Mafiascum.net

In post 1442, RLotus wrote:Andre and midway are my favorite kills. Elements is next best. Italiano, Dunn, Harumi are meh but ok.

I mentioned Harumi/maxi here, but yeah they've been pretty much ghost

Town
{Datisi, Italiano, Andre}
{Midwaybear, GC}
{VPB, RTB, Battle Mage}
{Duchess, Dunn}
{Rlotus, Maxwell}
Scum

so why did you not vote for either of your favorite kill options?

In post 1452, Elements wrote:so why did you not vote for either of your favorite kill options?

Trying to compromise at this point

Why do you have maxwell at the bottom?

never liked the Harumi slot
maxwell has dome nothing to change that. in fact, done nothing at all

what changed for you when you went from saying basically nothing to suddenly say a lot?

In post 1451, Elements wrote:Town
{Datisi, Italiano, Andre}
{Midwaybear, GC}
{VPB, RTB, Battle Mage}
{Duchess, Dunn}
{Rlotus, Maxwell}
Scum

may i inquire about the change of the position of my slot

So you had Harumi at the bottom in your last read list, checks out

In post 1456, Elements wrote:what changed for you when you went from saying basically nothing to suddenly say a lot?

Needed to step away a bit. I've been in the trenches all game.

VOTE: maxwell

you know what let's try it

people are generally ambivalent towards you. you're sort of sitting there in the middle of game impact. No one's pushed for you. You're towny enough that scum haven't bothered to push you but not so towny they need to try discredit you. Idk I'm spouting nonsense, vibes.

i actually unironically like 1442? like i was thinking of dropping a lotus vote and the dude just does That. also looking at the proposed blocc/poe, it's making me think either he's town coming to his senses or he's scum and there's multiple scumfucks inside that townblocc which is why he's willing to drop it there and we're fucked. given i'm ~town on p much everyone inside it other than maybe lotus himself? idk fam.

In post 1461, Elements wrote:people are generally ambivalent towards you. you're sort of sitting there in the middle of game impact. No one's pushed for you. You're towny enough that scum haven't bothered to push you but not so towny they need to try discredit you. Idk I'm spouting nonsense, vibes.

frankly i have no idea how this translates to a townread but i will admit that last sentence is a big mood

baltar is being town irl

In post 1427, Reformed Toxic Player wrote:VOTE: vpb

can i ask the vpb question

oh, if you think italiano's vote/progression on you is bad why are you lurkerwagoning duchess?

actually elements, gonna ask about italiano and andres too

bc i'm reskimming italiano's iso rn and i don't think i see it, chief

Datisi, what's the bullet point case on Italiano scum?

In post 1466, VP Baltar wrote:Datisi, what's the bullet point case on Italiano scum?

- i don't think i've felt genuine solving from him this game

- his way of dismissing/shading me gives me vibes of scum who wants to scumread me but doesn't know how / doesn't want me to get back on their ass again - like for the amount of things he implies are scummy about me i don't see how he can have me as lolnull

- i got a Performative vibe from some of his posts (e.g. ) that's trying to make it appear there's more to his thoughts than there actually is

- also i'm reskimming some isos and i cannot follow his vote onto rtp at all - i agree the jumpiness (or however you call it) doesn't necessarily make rtp town but saying it's full on scummy? agreed some play have been strange but? why is it scummy? like i also thought the readslist thing was strange but the explanation was fine? what explanations did he not like?

In post 1467, Datisi wrote:- his way of dismissing/shading me gives me vibes of scum who wants to scumread me but doesn't know how / doesn't want me to get back on their ass again - like for the amount of things he implies are scummy about me i don't see how he can have me as lolnull

Which posts of his do you feel like he is implying you're scummy?

Just a few examples is fine

In post 1442, RLotus wrote:A townblock of {Me, BM, RTP, VPB, Datisi, Duchess, GC} probably just wins the game.

This is like the avengers if true. IDK if I'm quite ready to jump in on this town bloc yet.

