Page 7 of 38
Posted: Mon Aug 19, 2013 12:45 am
by Cheery Dog
Smoker | RachMarie | A Simple Plan | | | | 2 |
VT | notscience | Ms Marangal | | | | 2 |
A Simple Plan | VT | | | | | 1 |
thenewearth | Prophylaxis | | | | | 1 |
Not Voting thenewearth CityElectric Smoker
With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch Deadline
(expired on 2013-08-29 07:00:00)
Prophylaxis is on V/LA from 18/8 until 21/8
Posted: Mon Aug 19, 2013 3:02 am
by notscience
@ASP
'
If you look at my history of games, you'll find I don't ever have a problem with where my vote is (I selfvote and all that other stuff for reactions sometimes, (although selfvotes are bad :<)) and vote townreads or conftown just to see how others react
He's also definate newbtown for the last bit.
Posted: Mon Aug 19, 2013 12:54 pm
by Ms Marangal
In post 147, Smoker wrote:though all the while town-reading everyone I'd town-read, which is suggestive of her just being scared of me as scum.
...
First off, I made my list of reads before you did and I haven't deterred from that yet
Second off, Why would I be scared of a noob?
I'll attack those who know me the best as scum, Fear isn't a part of my scum game. all My SE's can attest to this
I also wouldn't mind it if one of them stated my AtE Policy, it'll prolly mean alot more coming from them than from me.
I'll come back tomorrow
Posted: Mon Aug 19, 2013 1:38 pm
by Smoker
>I'll come back tomorrow
VOTE: Mara
Posted: Mon Aug 19, 2013 1:47 pm
by thenewearth
Smoker, what?
Posted: Mon Aug 19, 2013 2:13 pm
by Smoker
Mara, that part was actually directed at CE, but good job dodging my entire post. And I'm obviously not a noob now, am I? ;D
Posted: Mon Aug 19, 2013 3:01 pm
by notscience
Mara thinks AtE is a scumtell
jk she thinks it's a null tell but it's more fun to say she thinks it's a scumtell
Posted: Mon Aug 19, 2013 3:09 pm
by A Simple Plan
In post 152, Ms Marangal wrote: In post 147, Smoker wrote:though all the while town-reading everyone I'd town-read, which is suggestive of her just being scared of me as scum.
...
First off, I made my list of reads before you did and I haven't deterred from that yet
Second off, Why would I be scared of a noob?
I'll attack those who know me the best as scum, Fear isn't a part of my scum game. all My SE's can attest to this
I also wouldn't mind it if one of them stated my AtE Policy, it'll prolly mean alot more coming from them than from me.
I'll come back tomorrow
This post just reads weird. Ms M says that she's not afraid of Smoker, and then specifies in her very next line that she doesn't get afraid as scum? Erm... What? I will admit, smoker dropping a vote on her after that post actually feels town-motivated... I'm starting to have second thoughts on him right now.
That last post by Notscience (151) is giving me a slight town feel to him though I'm definitely not sure about that. Keeping an eye on him.
P-Edit: I kinda agree with Ms M though on AtE being somewhat of a null tell more than town or scum, but I haven't seen enough of it in the past to be sure. Not fond of seeing people use it.
156 was too jokey for my liking, NS. What are your thoughts on AtE?
Posted: Mon Aug 19, 2013 3:15 pm
by Smoker
AtE is a null tell, sure, but I'm a logical dude and she's not approaching me on the field of logic whatsoever. I mean, she just dodged the entirety of my analysis...
Posted: Mon Aug 19, 2013 3:49 pm
by notscience
Lmfao
I am ALWAYS jokey.
I can't say it's a scumtell because I do it all the time as either alignment
It depends on the situation
Posted: Mon Aug 19, 2013 4:01 pm
by notscience
And ASP you're misrepping like crazy
Posted: Mon Aug 19, 2013 8:43 pm
by thenewearth
Prod dodge.
If anyone needs me just holler up
Posted: Tue Aug 20, 2013 1:09 am
by notscience
TNE
Care to actually do stuff
Posted: Tue Aug 20, 2013 4:58 am
by Smoker
These game seems to have been pretty much abandoned. Good game, guys. Well played.
Posted: Tue Aug 20, 2013 6:12 am
by notscience
Smoker, some people aren't spam posters like you and myself.
It's not over until the fat lady sings. (or CD says so)
Posted: Tue Aug 20, 2013 6:19 am
by RachMarie
wait I am supposed to sing? Nobody told me that
Smoker one of the reasons for the longer days is to allow people to play a bit then go do other things then come back and play a bit.
If you want activity to increase then instead of complaining, why not ask questions and put pressure on people?
Posted: Tue Aug 20, 2013 6:21 am
by RachMarie
tne
Give me one reason why I should not vote you now? Seriously prod dodge?
