Because the reasoning for townreading him was nonsense to begin with and it's not like he's done anything outstandingly town.
Posted: Wed Apr 11, 2018 7:44 pm
by Brian Skies
In post 1262, Firebringer wrote:Okay I am going to make a really good argument here on why mastina has to be scum.
Let’s go with a few assumptions:
1) Alisae assigned all Town roles on purpose to players
2) Alisae knows of my annoyance with mastina
3) Alisae gave me vigilante
Sooo
Knowing this Alisae knows I’m going to shoot Mastina if we fail to lynch her. And he knew scum team before game starts.
You guys tell me if Alisae didn’t think I would shoot mastina in the face here with him giving me a gun.
So you tell me if you think he would throw it in just for me to shoot Town or what.
*Firebringer drops the mic*
This is probably the most compelling thing I've seen in this game.
If you think firepup is town, why are we not lynching Mastina?
Posted: Wed Apr 11, 2018 7:52 pm
by camn
Why was it nonsense, Brian?
Posted: Wed Apr 11, 2018 7:59 pm
by Brian Skies
Because I think the whole 'he surely wouldn't be picked' by Pine only works for like the first two rounds or so. After that, when Alisae begins to obliterate the pool and Pine starts getting left with weaker players and others he doesn't know, Aristophanes probably becomes more enticing than you'd think.
Also, while I think it's okay as a conversation starter, I'm not a fan of basing reads around who Pine would or wouldn't pick. It's just speculation and should be treated as such.
The harder lynch should go through today so I'm more likely to be sheeped post death.
I'm not caught up and won't be until sometime tomorrow.
But I do want to know why this slot thinks I'm the harder lynch. Especially considering the Mastina wagon has stalled all day and and it took barely two hours (give or take) for me to become the leading wagon.