Mafiascum.net

I....already said Shoshin is my top townread.

Talking to Vorkuta. I know that Shoshin is your top townread.

Shoshin/CoA/Vedith/Aura

Vorkuta/RC/Boats

Yellowsnow/Tarkus

DDL/Creature/Morality

not nearly understanding the vedith placement but i grok everything else

No one else likes it either which makes me more confident he's town.

But then............... who is the 3rd skumz

In post 1507, DrDolittle wrote:VOTE: rce

Why?

I think hes more likely scum and your last couple of posts have been entertaining

Why is he more likely scum?

Tldr, reads are inauthentic and inoffensive. Theres barely any follow up in the reads, and strangely almost no movement despite lots of action happening (from what I recall)

It's just not town.

And which reads are inauthentic?

What constitutes inoffensive?

Don't throw out bs and pray it sticks.

In post 1511, DrDolittle wrote:Tldr, reads are inauthentic and inoffensive. Theres barely any follow up in the reads, and strangely almost no movement despite lots of action happening (from what I recall)

What makes them inauthentic? What changes should he have had that didn't happen? And why would he have had those changes as town?

The game is progression and town is uncertain. Reads should move relatively continuously as town, and players rigid reads are scum trying for consistency. Its unnatural

That doesn't answer my questions.

In post 1513, RCEnigma wrote:And which reads are inauthentic?

What constitutes inoffensive?

Don't throw out bs and pray it sticks.

Inoffensive reads are those where people go and say oh ok I understand move along. That's lit your reads all game. Theres nothing much to comment about it, it's extremely generic and could be construed as scum coating.

Your reads are inauthentic bbecause theres no substance behind iit. For example you dont have anything on why I'm scum other than some omgus or creddible reasons on why vedith is town despite him doing nothing.

In post 1514, Shoshin wrote:What changes should he have had that didn't happen

Yes it does. Some changes should happen, if any. The fact that theres nothing for the past N pages is of concern

Are you being difficult with me on purpose because I called you out on not following up on stuff as scum?

Town don't always change their reads after N pages. I can't believe how shallow your analysis is.

Imo this game is being played (not by me) at an extremely high level and sorting anyone is pretty hard. At least I'm constantly shifting my reads on people as I'm reading. I have a hard time believing that RCE is so confident with his reads that they dont change at all.

This isn't a game where people just banter for N pages after obv scum is lynched and is waiting for flips. Context matters.

In post 1517, DrDolittle wrote:Your reads are inauthentic bbecause theres no substance behind iit. For example you dont have anything on why I'm scum other than some omgus or creddible reasons on why vedith is town despite him doing nothing.

I'll get to both of these.

Rigid reads is also false.

Vedith/snow/boats/morality/RC have all shifted in my reads at some point or another.

Let's flip the table. Why do you think RCE is town.