Nintendo Mafia (Game Over)

[Ythan]

Go town go.

[Kdub]

thil, any results last night? Also, please answer this:

@thil:
Were you explicitly told that you were roleblocked? Could be important.

How do people feel about a mass nameclaim?

My access may be a bit spotty through Sunday, but I should still be able to check in at least once per day.

[The Master Hand]

Jesus guys, did we have to claim role related information to get it through your fucking skulls that dana was town?
For fuck's sake, he couldn't have been townier.
IT DOESNT TAKE A ROCKET SCIENTIST.

Dekes claiming was freaking retarted. Nameclaiming is bad as it would distinguish the VTs from the PRs since *apparently* the PRs are actual known characters and non-PRs are random joes (GET IT JMJ) thrown into the game. Freakin hell guys. dana was town.

Still think pianist is scum, even if my other scumreads flipped town. *sigh*

[esuriospiritus]

VOTE: thil

Can this happen now?

Nameclaiming is bad as it would distinguish the VTs from the PRs since *apparently* the PRs are actual known characters and non-PRs are random joes (GET IT JMJ) thrown into the game. Freakin hell guys. dana was town.

if you really believe this why the fuck is your vote not on thill?

better post when I havent been drinking. ^_^

[The Master Hand]

VOTE: thil

Can this happen now?

Nameclaiming is bad as it would distinguish the VTs from the PRs since *apparently* the PRs are actual known characters and non-PRs are random joes (GET IT JMJ) thrown into the game. Freakin hell guys. dana was town.

if you really believe this why the fuck is your vote not on thill?

better post when I havent been drinking. ^_^

No, it can't. Toast is under the impression that the mafia killed Ythan to make thil look worse. I'm coming to terms with it- let's face it. If they have a RB they can go LOLOLOLOLOLOL WE GONNA BLOCK YOU COP BOY forever and never worry about him- perhaps push a mislynch by getting the Doc killed.

Because I hold my townread on him regardless. We'll get a better look into what's going on after tonight, when they (mafia) CAN kill thil (no YthanDoc) and RB someone else like the person who killed one of them the other night.

Dekes, you suck for claiming prematurely. That is all.

[The Master Hand]

6. Pinky and the Brain (twistedspoon and hoppster hydra)
8. esuriospiritus
10. thil13
11. GhostWriter
13. ObliviousDruidMuncher sorasgoof Kadersalad Kdub
15. The Master Hand (Andrius and ToastyToast hydra)
16. lewarcher82
17. crazypianist1116 weirdalexv
18. mb53 DemonHybrid
19. DarlaBlueEyes Bunnylover

HRMMMM

Taking townreads off the list doesn't leave many options for them scumbags to be hiding in.

Vote: weirdalexv (crazypianist)

[lewarcher82]

mmh... the player I was sure was scum and the player I trusted less in the voting bloc were tonight's victims.

I have to reconsider the situation.

Esurio: no. You don't vote the claimed cop this way... Ythan's flip does not automatically make thil look worse. You should at least wait for his report, if any.

kdub: massnameclaims hardly ever work. I am sure scum has good fakenames like in almost any themed game I have seen. It does no good, it does no harm... do you think we may use one?

P-EDIT: this is by no means a bad choice, TMH, I will articulate more later.

[wierdalexv]

Hi. I will be having a post later today with my catchup in it.

Spoiler: Slight Preview

I think thil13 is scum.

[wierdalexv]

So...extremely long catchup post.

My reads after 10 pages:

TOWN

The Master Hand

-- His reaction to the surprise hammer seemed genuine.

DTMaster

-- I like the surprise hammer gambit. Nullish town.

Esuriospiritus

-- I like the scumhunting.

SCUM

Lelouch VI Brittiana

-- Active lurking, just being an idiot, etc.

thil13

-- He did absolutely nothing.

CSL

-- Didn't do much.
Everyone else is null.

My reads after 20 pages:

TOWN

DTMaster

Super Smash Bros. Fan

-- Same + Scumhunting.

Esuriospiritus

-- Same + ISO #32 looks town, except for one thing: Why did you think Lelouch was scum after you saw the breadcrumb? I took him/Jak off the my scumlist when I saw that.

Lelouch VI Brittiana

TheJakalope

-- The breadcrumb caught by Esurio made me change my mind about him. I am pretty sure that scum were pushing his wagon pretty hard.

