Ugh, this isn't good.
Of the five of us remaining, here is a list of who voted on each of the ill-fated lynches:
Day 1
Armlx, Sentinel and I voted Adele.
Pooky voted kirbyphreak.
logicticus did not vote.
Day 2
Sentinel, armlx, logicticus and Pooky voted kirbyphreak.
I voted kirby, changed to Sentinel (was confused by W!nt3r's results)
Day 3
Everyone here voted W!nt3r except logicticus, who didn't vote.
Conclusion: we are all gullible. It does appear that logicticus seems the most unwilling to bandwagon, which is usually a good sign.
How the scum voted, and any interactions:
Day 1: Max votes W!nt3r.
drake votes Adele, and seems to also disbelieve W!nt3r.
W!nt3r and I FOS Max.
Day 2: Max is nightkilled. drake does not do anything.
Day 3: drake does not do anything.
So that doesn't tell us too much either... augh...