Mafiascum.net

In post 1447, ClarkBar wrote:

In post 1440, Battle Mage wrote:The mafia PT when we replaced in was hilarious, I think it was just Blopp and Homura going "shit, what do we do now?" If they come back to the site, they can claim an unbeaten record though, Looker and I definitely gave scum a better chance here.

Yeah, I'm 2 for 2 on newbie games where the scum team are highly experienced players that replace in. Probably good for learning purposes I suppose. Can't wait for that scum chat!

In post 1447, ClarkBar wrote:

In post 1440, Battle Mage wrote:The mafia PT when we replaced in was hilarious, I think it was just Blopp and Homura going "shit, what do we do now?" If they come back to the site, they can claim an unbeaten record though, Looker and I definitely gave scum a better chance here.

Yeah, I'm 2 for 2 on newbie games where the scum team are highly experienced players that replace in. Probably good for learning purposes I suppose. Can't wait for that scum chat!

In post 1451, JamSV wrote:

In post 1447, ClarkBar wrote:

In post 1440, Battle Mage wrote:The mafia PT when we replaced in was hilarious, I think it was just Blopp and Homura going "shit, what do we do now?" If they come back to the site, they can claim an unbeaten record though, Looker and I definitely gave scum a better chance here.

Yeah, I'm 2 for 2 on newbie games where the scum team are highly experienced players that replace in. Probably good for learning purposes I suppose. Can't wait for that scum chat!

I've lost 3 out of 3.

In post 1436, Looker wrote:

In post 1432, Battle Mage wrote:

In post 1428, Porkens wrote:No problem

I didn’t read too closely after being eliminated, but it seems you all had fun. Probs to BM for having the energy to spew all those words as scum.

haha yes, my typical scumplay is just to shamelessly lurk.

Spoiler:

In post 1440, Battle Mage wrote:

In post 1383, JamSV wrote:Another game where lurkers and the obvscum win. Town has actual cases against scum but they are ignored. Oh well.

Don't think this is a fair reflection at all.

In post 1392, Nahdia wrote:GG all. I appreciated seeing everyone playing hard this game, it's all you can ask for as a moderator really. TTJT, I'll say that the first time I mishammered in LYLO was pretty soulcrushing, but it's a rite of passage we all go through. You only get better!

Big ups to the mafia team for informing me when JamSV accidentally selfvoted in LYLO and asked me how I was going to handle it rather than just blitzing. Like I said, I think going forward I'll put a rule in my ruleset that votes inside broke quote tags won't be counted, but not having that rule to begin with made it an ambiguous situation and there are mods who would have ended the game there. So I appreciate them giving the opportunity to play it out.

In fairness, TTJT didn't mishammer, 72offsuit did (somehow!?).

And the Jam accidental self-vote was a really interesting situation. I think you made the right call as Mod to disallow it, but I think it was problematic to confirm that in the thread after the situation had already resolved itself. It would have been better for the game to leave that ambiguity there, and I'm never mad about Mods weighing in on something in the thread which can affect people's judgements about alignment. As I noted in the scum PT, your public response to the question from Jam and 72o which stated an unequivocal position illegitimately damaged my argument that I could have arguably hammered in that spot because of the ambiguity. It would have been a good thing to clarify after the game I think (as it was unlikely the situation would arise again).

In post 1393, Nahdia wrote:I feel bad for Blopp. She seemed so excited to play here, and her spirit was crushed so quickly! I do wish she had told me she was flaking rather than just disappearing like that though and forcing me to go through prodding her and all. Perhaps next time I get newbies that roll goon I should provide some more encouragement.

On that note, also big thanks to everyone who replaced in.

I don't know if this applies to anyone here, but if any of you who were newbies haven't tried out the other queues, I encourage you to do so. I'm happy to answer questions about the other queues if you have any. Or anything else about the site, really. I hope to see you around in other games.

The mafia PT when we replaced in was hilarious, I think it was just Blopp and Homura going "shit, what do we do now?" If they come back to the site, they can claim an unbeaten record though, Looker and I definitely gave scum a better chance here.

Thanks again Nahdia, was a really good game!