Currently liking green and cyan, very much dislike magenta. So that means, I still feel good about Red as well. Blue hasn’t done anything to concern me yet.
In post 2, RH wrote:Automaton - You own an automaton, which you may use at any time during a Session to help you wrangle masks off. Unfortunately for you, the automaton doesn't have a return function so you may only use it once.
Furthermore, you must tell it the true identities of both masqueraders in the pair that you want to target in order to successfully wrangle off their masks.
it would be unequivocal that invitee is the proper label.
or, try this: Purple read the opening flavor
Intruders were mentioned in there
And invitees were not, so?
Posted: Tue Sep 27, 2022 9:24 am
by Masquerader Yellow
One more post about Purple
Does no one see that offering
to as many people as they reasonably could so early on
maximize their odds of not being squeezed out?
And does no one find this scummy?
Posted: Tue Sep 27, 2022 9:47 am
by Masquerader Magenta
@olive, it's a million % a tone thing, what really stood out was the difference between your 129 and 141: you must see the difference? But then your tone to purple changes massively between 125 and 129 so maybe I'm jumping ar shadows.
With red, what specifically do you disagree with me about?
Blue could be town, their original opening was fine.
I want teal to come back. *pout*
Posted: Tue Sep 27, 2022 11:01 am
by Masquerader Teal
I've been sick since yesterday. Trying to muster the energy to play but I may be absent or loopy or something.
Posted: Tue Sep 27, 2022 12:12 pm
by Datisi
Posted: Tue Sep 27, 2022 5:22 pm
by Masquerader Red
In post 144, Masquerader Magenta wrote:Re: reds big wall from before, I felt it was vaguely shady on most slots but without any really clear X is scum because. I've seen scum rely on it as a crutch before.
I did say two people (Teal and Green) were my scumreads. And I gave reasons for both of them. So I'm uncertain what your insinuation here is.
Posted: Tue Sep 27, 2022 5:23 pm
by Masquerader Yellow
Magenta, Cyan
If I offer will you dance?
Posted: Tue Sep 27, 2022 5:25 pm
by Masquerader Red
I think the Purple offering to all but two people thing is a shtick, and it does have obvious utility as scum but there's also intrinsic risk to making that post and I don't think it's like Purple was particularly likely to be left out by taking a different tact. So I don't really think it was Purple panicking as scum. The invitee thing is, eh, more or less meaningless in my mind. Purple could be scum who didn't realize that town are invitees, but in some respect I'd think if Purple were scum they'd have been more careful about that; I don't think they're particularly more likely to make that mistake as scum than as town.
Posted: Tue Sep 27, 2022 5:29 pm
by Masquerader Red
Olive, what are you liking recently from Green? I can see Cyan being more town in the past page.
Posted: Tue Sep 27, 2022 5:43 pm
by Masquerader Purple
In post 161, Masquerader Red wrote:Olive, what are you liking recently from Green? I can see Cyan being more town in the past page.
I concur about cyan. I can see two intruders out of teal, magenta and green. I prefer one be left without a partner and the other two be paired together.
Why did you ignore Olive's participation in that exchange?
I don't really have a cut-and-dry feel for Olive's actions so I haven't really spoken on them yet
Posted: Wed Sep 28, 2022 2:45 am
by Masquerader Green
In post 150, Masquerader Olive wrote:Currently liking green and cyan, very much dislike magenta. So that means, I still feel good about Red as well. Blue hasn’t done anything to concern me yet.
I did a quick think about pairing options and Cyan doesn't seem that terrible rn
I am not inclined to pair with Yellow, would rather just leave Yellow unpaired entirely
In post 161, Masquerader Red wrote:Olive, what are you liking recently from Green? I can see Cyan being more town in the past page.
I concur about cyan. I can see two intruders out of teal, magenta and green. I prefer one be left without a partner and the other two be paired together.
are you for real
you sussed me because you thought I was distancing from Yellow, now you've dropped Yellow from your suspects but I'm still there?
Why has Yellow even left your suspect pool? I think this scumslip angle they're pushing against you is a terrible look for them.
@red, i re read your post and while I think my initial 'negative vibes ' impression is still valid, it's not quite as bad as I thought. There are some take.aways, but I guess I find it easier to find town than scum and that affects my take on those kind of posts. In particular, I think what you said about green was well thought through, that their logic seemed backwards.
Their posting on this page is terribad.
I wanted to dance with teal but also really want their catch up. Would anyone oppose this pairing?
it would be unequivocal that invitee is the proper label.
The fact that it was in the pre-game setup post, invalidates your argument.
No it really doesn't.
I don’t understand then, how so? Your argument is that Purple slipped but they had access to the invitee role pm because of the setup post, so why would they use the word “masque” in lieu of that? If there was no sample role pm, then I could see why your argument would make sense but they’re was.
it would be unequivocal that invitee is the proper label.
or, try this: Purple read the opening flavor
Intruders were mentioned in there
And invitees were not, so?
Known only to their possessors!
Alas, those Intruders, they'll be the guessers!
How they wish to unmask you all!
How they want to use them to cause your downfall!
Beware, friends, and confide to none!
Heed this advice or you're done!
to as many people as they reasonably could so early on
maximize their odds of not being squeezed out?
And does no one find this scummy?
They didn’t offer it to you or green at the time. I don’t know. I’m thinking they’re continuing to re-evaluate their reads is a sign of possible inviteeness. I initially intruder read them for their ridiculous tunnel on me but their continual reassessing the playerlist is generally something that town is far more likel to do than scum. Am I nervous, sure. Purple wasn’t my most confident invitee read but I also like their assessment of that I really didn’t put too much thought into trying to disguise my posting and how that might possibly make me more vulnerable and then when I asked why they didn’t retract the offers they were less sure of to give me more time to think about it, they did. I just think that intruder Purple would be more likely to want to keep me as viable nightkill option, based off of what they said about me. Because apparently they think my identity is less difficult to guess, so why did they want to pair with me the most?