In post 1378, Titus wrote:Personal attacks are not ok, regardless of alignment. I just want to say that.
Scum is still jjh.
i think vax's reaction to being wagoned over jjh is hardclearing for jjh
Look at Vax's reaction in Booneytunes and tell me that again.
@Nancy, I'm not scum. I am sorry you felt attacked.
i think it's evidence towards jjh being town. but it's not hardclearing, Vax seemed annoyed at being run up but there was no particular ire towards jjh that i thought couldn't have been faked.
better evidence for jjh town would be voteparking Vax all day and not doing anything to find an alternative.
I know strategically never eliminate the guilter before the guilty though.
While I am like 99.9% sure jjh is scum, it should be asked though...any chance of S v S?
pretty much this. besides the SvS thing.
unrelated to this post, i lean town on Titus. i'm not seeing her trying to subtly control the game the way she
tends
to as scum, and i don't think the way she's handled her VCA this game counts as that, either.
coming from the perspective of someone who also suspected jjh first overnight after double-ISOing him with Vax, even though i now think he's more likely town.
i also think scum Titus does more to actively try and dismantle the earlier wagon on me so she can claim cred for it later, instead of simply calling me town while not actively doing any defending.
Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2021 5:27 pm
by Raya36
Who do you think is scum then? You seem to have almost everyone as town
In post 1378, Titus wrote:Personal attacks are not ok, regardless of alignment. I just want to say that.
Scum is still jjh.
i think vax's reaction to being wagoned over jjh is hardclearing for jjh
Look at Vax's reaction in Booneytunes and tell me that again.
@Nancy, I'm not scum. I am sorry you felt attacked.
i think it's evidence towards jjh being town. but it's not hardclearing, Vax seemed annoyed at being run up but there was no particular ire towards jjh that i thought couldn't have been faked.
better evidence for jjh town would be voteparking Vax all day and not doing anything to find an alternative.
Vax never had any ire towards Bell in Booneytunes either.
Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2021 6:15 pm
by Chara
In post 1452, Raya36 wrote:Who do you think is scum then? You seem to have almost everyone as town
Red and kitty, possibly still Misty.
there is the possibility of being wrong on Titus as well, but i'm not sure how i'd quantify it against the possibility of being wrong on my other townreads. excepting the top three, but i'm actually not sure about bob anymore, though that is likely more to do with the passing of time than my initial thought being wrong.
Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2021 6:16 pm
by Chara
In post 1453, Titus wrote:Vax never had any ire towards Bell in Booneytunes either.
In post 1378, Titus wrote:Personal attacks are not ok, regardless of alignment. I just want to say that.
Scum is still jjh.
i think vax's reaction to being wagoned over jjh is hardclearing for jjh
Look at Vax's reaction in Booneytunes and tell me that again.
@Nancy, I'm not scum. I am sorry you felt attacked.
I’m not efforting this much, I need actual links/quotes.
I accept your apology because I actually do believe it’s sincere. I actually do think you’re scum however but I really do appreciate this regardless. <3
Posted: Fri Jan 15, 2021 7:42 pm
by Smoke and Mirrors
In post 1438, Titus wrote:I probably should have used hurt tags rather than an outright vote on Nancy.
That definitely would have been smarter or even better, just rebuke me with neither. I know what a concept. right?
can we fastforward this if Red isn't going to say anything and it's just going to make any other discussion pointless?
Hope it's not TvT, oh well if it is not like anything is going to happen other than the big ole pile on
I honestly don’t see how. Red claimed a hard and very specific guilty on Chara who hard claimed a role that makes zero sense with that guilty.
I actually think Vax/Chara/Titus
and if that’s wrong, probably
Vax/Chara/Mistyx
but there’s so many weird things pointing to Titus: the aesetic claim. Aesetic anything is usually not a town modifier. Vax’s strange read on her. Titus’ uberscummy jump on me. Vax/Chara/Titus shade on jjh, all 3 pushing the twins. In Boon uPick, scum!Titus voted Chk who was 3P scum for being “toxic” but in Gameshow, town!Titus never voted Moongrass for that, she merely rebuked her.
I hard tr jjh and he sounds extremely similar here to CoD. Do you agree with that @Gamma?
I still think Mistyx has high scum equity but only if Titus flips town which I no longer expect to happen. I don’t believe town!Titus ever opportunistically jumps on me the way she did and the fact that she’s making a point of mentioning that, considering that’s not what even upset me is very interesting. I think she had me in her pocket and now she’s scrambling to get me back in it. As if saying using HURT tags would have made that much a difference, in a plurality game right at daystart. Why would that make a huge difference? Either one looked extremely scummy in addition to her egregiously blowing it up.
What wouldn’t have? One - only one comment of her critiquing me for that, then dropping it. No vote, no hurt tags. . That would have looked townie to me and reasonable.
In post 1378, Titus wrote:Personal attacks are not ok, regardless of alignment. I just want to say that.
Scum is still jjh.
i think vax's reaction to being wagoned over jjh is hardclearing for jjh
Look at Vax's reaction in Booneytunes and tell me that again.
@Nancy, I'm not scum. I am sorry you felt attacked.
i think it's evidence towards jjh being town. but it's not hardclearing, Vax seemed annoyed at being run up but there was no particular ire towards jjh that i thought couldn't have been faked.
better evidence for jjh town would be voteparking Vax all day and not doing anything to find an alternative.
@Chara why does scum!Red make this post? It’s suicide if he’s scum.
I also don’t believe your 180 wrt your reaction to Red guilty as well as your sudden read change on jjh. And why would scum!Titus try to dismantle your wagon but town!Titus wouldn’t? Why wouldn’t she if she honestly believed you were town here?
I think you’re scum and your buddy Titus is washing her hands of what she sees as a very obvious sinking ship, kind’ve how she hammered Vax.
There is also the glaring omission of what town!Titus is NOT doing and the complete absence of what I’d expect her to be doing here, further convonces me I’m not wrong here.
In post 1452, Raya36 wrote:Who do you think is scum then? You seem to have almost everyone as town
Red and kitty, possibly still Misty.
there is the possibility of being wrong on Titus as well, but i'm not sure how i'd quantify it against the possibility of being wrong on my other townreads. excepting the top three, but i'm actually not sure about bob anymore, though that is likely more to do with the passing of time than my initial thought being wrong.
Looks like Red was reaction testing Chara and they failed. Apparently Red is some form of gunsmith, so had Chara claimed something like vig, there would likely have been no guilty.
Posted: Sat Jan 16, 2021 3:05 am
by jjh927
I think you're reading too much into it
Posted: Sat Jan 16, 2021 3:06 am
by jjh927
It is a hard guilty and Red doesn't want to make the specifics known
That's okay
Posted: Sat Jan 16, 2021 4:03 am
by Smoke and Mirrors
Perhaps. It was pretty obviously a hard guilty even before this.
Anyway, I think Titus saying that instead of voting me, she should have put it into HURT tags, reads scummy af to me, since what I was upset at her for was her making multiple posts shaming me for pretty much nothing but she makes it a point of saying that and Chara’s spending way too much effort in defending her, then once again waffles on her.