Mafiascum.net

I personally think red/green is the better way to refer to them. I use 'red' all the time.

@criticisms of the creeps wagon
Let's obviously not lynch Creeps yet when we still have 13 days to eek discussion and scumtells out of. A wagon is a convenient way to garner discussion.

Don't think anyone is advocating lynching anyone yet

@Naomi
I can see why you'd read both as green (I don't mind using this terminology if most of you prefer it, I don't find the usual ones like scum offensive though, it's just the role you were given in the game, not a value judgement of you as a person) but for me it's too early to make an informed decision.

Let's not forget the inactives.

@HS
What didn't you like in TF''s latest posts? I thought his interaction with Mort was fine (for now at least).

In post 152, copper223 wrote:@Naomi
I can see why you'd read both as green (I don't mind using this terminology if most of you prefer it, I don't find the usual ones like scum offensive though, it's just the role you were given in the game, not a value judgement of you as a person) but for me it's too early to make an informed decision.

Let's not forget the inactives.

@HS
What didn't you like in TF''s latest posts? I thought his interaction with Mort was fine (for now at least).

@Mod its cool. its the thought that counts.

I don't mind if you use your naive handles. I personally just don't want to do so. they all mean the same thing after all (as long as you make sure people know that)

No worries Key, you're doing just fine.

@copper
His ISO is pretty much empty, with a lot of safe comments and IIoA.
I think answering 'I don't have any reads' is more likely to come from scum than otherwise.

I think why Naomi has a reputation of being so hard to read because she's always acting, whether she's scum or not.

Why don't you think it's possible for town to not have reads? That's a weird opinion to have

Side note. How much mafia experience do you have?

Also I hate this no talking about ongoing game policy cause i could prove me not having reads isn't unusual for me.

@HS
That's basically why I was FOS'ing him a few pages back, but I find him being willing to admit there wasn't much going on that had pinged him, a good sign.

Copper. Thoughts on misa?

In post 156, Human Sequencer wrote:I think why Naomi has a reputation of being so hard to read because she's always acting, whether she's scum or not.

This isn't true. sorry to disappoint..

@TF
I haven't changed my mind from the last time I gave that read, I think her checking the experienced players first and noticing I had voted an inactive was an early attempt to game solve and that points at her being town.

I don't find that to match well with Chaos's point that her going back to Naomi was her bowing to and wanting to avoid pressure.

I did note the point Naomi made (which you also brought up in another way together with Uzi) that she could be scum over-pushing Creeps and that she was over-selling her outrage there but not having played with her and not knowing how volatile she usually is I put more weight in my early read.

@twoface
I didn't say town can't have no opinion. I said I believe it's more likely for scum to say they have no opinion.

This is my second game.

2nd game ever? That explains it I guess

Btw I disagree with you. I think most scum would be afraid to say they don't have reads.

Just got back from Temple. Catching up now.

In post 166, TwoFace wrote:Btw I disagree with you. I think most scum would be afraid to say they don't have reads.

Why do I feel this has scum intent?

Man I was scared of posting for a long time

In post 101, MisaTange wrote:IT'S RVS IT'S USED FOR PRESSURE AND IT'S USED TO ENCOURAGE PEOPLE TO POST AND ALSO TO THINK THEIR REASONING OUT BEFORE THEY POST AND TO PROMPT POSTS LIKE THIS 62. IT'S LITERALLY THE ONLY STAGE IN THE GAME WHERE OMGUSES AND "I VOTE HIM BECAUSE HE SMELLS BAD" VOTES ARE OKAY.

WHAT

THE

FUCK

CREEPS

YOU ARE BETTER THAN THIS.

This feels fake and very contrived.

In post 168, Creeps20 wrote:

In post 166, TwoFace wrote:Btw I disagree with you. I think most scum would be afraid to say they don't have reads.

Why do I feel this has scum intent?

Man I was scared of posting for a long time

Why were you afraid of posting?

In regards to my post above, I was attempting to put the first quote and my reply in a spoiler tag. Not sure how that happened. My apologies.

In post 168, Creeps20 wrote:

In post 166, TwoFace wrote:Btw I disagree with you. I think most scum would be afraid to say they don't have reads.

Why do I feel this has scum intent?

Man I was scared of posting for a long time

Idk. Maybe cause you are an inexperienced player.

>if you disagree with me or read me as scum you're new and stupid
lol ok

Thank you @mod, for fixing my post.