NanookTheWolf wrote:I'd really like to hear a little something more from Cadmium, I can't recall if he is on holiday or not, but I know that he hasn't posted since like page 1 ...
Dragon Phoenix wrote:Happy with my vote on Cadmium, given his inactivity.
Here, DP's reason to keep his vote on me was purely based on Nanook's post (which wasn't correct either). Had he looked for inactivity himself, he would have found out that niMic was the inactive one. Simply following someone else seems scummy to me. Also, jumping on any other bandwagon (StevieT92, niMic or Maximus) would have made him look scummier so this was the best way to stay low.
Dragon Phoenix wrote:The consequent misspelling perk/park does not give me a good feeling: it sounds like a mistake a scumbag would make who made up a role after some googling. I'm sure the mod would use perk.
After Maximus' claim, DP was the first to question the misspelling which caused the lynch of Gunther. Scum uses inconsistencies in a role claim to question it. Had maximus really googled it, he would have gotten it right for sure. Also noticable is the way DP brings it up, waits for other input and then immediately votes after Nanook said that he was happy with his vote on Maximus.
niMic wrote:What just happened? Did the doctor save the mafia target, and a vig killed a mafia? Or could a role-blocker be involved? Either way, I guess we have a vig, unless the mafia wanted to kill one of their own.
Dragon Phoenix wrote:A vig? A serial killer? A target switcher? Two mafia groups?
This is the one of the two more interesting posts, IMO. niMic suggests a vigilante and DP doesn't state the obvious right away (SK & mafia), instead he lists about every possibility. This post, to me, says that there's a fair chance of DP being the SK trying to confuse the town. It's difficult to explain what I mean exactly, but something in this comment alerted me.
Dragon Phoenix wrote:So we have a claimed doc (Stevie) who survives the night? Hmmmm. Double bluff by the scum? By BOTH killer groups? Or expecting that the other group would do the job?
olio wrote:Only one explanation Dragon Phoenix didn't bring up for Joey being alive is that Joey could be a SK.
Again, a list with possibilities, only this time he forgot to bring up the SK possibility. One wonders why. Is it because he
knows
that's not an option? Then again, mentioning it might attract too much attention (Olio got FOS'ed for it too). 'Hmmmm' is a better way to address it, the others will do the rest (as you can see). Keep the double bluff comment in mind too!
Dragon Phoenix wrote:I think he's trying a double bluff with his butchered role claim.
There it is again. Just too many double bluff suggestions for my likings. And again, trying to use an inconsistency in a role claim to question it. And again, first posting to say it's not likely scum would change claim and unvoting, but when it turns out that olio and mepmuff are having serious doubts, jumping right on again (similar to the Maximus lynch).
Vote: Dragon Phoenix
Just a hunch
! That and I've read a lot of other useful things in the thread which helped me deduce some likely innocents. I don't think DP is any of Ross, Rachel or Phoebe. So I think this is the best way to go today.
"OH MY GOD, Cadmium! I can make rye bread! You must be innocent, I'll do whatever you tell me!" exclaims Mackay excitedly. - Jeep, Mini Game 9