Page 7 of 40
Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 1:37 pm
by GuyInFreezer
Vote Count 1.2
REVERSE - Dongempire, Dunnstral
HALF - Locke113, Nymph, popsofctown
LAYER - MariaR
SKIP - Azuresky
Post 103 was fixed.
Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 1:43 pm
by Elements
VOTE: half
Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 1:47 pm
by popsofctown
"Half, pair, layer" kills Dongempire and makes Azuresky unkillable as it produces "dong, Elements, MariaR, Dunnstral, Hectic, Locke, Nymph, Azuresky, pops"
Someone check if my program is working right.
Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 1:51 pm
by Elements
I think that is a bad idea
Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 1:52 pm
by popsofctown
Care to elaborate
In a manner that references people's alignments
Because I probably ought to really get back into that
Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 1:55 pm
by Elements
coz it puts me second and I don't want to be night killed
Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 1:59 pm
by popsofctown
I like "Skip" in that Nymph and Azuresky become unkillable and I think those slots are town, and the mafia lose the undo option. But I'm not really scumreading Hectic and I'm one of those players that is pickier than "nullread" for the day one lynch.
pedit: oooooh a new game now I gotta find a sequence that makes Elements unkillable too
I'm not actually townreading to where I care
but games
Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 1:59 pm
by popsofctown
*townreading him
Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 2:04 pm
by popsofctown
"layer, pair, half" kills Dongempire, bulletproofs Azuresky, and doesn't make you bulletproof, but at least forces scum to lock in their night action without having the option of locking in undo if they want to kill you. That should be plenty good enough.
I think both BPs and killing Dongempire is impossible.
Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 2:12 pm
by popsofctown
Ideally we should pick a player we want to lynch, then one other player we want the scum to have to NK. Then we pick a set of mutations that achieve that lynch and NK that player, unless we've pushed the scum into committing to their shuffle method. Which then gives us wifomable info that that second player was scum.
Elements you've been really underwhelming this game. You've usually accomplished more than this by now when you're scum. Azuresky has even nudged you. Why the naked Half votes? Why not more commentary on...everything? Two slots have lashed back at me so far, do you think I'm scum?
Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 2:14 pm
by popsofctown
Like
There might be some Elements stuff on the first six pages
But what would really matter is that I don't remember any of it
Dunnstral doing, like, a more authentic version of what he did as scum last game is making me think he's not the scum here
Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 2:30 pm
by Elements
In post 159, popsofctown wrote:Elements you've been really underwhelming this game. You've usually accomplished more than this by now when you're scum. Azuresky has even nudged you. Why the naked Half votes? Why not more commentary on...everything? Two slots have lashed back at me so far, do you think I'm scum?
I've decided to change up my play style drastically so I'm not either mislynched day one or easily set up as a day two mislynch by scum.
I was going to vote after my post explaining why I think we should do at lease one shuffle but i didn't know what the highest current method was on, so I waited for the vote count.
I think you're town.
Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 2:36 pm
by popsofctown
Day 1 mislynch meta is my old meta and it's beautiful and freeing and you should embrace it.
But, no, seriously - playing to deliberately stick near null isn't good for your winrate, in my opinion (excepting some cases involving a PR, but even then I'm skeptical). You have a harder time sorting other players and players have a harder time sorting you. And mafia's a team game, X% of the time, a teammate who didn't try to play to null is getting mislynched in your place, and who's to say they're more valuable than you are?
If you came into this game planning to play this way I'm not sure I can sway you right away, but I encourage you to consider these things.
Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 2:40 pm
by popsofctown
I'm still foggy on your reasoning for why at least one shuffle method should be used. A couple posts back you kind of hinted at it fostering discussion a la RVS votes, is that a rep or a misrep?
I think we're throwing 3-4 1-shot town bodyguard effects in the trash if we use the options one at a time instead of leashing, I'm not sure I can swallow that pill. UNVOTE: if I haven't yet, btw.
Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 2:51 pm
by Elements
In post 162, popsofctown wrote:Day 1 mislynch meta is my old meta and it's beautiful and freeing and you should embrace it.