That being said, I feel fairly comfortable with Datisi, BM, RTP at the moment.

In post 1468, VP Baltar wrote:

In post 1467, Datisi wrote:- his way of dismissing/shading me gives me vibes of scum who wants to scumread me but doesn't know how / doesn't want me to get back on their ass again - like for the amount of things he implies are scummy about me i don't see how he can have me as lolnull

Which posts of his do you feel like he is implying you're scummy?

i went to look for these but i opened my own iso instead of italiano's, and it took me a good 5 seconds to figure out why italiano's posts aren't appearing on the screen

anyway

615 gives me the vibe of shading me for not giving him the same ~benefit of the doubt~ that i apparently want for myself
which i did call out at the time (618), i don't think i got a response

In post 810, ItalianoVD wrote:

In post 663, Datisi wrote:1./5. the game is dead because 4-5 people are barely playing or not playing at all and the moderator had abandoned us for half a week too. wow.

The fact that it doesn't at least somewhat frustrate you or allow you to understand why someone else would be frustrated by it is telling to me.

i was calling out the "this game is dead, i can't figure it out" thing as blatantly obvious to figure out, and his conclusion from that is that it's weird that i'm not frustrated by it (which is false and i never said that but besides the point) and that it's "telling" to him. what's it telling?

In post 1188, ItalianoVD wrote:You scumreading me for your reasons are goofy to me, but I’m not gonna change your mind and I’m not gonna try to, I’m gonna move on.

and this just, like ok my reasons are "goofy". am i scum bullshitting? am i a townie making a mistake? nah my reasons are just goofy he's not gonna try to change my mind

pedit: dude i am trying i'm braindead again give me a bit

In post 1471, Datisi wrote:

In post 1468, VP Baltar wrote:

In post 1467, Datisi wrote:- his way of dismissing/shading me gives me vibes of scum who wants to scumread me but doesn't know how / doesn't want me to get back on their ass again - like for the amount of things he implies are scummy about me i don't see how he can have me as lolnull

Which posts of his do you feel like he is implying you're scummy?

i went to look for these but i opened my own iso instead of italiano's, and it took me a good 5 seconds to figure out why italiano's posts aren't appearing on the screen

anyway

615 gives me the vibe of shading me for not giving him the same ~benefit of the doubt~ that i apparently want for myself
which i did call out at the time (618), i don't think i got a response

In post 810, ItalianoVD wrote:

In post 663, Datisi wrote:1./5. the game is dead because 4-5 people are barely playing or not playing at all and the moderator had abandoned us for half a week too. wow.

The fact that it doesn't at least somewhat frustrate you or allow you to understand why someone else would be frustrated by it is telling to me.

i was calling out the "this game is dead, i can't figure it out" thing as blatantly obvious to figure out, and his conclusion from that is that it's weird that i'm not frustrated by it (which is false and i never said that but besides the point) and that it's "telling" to him. what's it telling?

In post 1188, ItalianoVD wrote:You scumreading me for your reasons are goofy to me, but I’m not gonna change your mind and I’m not gonna try to, I’m gonna move on.

and this just, like ok my reasons are "goofy". am i scum bullshitting? am i a townie making a mistake? nah my reasons are just goofy he's not gonna try to change my mind

pedit: dude i am trying i'm braindead again give me a bit

Ok, thanks. I can see that from your perspective. I guess there is a certain aloofness to Italiano's play that gives me pause on a scum read, but if I was in your shoes I'd probably find it more scummy than I do.

The second post you cite does indeed look bad.

I hate that I started this day super confident in my reads, and now everything is mush.

In post 1464, Datisi wrote:baltar is being town irl

In post 1427, Reformed Toxic Player wrote:VOTE: vpb

can i ask the vpb question

oh, if you think italiano's vote/progression on you is bad why are you lurkerwagoning duchess?

I was like just frustrated voting idk where scum is anymore rly I'm kinda just having trouble