Mafiascum.net

In post 1498, House wrote:but able to be solved if you are knowledgeable of the flavor.

How does that make a mafia game, we can all claim names and the most devoted video game players solve it in 5 minutes.

On second thought, I think I can tell from the way you're playing

In post 1499, Marashu wrote:I ask because I'm trying to figure things out, and if you're claiming 2/3 of that group, then that helps us sort you and the people who have flavour-claimed, especially post-flip.

House doesn't want to claim flavor until his mason bodyguard is dead.

In post 1498, House wrote:

In post 1488, Robert M Hunter wrote:Don't you think the mod would give scum credible safe claims?

The whole point of fake claims is that they're meant to look credible but able to be solved if you are knowledgeable of the flavor.

I played Chrono Trigger for years. I know the Yakra battle VERY well.

PEdit

In post 1499, Marashu wrote:I ask because I'm trying to figure things out, and if you're claiming 2/3 of that group, then that helps us sort you and the people who have flavour-claimed, especially post-flip.

This is d3 discussion.

I'm not saying anything until Robert is dead, because it will just lead to more information for scum.

On one hand you need red herrings so that the game can't be solved by claiming names, on the other hand you need proper safe claims so that the scum team isn't annihilated on day 1.

Why did the mod decide to inform me that Spekkio is in the game? Explain that.

House cannot out his flavor because it would hint what his JOAT abilities are.

In post 1500, Robert M Hunter wrote:

In post 1498, House wrote:but able to be solved if you are knowledgeable of the flavor.

How does that make a mafia game, we can all claim names and the most devoted video game players solve it in 5 minutes.

I mean, if you flip town, I think we flip House next.

Robert M Hunter wrote:

In post 1499, Marashu wrote:I ask because I'm trying to figure things out, and if you're claiming 2/3 of that group, then that helps us sort you and the people who have flavour-claimed, especially post-flip.

House doesn't want to claim flavor until his mason bodyguard is dead.

I know, but he's also talking a lot about the flavour of the source material right now, so my question comes from what his point of view is regarding Gaspar/Melchior/Cyrus/Spekkio. (I'm not taking the Gaspar claim seriously tbh)

I'm ok with flipping Robert, but I absolutely want to hear from Lukewarm first.

PEdit - yeah, I think I got there in the end.

It's after 10 and I need to work in the morning.

I'll be back tomorrow evening. Good night.

In post 1498, House wrote:I know the Yakra battle VERY well.

In post 1508, Marashu wrote:I mean, if you flip town, I think we flip House next.

I accept this trade off.

In post 1511, Robert M Hunter wrote:

In post 1508, Marashu wrote:I mean, if you flip town, I think we flip House next.

I accept this trade off.

And this sequence is why Marashu should be lit on fire.

And if you can all do me a favor after I'm dead, Titus is scum, you can yeet that from here to Sunday.

Titus, do you think that Robert and House are of the same alignment?

In post 1512, Titus wrote:

In post 1511, Robert M Hunter wrote:

In post 1508, Marashu wrote:I mean, if you flip town, I think we flip House next.

I accept this trade off.

And this sequence is why Marashu should be lit on fire.

Marashu is right.

There is no way that a townie actually believes that there is a game that can be solved by having everyone state their flavor.

He coulid just be scum with a bulletproof and there is no mason bodyguard at all.

In post 1515, Robert M Hunter wrote:There is no way that a townie actually believes that there is a game that can be solved by having everyone state their flavor.

I don’t think House is saying that per se? Tbh I think T3 said that.

Robert, it's more that if you are telling the truth and are town, then you are one of (presumably) three roles. House is accounting for 2 of them. You have info on another role. From my POV one of you has to be lying.

In post 1516, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 1515, Robert M Hunter wrote:There is no way that a townie actually believes that there is a game that can be solved by having everyone state their flavor.

I don’t think House is saying that per se? Tbh I think T3 said that.

No he's definitely pretending that if your role name doesn't fit his perfect video game narrative then that's reason enough to eliminate.

In post 1506, Robert M Hunter wrote:Why did the mod decide to inform me that Spekkio is in the game? Explain that.

Because you're lying. Melchior is in the Dark Ages and the Present, but never in the Middle Ages which the Yakra boss fight takes place in. Why would the mod flavor the game as the Yakra boss fight but then add in completely unrelated characters as flavor?

Additionally, Town are supposed to be seven soldiers and three weirdos. Melchior is not a soldier, and it would fucking wild if he got brought in as a flavored weirdo over the actual characters who are a part of that arc.

In post 1517, Marashu wrote:Robert, it's more that if you are telling the truth and are town, then you are one of (presumably) three roles. House is accounting for 2 of them. You have info on another role. From my POV one of you has to be lying.

Again that's assuming that the game we're playing is a perfect mirror for the video game.

In post 1519, Roden wrote:

In post 1506, Robert M Hunter wrote:Why did the mod decide to inform me that Spekkio is in the game? Explain that.

Because you're lying. Melchior is in the Dark Ages and the Present, but never in the Middle Ages which the Yakra boss fight takes place in. Why would the mod flavor the game as the Yakra boss fight but then add in completely unrelated characters as flavor?

Additionally, Town are supposed to be seven soldiers and three weirdos. Melchior is not a soldier, and it would fucking wild if he got brought in as a flavored weirdo over the actual characters who are a part of that arc.

ask the mod.

In post 1520, Robert M Hunter wrote:

In post 1517, Marashu wrote:Robert, it's more that if you are telling the truth and are town, then you are one of (presumably) three roles. House is accounting for 2 of them. You have info on another role. From my POV one of you has to be lying.

Again that's assuming that the game we're playing is a perfect mirror for the video game.

Not really? Like, you both appear to have information and are playing based on it, but that information is contradictory.

LOL, if I were scum I would have a safe claim and no one would be the wiser.

Instead I've got one of those red herring flavors that are so popular these days.

In post 1515, Robert M Hunter wrote:

In post 1512, Titus wrote:

In post 1511, Robert M Hunter wrote:

In post 1508, Marashu wrote:I mean, if you flip town, I think we flip House next.

I accept this trade off.

And this sequence is why Marashu should be lit on fire.

Marashu is right.

There is no way that a townie actually believes that there is a game that can be solved by having everyone state their flavor.

He coulid just be scum with a bulletproof and there is no mason bodyguard at all.

VOTE: Marashu

I've seen town believe almost everything.

I've seen town believe that CCing a suicide bomber was a good play.