There has been a fair bit of activity so far you have no thoughts at all yet?
Posted: Tue Aug 20, 2013 6:22 am
by notscience
Rach he does that like everywhere
So any lynch on him is essentially a PL
Posted: Tue Aug 20, 2013 6:22 am
by notscience
It's not a great example :L
Posted: Tue Aug 20, 2013 8:31 am
by CityElectric
In post 134, VT wrote:
Can we look at more suspicious people like CE and Simple plan though?
Great
reads, all of you. Care to explain? (Yes, do me a favour and explain again if you already have, because I occasionally fail reading and I have the memory of a goldfish)
RE: Smoker's
Post 147: Not a bad post, but virtually useless right now. There are so many associative tells that in order for it to have any use, Mara needs to be confirmed scum. Which she isn't until she's lynched and flips scum.
Posted: Tue Aug 20, 2013 8:43 am
by notscience
VT saw people townreading Smoker who was saying "I'm town" or the likes and tried to say "Well look at other suspicious people" which is like "I'm not the ONLY suspicious one why are we all bullying me" which is a scummy mindset
ASP is just flipfloppy and scummy as fuck
Posted: Tue Aug 20, 2013 2:11 pm
by thenewearth
In post 163, Smoker wrote:These game seems to have been pretty much abandoned. Good game, guys. Well played.
Stop posting too much.
In post 15, VT wrote:Hi Everyone
I'm new here but I've played some mafia before in real life which is quite a bit different but the same concept I think. Hope to be fun playing with you guys!
VOTE: notscience
VT have you seen the other votes on notscience? Running someone up to L-1 on page 1 will DEFINITELY give prick me.
Were you serious when asking this?
In post 21, Smoker wrote:Pretty sure notscience is PR actually, so... how do I unvote?
Yeah, notscience is townie PR being buddied my Ms Marangal who's mafia right now.
I mean, notscience is scummy as f
WTF? REALLY?!
In post 37, Smoker wrote:And VT actually seems town to me to be honest. And I'm still on notscience for weird town, dunno where the 'y so serious' came from, though. Meh.
So RM and... prophy. Also newearthguy.
VOTE: RM
Wishy washy with your reads, eh?
In post 39, A Simple Plan wrote:UNVOTE:
Alright, a few alarms are going off for me reading Smoker's posts.
-His 17 is suspicious, watching NS go to L-1 and right away asking for a claim despite being on the wagon and being unable to declare intent (which, on page one, would be incredibly bad play anyway).
-in his 21, he specifies he thinks NS is "scummy as f", and then in 24, not an hour later, he jumps on a MM vote that I made as a RVS vote, declaring in the process he believed NS to be town and VT mafia. NS's most relevant comment was wanting to "see how much further the wagon on (NS) would go" so we would "have a wagon to analyze". That still has me suspicious of NS as well.
-his 32 and 35 calling VT a troll in an attempt to draw out an angry and/or incriminating response seems rather crude, and resorting to insults such as that is, IMO, bad and unethical play.
-his 37 is an OMGUS vote in response to RM's 30, and in an effort not to quote RM here, that isn't a good sign. Definitely vote worthy.
VOTE: Smoker
Simple Plan is town.
Add the fact that you have stated that you "Towntold"
I don't care if he said it "for lolz"
Anyone could say that.
I don't buy it
You've been after MM since page 1. Yet I don't really see a SOLID vote on her.
Anyways...
VOTE: Smoker
Posted: Tue Aug 20, 2013 2:50 pm
by Smoker
You guys realize Ms Marangal is just not posting in this game anymore, right? And she's posted in others. She seems to be running away from this one.
Excellent post by the way, TNE.
Posted: Tue Aug 20, 2013 3:06 pm
by Ms Marangal
In post 156, notscience wrote:Mara thinks AtE is a scumtell
jk she thinks it's a null tell but it's more fun to say she thinks it's a scumtell
You disappoint me ns
I think AtE is a inherent town-tell. there are some people who are able to use it to their advantage as scum, however, how it is usually applied it's used for town
In post 158, Smoker wrote:AtE is a null tell, sure, but I'm a logical dude and she's not approaching me on the field of logic whatsoever. I mean, she just dodged the entirety of my analysis...
Fuck logic.
I could have tried to dig into that post, but it isn't worth the energy because 1v1 battles bog up the thread to the point where others aren't able to read it, but it will be TvT which is even worst.
I was typing up an analysis but my cat deleted everything so I need to type it up again.
I also didn't post here yet because I was mainly phone posting and newbie games generally deserve more than I What I give on a phone, especially my IC games
Posted: Tue Aug 20, 2013 3:10 pm
by notscience
Mara
I really hope TIP switches in to argue with you