Mafiascum.net

My plan was to neiborize everyone and claim we are now immortal.

But now i turned in pewpewpewpew.

Just a few comments on balance:

1) I think the impact of being able to speak after death was underestimated quite a bit. I think that's the biggest flaw in the setup's balance. Mafia did receive this benefit too however.
2) The traffic analyst role honestly did a lot better than I expected. We basically agreed in review that it was a fairly weak role given the neighborhood chaos.
3) While we expected some kind of neighborhood massclaim early on, we didn't expect such open communication of information between the neighborhoods.
4) The scum slip cleared a bunch of people and certainly didn't help the setup's balance.
5) I will be hosting a Web of Lies 2 in the near future due to the scum slip. It won't be the same setup. If you have suggestions, please fill out my survey.

Would’ve been weaker had it not been modified, basically a meme role.

A scum slip aside, this game was very townsided. I tried to play to win up until Strange Matter didn't die and then Dunn was a Friendly Neighbour... and then....


Look the scumslip made the result much more heavily obvious but... I don't think scum wins this game.

In post 1451, Ircher wrote:Just a few comments on balance:

1) I think the impact of being able to speak after death was underestimated quite a bit. I think that's the biggest flaw in the setup's balance. Mafia did receive this benefit too however.
2) The traffic analyst role honestly did a lot better than I expected. We basically agreed in review that it was a fairly weak role given the neighborhood chaos.
3) While we expected some kind of neighborhood massclaim early on, we didn't expect such open communication of information between the neighborhoods.
4) The scum slip cleared a bunch of people and certainly didn't help the setup's balance.
5) I will be hosting a Web of Lies 2 in the near future due to the scum slip. It won't be the same setup. If you have suggestions, please fill out my survey.

My suggestions having had been scum and town as a game without an actual night, treat it like a 1 shot cop for balance reasons. For players used to hoods such as me, it’s not as bad, but if players aren’t used to eternal hood games it has major town swing.

That’s what I can think of off the top of my head.

In post 1453, Lady Lambdadelta wrote:A scum slip aside, this game was very townsided. I tried to play to win up until Strange Matter didn't die and then Dunn was a Friendly Neighbour... and then....


Look the scumslip made the result much more heavily obvious but... I don't think scum wins this game.

Agreed. I think this probably was way too townsided

Protectives should be nerfed or banned in talk after death games

Gg, Bell I'm glad we managed to not miselim you along the way!

In post 1445, MathBlade wrote:Deploying hugs.

I am sorry LLD.

I did what I could to give you a fair shake but yeah this needs words after work.

I am sorry for what House did and how he tried to use me as a token.
That’s 100% not fair to you at all.

I can’t sneak a good lengthy response in.

It’s not fair to both LLD & you.

Like the fuck.

I love you both, but House that was totally uncalled for. Especially to use Math in that to try to make an insult feel ‘better’ and even worse is Math is someone you consider your friend.

The main reason is mostly fatigue

Scum have an uphill battle in that the dead can talk after they die.
Leaving in the possibility of no death at night just extends that fatigue.
Instead of a doctor I would use something like a Vanillizer that acts before the check. I would have to chew through the ramifications.

Things about balance, the scum slip definitely did not help.

Also, I think we got more benefit from StrangeMatter's ability then would have happened in 90% of this game being ran. She happened to be in the largest street hood, giving her the biggest chance of having any targets, AND the career hoods lined up for her, AND both of her valid targets happened to be neighborizors that we could coordinate making sure they worked.

I think simply having 4 career choices that were equally appealing would have caused her to have ~0-1 targets she could invest

... Who insulted who?

I don't remember House insulting anyone.

In post 1457, Malakittens wrote:

In post 1445, MathBlade wrote:Deploying hugs.

I am sorry LLD.

I did what I could to give you a fair shake but yeah this needs words after work.

I am sorry for what House did and how he tried to use me as a token.
That’s 100% not fair to you at all.

I can’t sneak a good lengthy response in.

It’s not fair to both LLD & you.

Like the fuck.

I love you both, but House that was totally uncalled for. Especially to use Math in that to try to make an insult feel ‘better’ and even worse is Math is someone you consider your friend.

It’s not but I have to work now
But I wanted to make sure LLD knew I cared and tried before I have to disappear

In post 1458, MathBlade wrote:The main reason is mostly fatigue

Scum have an uphill battle in that the dead can talk after they die.
Leaving in the possibility of no death at night just extends that fatigue.
Instead of a doctor I would use something like a Vanillizer that acts before the check. I would have to chew through the ramifications.

Did we have a doctor?

I thought both doc claims were the scum team lol

Yeah the moment House used Math, someone I have a close bond with, as a way to try and explain away his actions, it made it hurt more cause I knew math would be hurt?

And then he replaced into the game and had to live in this world too?

I hated it.

In post 1461, MathBlade wrote:

In post 1457, Malakittens wrote:

In post 1445, MathBlade wrote:Deploying hugs.

I am sorry LLD.

I did what I could to give you a fair shake but yeah this needs words after work.

I am sorry for what House did and how he tried to use me as a token.
That’s 100% not fair to you at all.

I can’t sneak a good lengthy response in.

It’s not fair to both LLD & you.

Like the fuck.

I love you both, but House that was totally uncalled for. Especially to use Math in that to try to make an insult feel ‘better’ and even worse is Math is someone you consider your friend.

It’s not but I have to work now
But I wanted to make sure LLD knew I cared and tried before I have to disappear

The love is felt. You did your dilligence. <3

In post 1460, Enchant wrote:... Who insulted who?

I don't remember House insulting anyone.

I don't think there is a need to talk it through again. House was banned for it, so if you want to know you can look it up that way.

In post 1463, Lady Lambdadelta wrote:Yeah the moment House used Math, someone I have a close bond with, as a way to try and explain away his actions, it made it hurt more cause I knew math would be hurt?

And then he replaced into the game and had to live in this world too?

I hated it.

Yeah. I took the slot without realizing the ban thread or reading because I thought it would be a fun hood game. That’s entirely my bad. I just like hood games.

That being said imho it would have been worse to have someone else replace in then tell me after

The review, mod, and dead thread have been released. If you would like to help review or pre-in for take 2, please pm me.

In post 1443, Ircher wrote: Noraa - Town Macho Doctor (N1 Strong-Willed Mass Neighborizer) Neighb

Omg

How is this real.

I was sure that was a meme claim

In post 1459, Lukewarm wrote:Things about balance, the scum slip definitely did not help.

Also, I think we got more benefit from StrangeMatter's ability then would have happened in 90% of this game being ran. She happened to be in the largest street hood, giving her the biggest chance of having any targets, AND the career hoods lined up for her, AND both of her valid targets happened to be neighborizors that we could coordinate making sure they worked.

I think simply having 4 career choices that were equally appealing would have caused her to have ~0-1 targets she could invest

I likely wouldn't have known how to use my role at all until it was explained how by Lukewarm, and information was given from others. Plus knowing the PTs from what people have said helped a lot more to figure out who to target from that.

Also, if a scum mass neighborizor had fired night 1/2 they could have used it offensively to stop strange's invests without increminating themselves by just not claiming to be the mass neighborizor

Just letting you know both of you, LLD & Math, my PMs are open if you need

Love you both.

The heck did I miss?

GG?? lol

In post 1472, Flea The Magician wrote:The heck did I miss?

GG?? lol

Welcome back flea! We won!

Flea Gg House is scum who lost and everyone else won!

Yes I can’t read but I am going with this.
LLD and Enchant don’t deserve the L