SCUM

thil13

-- Same.

CSL

-- Same.

The Master Hand

-- I don't like the way they pushed the Lelouch wagon. Call it gut if you want, but it felt off. Slightly scum.

Lucresia

-- That hammer was epicfail. You should have lynched him D2.

Tradgedy

-- Lurking while calling others out for lurking. *facepalms*

Espeonage

-- lolfail case on Esuriospiritus.
Everyone else is null.

My reads after 30 pages:

TOWN

Super Smash Bros. Fan

-- Same.

Esuriospiritus

-- Same.

Dekes

-- Scumhunting.

lewarcher82

-- Scumhunting

Pinky and the Brain

-- Scumhunting

SCUM

thil13

-- Same + afraid of being suspected.

CSL

Ythan

-- Same.

The Master Hand

-- Same.

Lucresia

-- Same.

Tradgedy

-- Same.

Espeonage

-- Same + lurking and avoiding questions.
Everyone else is null.

My reads after 40 pages:

TOWN

Esuriospiritus

-- Same.

Dekes

-- Same.

lewarcher82

-- Same.

Pinky and the Brain

-- Same.

SCUM

thil13

-- Same + OMGUS.

The Master Hand

-- Same.

Lucresia

chkflip

-- Same.

Espeonage

-- Same.

Xtoxm

hohum

-- How did he know Espeonage would claim VT before he claimed?
Everyone else is null.

My reads after 50 pages:

TOWN

Esuriospiritus

-- Same.

Dekes

-- Same.

lewarcher82

-- Same.

Pinky and the Brain

-- Same.

SCUM

thil13

-- Same + backdown for cop claim: 'there may be more than one cop'. THIS GUY IS SCUM.

The Master Hand

-- Same.
Everyone else is null.

Caught up:

TOWN

Esuriospiritus

-- Same.

lewarcher82

-- Same.

Pinky and the Brain

-- Same.

SCUM

thil13

-- Same. LYNCHLYNCHLYNCH.

The Master Hand

-- Same.
Everyone else is null.

And those are my reads. Here is my full case on thil13:
-He was lurking a ton earlier.
-He was using the newb card a little bit.
-ABSOLUTELY NO SCUMHUNTING. AT ALL. IN A 60 PAGE GAME.
-

Pine, it would be no surprise to me if there were more than one cop with the amount of people that signed up for this, so unless the mod wanted to put in every obscure role, he may have doubled roles, but that's just what I think. There very well could be another cop, or more than one doctor/vig/whatever. All I know is that my role PM says town cop...

LYNCH THIS GUY. PLEASE.

VOTE: thil13

[The Master Hand]

I'm sorry, I didn't know it was scummy to push a lynch on someone who claimed scum after being removed from the game.
-Toast

[The Master Hand]

Yep.
Weirdpianist still needs to die. So he replaces in as scum, is told who the easy mislynch is (remember whoeverbroughtitupD1: scum have daytalk), so he reads and pushes thil on crap reasoning.

His reaction to the surprise hammer seemed genuine.

If that's the ONLY reason for a read then you need to rethink how you play your

scum

game.

I am pretty sure that scum were pushing his wagon pretty hard.

Why would scum push a VT lynch D1, when they could simply push, oh, idk, ANOTHER lynch D1 without getting caught?
What scum motivation would we have (as scum (LOL)) to push a lynch THAT HARD knowing full well (his crumbs) that he will flip VT? If he'd flip Double-Acting-Cop then I'd throw a goon down to get that man lynched before N1. But no. He flipped VT.
So, tell me, where's the scum motivation for pushing that lynch --> knowing we would take a HEAP of crap for doing so D2? Hell, we figured if he DID flip town that we'd be shot for sure. (We weren't, so that tells you a couple things in and of itself.)

Also:

I don't like the way they pushed the Lelouch wagon. Call it gut if you want, but it felt off. Slightly scum.

You can call it gut.
But that is your only reasoning for ever suspecting us.

Same.

That's your reasoning for finding us scummy after the one instance of lelouch-wagon.

Also, if that's your replace-in post I am very let down.