But, no, seriously - playing to deliberately stick near null isn't good for your winrate, in my opinion (excepting some cases involving a PR, but even then I'm skeptical). You have a harder time sorting other players and players have a harder time sorting you. And mafia's a team game, X% of the time, a teammate who didn't try to play to null is getting mislynched in your place, and who's to say they're more valuable than you are?
If you came into this game planning to play this way I'm not sure I can sway you right away, but I encourage you to consider these things.
I'm not a fan of day 1 as an entity. I used to play day 1 to survive night 1 which mostly involved getting scum read day one.
Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 2:52 pm
by MariaR
Guess it's time I come back and check what this is about. Rather be dancing though.
Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 3:00 pm
by Elements
what style?
Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 3:15 pm
by MariaR
In post 69, Azuresky wrote:Ok, I'm going to leave a big post here for awhile as I plan on being busy tomorrow:
Give me Maria for town at this point, I'm usually a sucker for posts like #11, as most of the time this is a genuine statement.
Quickly looking at Hectics #12, I found the words, Wind Tracker May Ruined Wrong Byes take that as you will, its probably nothing, as there are no PRs in this game.
Hectic #15 ("You Believe Scum are Less Likely to put themselves at the top of the list") - Hectic could be scum for this. The WIFOM play is ballsy and something I can respect. Nymph v Hectic looks to be TvS if you ask me.
Do you, normally townread weak stuff like this? Because a lot of the things you’re trusting or suspecting are kinda weak bud. Honestly I wouldn’t put you on my investigative team anytime soon.
In post 76, Nymph wrote:There will always be a lynch. Scum can kill by manipulating the list during the night.
You do know scum can only do this once right? I should make it clear for you humans just so you don’t get confused
In post 87, popsofctown wrote: In post 69, Azuresky wrote:
Pops is probably town, but I do have a tiny tiny tiny reason to believe she is scum, but I do not feel like outing my reason as it is reaching (and somewhat a gut feeling) and I tr pops enough for now to ignore it.
I can't think of a protown reason not to out it.
If you feel that the reason is invalid at its core, there are six townies that can show you so in a collaborative process.
If it's truly valid at its deepest core then scum!pops would possibly NK you n1 or n2 as one of the players with a reservation against you she could never address, or maybe I guess she leaves you alive until LyLo where there is only 1 other townie to figure out whether your idea is dumb or smart and talk it out with you. But like, I don't see how it helps you to hide it.
That said, if it concerns some of my ongoing games that you have read, it is undeed the unfortunate case that you're required to use it to inform your read but not explain it to other people, according to site rules. Expressing a desire that you hope one of those games finish during this one would be o.k.
Let me explain this in a really obvious way for you. The reason you don’t out it is simple. If you suspect someone but it’s a tiny hunch. You don’t state the reason why you look for patterns on why they’re scum. That’s a little vastaya lesson for you. You can thank me later.
Don’t really like how you came at the comment but who knows maybe you got some air under your wings.
Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 3:29 pm
by MariaR
Let me answer this for you. No. Talking about this is also pointless. If it meant something it would be in another game. This is an open setup and no matter how many words are in here they’re pointless at the end of the day. Jeez, do I need to state the obvious here?
In post 90, Elements wrote:In regards to weather the mafia would put themselves at the top or bottom of the list - I think there's so much wifom there it's pointless speculating especially given we can get anyone to the top of the list.
This, I can agree with. I guess you’re not all that stupid after all. Props to you
In post 95, Hectic wrote: In post 48, MariaR wrote: In post 44, popsofctown wrote:Why "kid"? I get the feeling it's an experienced alt. And no, I'm not hinting I know the main, I figure that sort of thing out.
Kid is just a slang term I use. You humans have slang terms don't ya? Alt or not that's not the issue here? Why don't you tell me what you think of Nymph eh pops? You really don't see what I'm talking about right now?
who you roleplaying?
would let me immerse myself better
Call me Xayah, or The Violet Raven it’s a fancy little nickname I got. Not that I mind it.
In post 98, Hectic wrote: In post 56, MariaR wrote: In post 52, Azuresky wrote:P-Edit: Oh boy, I need Elements in here, I need him to help me break this game
What's your history with Elements? Don't tell me you need them to get your own footing in the game. That'd be pretty bland.
