In post 97, Tchill13 wrote:If he was town he'd definitely believe his reads. No reason to give reads he doesn't believe them if he's town.In post 94, Cedrick wrote:Idk if he’s scum yet but I’m leaning that way. If he is town I don’t believe for a second he believes any of the reads he’s given.
I don't get your mindset here - you hard townread Kill because scum wouldn't be aggressive early D1, but then dislike Kill admitting he's aggressive as either alignment?In post 108, Tchill13 wrote:I don't think there's enough reason to scum read mumble. I do appreciate activity but I feel like you're definitely trying to take control of the game and I also don't like how you pointed out you could be aggressive as scum also.
This is such a blatantly scummy thing to say I'm almost thinking it's Town.In post 114, Tchill13 wrote:Early day one I'm down for any wagon that's not mine.In post 111, implosion wrote:It's very beg-the-question-y, as though it would be reasonable to nail someone as scum off of a single point. It looks like scum hedging on either a scumbuddy or on a townie and not really sure if they want to risk joining the possibly-developing wagon.In post 110, katherine wrote:What about it? Should he be drawing the same conclusion as you..?
I covered this already. Sometimes players give fake reads in rvs to generate discussion. There is literally no way he can scum read somebody off one post. His read on mumble at least in a lie. Idk about the rest of his reads. I don’t really believed his read on you either.In post 97, Tchill13 wrote:If he was town he'd definitely believe his reads. No reason to give reads he doesn't believe them if he's town.In post 94, Cedrick wrote:Idk if he’s scum yet but I’m leaning that way. If he is town I don’t believe for a second he believes any of the reads he’s given.
Why is it scummy? I’m inclined to believe it except I’ll go one further and say even a wagon on me would be fine. Wagons = pressure which = discussion which = game solving.In post 151, Luca Blight wrote:This is such a blatantly scummy thing to say
Why does having dif reads=dislike to you (I assume that means scummy as well correct me if wrong) I don't really think having dif reads is what's important it's the reasoning and if it feels genuine (as does all reads but this is basic mafia 101 talk I'm going into)In post 147, Cedrick wrote:Yes. I’m leaning scum on kts and null on tchill. I’m not excluding this being scum theater either but I don’t know if I’m ready to commit to that theory so early.In post 138, MariaR wrote:Because you disagree or?In post 135, Cedrick wrote:Maybe but I dislike him thinking both kts and chill are town.In post 130, Ausuka wrote:Alright, Creature can be town.
In post 108, Tchill13 wrote:I don't think there's enough reason to scum read mumble. I do appreciate activity but I feel like you're definitely trying to take control of the game and I also don't like how you pointed out you could be aggressive as scum also.
VOTE: Tchill
This post is objectively false.In post 151, Luca Blight wrote:I don't get your mindset here - you hard townread Kill because scum wouldn't be aggressive early D1, but then dislike Kill admitting he's aggressive as either alignment?In post 108, Tchill13 wrote:I don't think there's enough reason to scum read mumble. I do appreciate activity but I feel like you're definitely trying to take control of the game and I also don't like how you pointed out you could be aggressive as scum also.
Backwards reasoning.
This is such a blatantly scummy thing to say I'm almost thinking it's Town.In post 114, Tchill13 wrote:Early day one I'm down for any wagon that's not mine.In post 111, implosion wrote:It's very beg-the-question-y, as though it would be reasonable to nail someone as scum off of a single point. It looks like scum hedging on either a scumbuddy or on a townie and not really sure if they want to risk joining the possibly-developing wagon.In post 110, katherine wrote:What about it? Should he be drawing the same conclusion as you..?
ewIn post 157, Gamma Emerald wrote:In post 108, Tchill13 wrote:I don't think there's enough reason to scum read mumble. I do appreciate activity but I feel like you're definitely trying to take control of the game and I also don't like how you pointed out you could be aggressive as scum also.VOTE: Tchill
The point is the progression is weird: he hard townreads him for aggressiveness but then dislikes him admitting he's aggressive as either alignment - I could understand if his reaction wasIn post 158, MariaR wrote: This post is objectively false. It's not backwards reasoning because doing something andsayingsomething are 2 dif things. Acting one way is something admitting to it is something else and I think that's the case and point here.
Point 2:
How is that scummy? It's just blunt and true. Sure it's not the most optimal town play but that doesn't mean it's scummy.
Like day 1 for me I fully expect to be suspected maybe even lynched so I might just "roll with the flow"
same type of reasoning.
I’m confused. I don’t think I said I dislike him because he has different reads. I just dislike his reads because I don’t agree with them. Dislike doesn’t mean scummy, at least not in this context.In post 155, MariaR wrote:Why does having dif reads=dislike to you (I assume that means scummy as well correct me if wrong) I don't really think having dif reads is what's important it's the reasoning and if it feels genuine (as does all reads but this is basic mafia 101 talk I'm going into)
Yeah this makes sense now, but honestly Tchill is just scumIn post 112, Killthestory wrote:mumble's entrance while albeit not scummy into itself, within the context of the game, is a scummy pop in during rvs to lock a vote and leave. no sense of forming a wagon, no sense of solving, and the vote i have on him almost always hits a wolf.
What? 38 feels okay to me. Besides that what would you think of kts if Tchill is lynched and flips scum?In post 116, Ausuka wrote:Notes so far;
38 from Maria is really reachy.
44 feels pretty scummy too. 59/63 is a huge overreaction to the push at that point.
I townread Cedrick and katherine.
Creature hasn't really posted enough to be sorted yet. If this keeps going for a while he can be town.
What kts did can come from either alignment and I haven't found anything to sort him with.
Extra-Special Townbloc of Happy Friends
Ausuka, Cedrick
Candidates For Promotion
Katherine
Watchlist For Meaniness
brassherald, Creature, Gamma Emerald, Mumble, Killthestory, implosion
Wanted for Bullying and General Sad Crimes
MariaR, Tchill13
VOTE: Tchill
I'm so excited *lurks*In post 137, MariaR wrote:Why?In post 120, Creature wrote:This being Gamma's only post so far looks terrible.In post 10, Gamma Emerald wrote:VOTE: katherine
Too many already.
btw I'm super excited about this playerlist
Gamethrowing town character-claiming and giving scum extra NK for the remaining nights.In post 142, Gamma Emerald wrote:Oh man what happened thereIn post 26, Creature wrote:Feeling like Harry Potter mash MS version.
I mean 38 is based on scum not having a reason to think town are lying, as for the Havo thing I don't really know what you're scumreading?In post 117, brassherald wrote:In post 38, MariaR wrote:Both these posts feel fake to me. I really don't get the "scum takes things too seriously day 1" BS, and the Havo thing is weird as well, even if she does land on town.In post 48, MariaR wrote:
VOTE: Maria
I hate myself for this quote wall already by the way.
I feel like you're trying to connect the 2 statements as if it's similar when I don't think it is? Saying you townread someone for being aggroIn post 161, Luca Blight wrote:The point is the progression is weird: he hard townreads him for aggressiveness but then dislikes him admitting he's aggressive as either alignment - I could understand if his reaction was 'Oh, in that case I'll rescind my hard townread on you', but to say he doesn't like it implies he sees it as possibly scum-motivated - which is weird as I would have expected his natural progression here to be 'why would scum admit they shouldn't be townread for something?'.
hm While you're probtown this kinda feels a bit lazy? what do you think of Teech now?