.
Creature himself has even acknowledged that his opener was scummy as fuck. I don't think that's a legitimate read. I think that's scum who thinks they can look good by defending Town!Creature because they already know they're gonna prove themselves town and there's no point going after them. I'm saying that that read is a TMI read, in other words.

In post 1450, Vorkuta wrote:-I don't think we find scum on D1. Simple as that. We lynch the least common denominator, or the most anti-town player and see what the night PR's do/give us.
This isn't an open setup with X VT's and Y Goons with no powers, so let's see what happens. They've won games for me in the past, and if it ain't broken...

Do you realize that I hit scum >50% of my town games D1 and my reads have been progressively getting better and better over the last year?

Like- we're planning to hit scum D1. Don't sell what we're capable of as a town short. If you think that we can hit scum D1 we can hit scum D1. If we're not trying to hit scum D1, what exactly are we trying to do?

I'm 10 pages behind so it'll take some time to catch up, page 48 has some pressure on Shoshin and Vedith though. I'll defend both of these slots, they are both strong townreads for me and bad lynches at that, Shoshin more so.

My reads have jumped around a fair bit so I'll get around to my reads list after I'm caught up.

In post 1453, RadiantCowbells wrote:Like- we're planning to hit scum D1. Don't sell what we're capable of as a town short. If you think that we can hit scum D1 we can hit scum D1. If we're not trying to hit scum D1, what exactly are we trying to do?

Seriously. I hate the mentality so many players have of not even trying to lynch scum D1. I definitely hit scum on D1 more often than not. And even when we mislynch, scum are almost always in town's crosshairs. It's often just a matter of getting town to agree on the right player.

Enigma, why is Vedith town? You need to help me with that.

If you're town RC.

D1 we're trying to establish precedents/relationships, see the interaction between players, hear out some meta arguments, and get the lynch that provides the most information. Like there's a really strong Shoshin/RC bond, and there's a real nice Morality/Vedith bond as well this game. Creature is in Team Morality, Boats is closer to team RC, and so on. Factionalism.

Fuck information lynching. You win mafia by lynching scum, not by creating information.

VOTE: DrDolittle

I think this is my most confident wolfread that isn't Morality.

If you're town RC.

D1 we're trying to establish precedents/relationships, see the interaction between players, hear out some meta arguments, and get the lynch that provides the most information. Like there's a really strong Shoshin/RC bond, and there's a real nice Morality/Vedith bond as well this game. Creature is in Team Morality, Boats is closer to team RC, and so on. Factionalism.

Or we could just, like, murder scum. Do you really think if I was scum I wouldn't be manipulating the way that the factions developed such that your analysis of it would lead you further away from winning the game?

That factionalist approach is so manipulable by scum, Vorkuta. Like, oof. You're the kind of townie I dream of playing against as scum.

That's technically untrue Shoshin, we create information by lynching people who flip scum. That information is that the person we lynched was scum.

In post 1460, Shoshin wrote:That factionalist approach is so manipulable by scum, Vorkuta. Like, oof. You're the kind of townie I dream of playing against as scum.

You're the kind of townie I dream of playing with as town. <3

In post 1462, RadiantCowbells wrote:

In post 1460, Shoshin wrote:That factionalist approach is so manipulable by scum, Vorkuta. Like, oof. You're the kind of townie I dream of playing against as scum.

You're the kind of townie I dream of playing with as town. <3

I'm going to be heartbroken if you're scum this game.

In post 1459, RadiantCowbells wrote:VOTE: DrDolittle

I think this is my most confident wolfread that isn't Morality.

Missed the last 10 pages but big oof

"You win the game by getting more points than the other guys".

Maybe in a dozen or so games I'll get closer to understanding that. But right now, it's my *trigger warning* """"opinion"""" that scum has to be bad on D1 to get lynched.

It's the other way around, Vorkuta. Town has to be bad for scum to survive D1.

In post 1456, Shoshin wrote:Enigma, why is Vedith town? You need to help me with that.

I can't explain it in detail at the moment, I'll get to it in time. Probably with my readslist.

I think it was yellow that asked if I still thought creature was scum, somewhat. He's still one of the better lynches today and creature/ddl is my shortlist.

So I know my alignment. and I know rc should be generally pretty good at hunting for scum. So the fact that hes so wrong on my slot means hes more likely scum pushing for a mislynch

In post 1463, Shoshin wrote:

In post 1462, RadiantCowbells wrote:

In post 1460, Shoshin wrote:That factionalist approach is so manipulable by scum, Vorkuta. Like, oof. You're the kind of townie I dream of playing against as scum.

You're the kind of townie I dream of playing with as town. <3

I'm going to be heartbroken if you're scum this game.

I would have been heartbroken if I had rolled scum this game.

So I know my alignment. and I know rc should be generally pretty good at hunting for scum. So the fact that hes so wrong on my slot means hes more likely scum pushing for a mislynch

Spicy. What about Morality? What's your read on them?

In post 1468, DrDolittle wrote:So I know my alignment. and I know rc should be generally pretty good at hunting for scum. So the fact that hes so wrong on my slot means hes more likely scum pushing for a mislynch

Don't try and get on my good side after I just called you scum lol.

I'm shifting him back to null. I liked some of his posts 10 pages ago before I went offline

In post 1470, RCEnigma wrote:Don't try and get on my good side after I just called you scum lol.

What good side? What I miss

Ftr I was just about to say that I wasn't sure I wanted to actually lynch you anymore.

VOTE: Tarkus

Maybe this?

I'm having trouble pinning down the non-Morality scum.

I gotta be really careful here because I think flipping town D1 could domino effect to my reads being ignored and town losing.

Shoshin, CoA, everyone else, what are your reads on all of {Vedith, Morality, Yellowsnow, DDL, Tarkus}