In post 53, Nymph wrote:I'll entertain this. I feel like MariaR has some weird interaction with Hectic.
@MariaR: What do you think about Hectic?
Uh, are you alright? I don't have a single interaction with Hectic. So I don't know what you're talking about. Humans, you're so strange I swear.
What do I think about the guy? He's posted a bunch of nonsense that I don't care to read. His questions aren't interesting. I'm waiting but he's on my bad side. Well, more than normal.
Pedit: Thanks for joining my vote. Keep it up
we got one of these ones eh?
you're lucky you're not in my prime years of 2008-2012
would rage and deathtunnel you
but i have something that my 2010 self didn't
patience
apathy
wisdom
so i will disregard this
for now
Calm down brainiac. I meant your first posts were nonsense where they clearly didn’t mean anything. It was useless filler that everyone should’ve ignored. But they didn’t so gold star for you I guess.
Locke113 or whatever his name is had a pretty bland catch up. I mean, the questions were weak along with a bit of filler. I wouldn’t mind if his name was at the very top of the list at the moment.
Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 3:42 pm
by MariaR
In post 112, popsofctown wrote:Also, why do people drop the 'R' off "MariaR"? The R is the best part. I say it out loud in my head every time I read it. "Muuuhreeeuuuuhhhaaaawwwwwrrrr". I'm pretty sure the R doesn't stand for anything. It's capitalized to emphasize that when you say her name, you should strongly be overcome by a desire to roar by the end of the word, because she's so alpha.
OOC (and any post in white is considered ooc): Pops, I adore you. This made me laugh so fucking hard that you made me scare my kitten on my lap. Oh god I am saving this. I was all serious and then you post this and ruined my mafia mood by making me laugh my ass off. Thank you very much.
In post 114, Elements wrote:atm I'd say I'm slightly scum reading him. Mostly just gut here but his persona doesn't feel very obvious atm. I think we should do at least one rearranging of the list even if we then undo it.
Huh? His persona? First of all, even if it’s clear he’s putting on a show why is this scummy? Why do we need to move around the list if you scumread the guy? This post needs a lot of clarification. You guys need to speak clearly. Use. Your. Words.
Sigh, the vastaya will never be saved at this point. Unless you’re scum then please carry on.
Anyone who does this should say who they’re trying to lynch and let die. Because you do know whoever gets second of that list will die at the end of the night correct? How careless are you people?
Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 3:47 pm
by Elements
have you played with hectic before?
Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 3:50 pm
by MariaR
Depends what song is playing of course~
Alright alright I'm all caught up.
I think I'm fine letting Pops/Nymph live to the next round so far. They seem useful in my cause.
Hectic is boring and unreadable and the fact Azuresky wants them lynched makes me perk one of my eyebrows.
The only issue I have is how to get Locke113 killed without nymph being next on the list
Pedit: Nope. I would remember...that
Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 3:51 pm
by MariaR
VOTE: Pair
This would leave Lock out right? Then reverse killing Lock/Azure. I think I'm fine with that right now
Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 3:57 pm
by Azuresky
Might go look into Pops posts, maybe not.
@Maria
R
- I come from the Matsina school of being town, where you base reads off tiny gut feeling, then work to make it more concrete. Im a shitty townplayer so I work based on her style. To answer your question, I usually find those statements to be pretty truthful. The kind that are subtle and not obnoxious “IM TOWN BITCHES” (Hectic’s post where he claims dayvig is an example of bad posting).
I mean, if you are telling me that your #11 is a lie, we can lynch you if you like.
@All: Im motioning for a skip to end the day, lynch hectic, and get scum to move dunn or kill him since I dont have a read on him. Im not looking to see who is immune in the scenario because I dont want to have a stroke.
Posted: Fri Sep 27, 2019 4:00 pm
by Azuresky
In post 172, MariaR wrote:VOTE: Pair
This would leave Lock out right? Then reverse killing Lock/Azure. I think I'm fine with that right now
Im Conductor, Locke is GM.
*Math Pun*
Attempting to lynch us results in your erasure.
This is fluff dont read into it