His one case:
[quote"piano"]
And those are my reads. Here is my full case on thil13:
-He was lurking a ton earlier.
-He was using the newb card a little bit.
-ABSOLUTELY NO SCUMHUNTING. AT ALL. IN A 60 PAGE GAME.
[/quote]
-K cool. Everyone lurks. Dekes lurked too. esurio lurked too.
-Newb card maybe. (But if you haven't noticed he IS rather, oh, how do you describe it....... N00BISH.)
-Cool story bro.

Also, everyone else is "null reads". Anyone think that is a load of horseshit?

-A

[thil13]

No result. Which is also what I got last night. I may as well be a vanilla townie, but I must be getting roleblocked, since I did receive a result night 2, and I haven't been getting results since I claimed.

I wouldn't mind a pianist lynch, I also wouldn't mind an Esurio lynch, but which to choose?

[thil13]

I was not "explicitly told" that I was roleblocked, but deductive reasoning makes it the only choice, unless I wasn't told that I was a one-shot PR.

[Bunnylover]

This is the cop without a counter claim.
I won't be voting for Thil.
Lynching Dana was stupid. Reminds me of freaking the SSBB game where Stels claims scum to get Shark lynched, and we stupidly lynch Stels even though we coulda lynched Shark. Ugh.

Im not opposed to a MC.

[esuriospiritus]

HI.

HEY, YOU WANT TO PLAY GAME NOW?

OKAY, HERE. I HELP.

12. Lucresia chkflip E_Lou_Sive,

Wario

, Mafia

Doc

, has been slashed to death Night 3.
4. Ythan,

Princess Peach

,

doctor

,was found incinerated and surrounded by energy burns Night 4.
2. Dekes,

Kirby

,

Jack of all Trades

, was found with multiple high-energy burn marks on their body Night 4.

My character name is

Merlon

. I guess he is from the mario games.

I can investigate

once per night.

ONE OF THESE THINGS IS NOT LIKE THE OTHER THINGS.
ONE OF THESE THINGS JUST DOESN'T BELONG.
CAN YOU GUESS WHICH THING IS NOT LIKE THE OTHER THING
BEFORE I FINISH MY SOOOOOOOOOOONG?

And no, smartass, the correct answer is not that chkflip is the only scum up there.

[thil13]

you're reaction doesn't make me think you're more town. That explosion was definitely uncalled for.

So, tell me, what

is[/] the thing that doesn't belong?

[esuriospiritus]

"explosion"? Maybe you should click the link, it will give you context.

Peach, Wario, and Kirby are all major characters in their respective games. Hell, all of them have had games starring them even if they weren't the lead character when they made their debut.

Merlon, on the other hand, not so much.

[thil13]

You're making the credibility of my claim, based on the character I claimed?

Sounds vaguely familiar...

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... 7#p3046267

[esuriospiritus]

You're... quoting someone who flipped town

talking

to someone who flipped town in an attempt to discredit me? And not only someone who flipped town, but someone who

also

thought you were scum?

Hah.

Who's scum, thil?

[thil13]

Certainly not me. I'm getting the feeling you are though.

[GhostWriter]

You're making the credibility of my claim, based on the character I claimed?

Sounds vaguely familiar...

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... 7#p3046267

That isn't the same thing at all, for the record. This is a case of "all PR's and mafia are mainstream characters that people recognize and VT's are obscure characters and you have a fairly obscure character claim as a PR". That was a case of "hmm, that character was a good guy, so it matches up that he'd be town aligned". Quite different. Also, your OMGUS just now is quite alarming.

[Bunnylover]

"explosion"? Maybe you should click the link, it will give you context.

Peach, Wario, and Kirby are all major characters in their respective games. Hell, all of them have had games starring them even if they weren't the lead character when they made their debut.

Merlon, on the other hand, not so much.

Wario flipped mafia doctor. If you were trying to make the connection that all main characters have PR, and therefore since Merlon is not a main character he wouldn't have a PR like cop, isn't correct.
If I am wrong then:
I'm not sure where your going with this x_x.

[GhostWriter]

Wario has his own games. He's a main character.

[GhostWriter]

P-EDIT: this is by no means a bad choice, TMH, I will articulate more later.

Curious about this.

[Bunnylover]

Wario has his own games. He's a main character.

Yes, but wario was

mafia

.
Ignoring that, you two are saying that PR are based on main characters.
That is false.