Mafiascum.net

Now that I really think about it we don't really get more info from their plan either. We'll get good info on the people in the council but we won't get to analyze everyone's council votes, only the council leader they vote for.

I say we just play normally

missed daystart pm, will read later
happy to be here, good luck)

Fine then.

Also i disagree with This Council, because i'm not in it.

HEAL: Raya, Battle Mage, Enchant

I think this is good. I TR BM and I don't think that plan benefits scum!Enchant

You don't?

I feel like scum would be most likely to try and come up with a plan like this to get in the good graces of other people

Maybe but scum want to make sure they get in the council and that plan gives them much less control. It's easier for them to get in when they can influence a consensus vote rather than the choice of a couple individuals

So, how we deal with dilemma when everyone disagree with not being on Council and suggesting only with self? We could fight for eternity. We have deadline though, and we also need yell at each other for elumination which cost time as well.

Oh well, this is political game now. So.

I can accept Council of BM+T-Bone+Artemiana. Though, this was pretty easy and fast formed for me. Why is that? Do you think Artemiana is townie, or you just want to talk with her? If you want to talk, what stopping ya from talking here?

Can council members be voted in one at a time, or does it have to be all three at one time?

Oh nvr mind I cannot read

In post 153, Enchant wrote:Also i disagree with This Council, because i'm not in it.

Why do you think you deserve to be in the council compared to anyone else this game?

If you beleive experience a notable qualifier for council members , why should any of us beleive you would bring anything of value?

In post 157, Enchant wrote:So, how we deal with dilemma when everyone disagree with not being on Council and suggesting only with self? We could fight for eternity. We have deadline though, and we also need yell at each other for elumination which cost time as well.

Oh well, this is political game now. So.

I can accept Council of BM+T-Bone+Artemiana. Though, this was pretty easy and fast formed for me. Why is that? Do you think Artemiana is townie, or you just want to talk with her? If you want to talk, what stopping ya from talking here?

Well we have plenty of time still. Why not just ignore the council for the time being, focus on normal scumhunting, and that should help us develop reads to make a better decision with the council

Why are T-Bone and Artemiana being townread?

I do agree with Enchant's plan to appoint one council member first, on the simple basis that voting one person is more feasible than voting a three-member combination all at once

as for how the remaining 2 are chosen, we'll cross that bridge when we come to it

In post 163, yessiree wrote:I do agree with Enchant's plan to appoint one council member first, on the simple basis that voting one person is more feasible than voting a three-member combination all at once

as for how the remaining 2 are chosen, we'll cross that bridge when we come to it

Seems a good idea, with obvious caveat that you cannot vote for yourself.
HEAL: UNHEAL ALL

i guess in someways you dont need the tags sice it wont be counted by the mod, ut it makes it easier to see.

In post 73, Enchant wrote:After that, this person choose someone.

Problem is, if first person we choose for council is scum we could have problems.
Why dont we just do the same plan again for the second and third person on the council?

no you misread one of my posts, go back and read it again.
Howevr, I agree we should have an open vote.

In post 86, Battle Mage wrote:I'd say the player is a credible top scumread.

yeah i see what you mean now that you could be scum ,and WOULD know T-bones alignment. I was going off the assumption that you no one knows anything at the moment. but yeah, i guess you could have been scum saying that about T-Bone.
seems really unlikely tho.
all this still points BM being town, I cant scum going out on a limb like this early on, it's a minefield of wifom and drawing attention to thwmselves.

In post 149, T-Bone wrote:I'm generally against plans because it fosters fake cooperation. I'd rather people independently play their best. Yes, it means cooperation is harder, but it also means it is more genuine (and thus less prone to manipulation).

what are your reads so far?

So far Enchant, Almost, BM, Yes town.
Arte prob town.
Tbone worries me a bit.

Raya prob town as well

So scum are in:
Nono, TBone
lol i have town read everyone else
game solved then!