Mini 1566: Lunar Silver Star Story Complete (Game Over)

[zMuffinMan]

yes, and if it wasn't bussing, it was distancing so same point

[Aegor]

The vote being distancing would be consistent with my suggestion as well.

[zMuffinMan]

but not really, because the point of distancing is to look better after a flip. any scum that distances needs to be fully prepared to bus or there is no point in distancing in the first place.

which is why i said i suppose it's possible hkc is just not a very good scum player, but otherwise it doesn't make a lot of sense

but this seems to be an argument for another day since you don't seem to be a suggesting a hkc lynch atm so whatevs - if mac and aj-slot are scum, this is a pointless discussion

[Mac]

Well I can definitely state that at least one of us is not scum, and have the evidence to back it up.

Catch up today!

[zMuffinMan]

i don't think you can or do!

[Jake from State Farm]

aegor - I don't see anything pro-town from AJ's slot, but I don't see anything overy scummy either. What is your case on him?

[Kdub]

i know i'm answering someone else's question, but since it's based on what i think is a misinterpretation anyway, those are my thoughts

Well, you gave more of an answer than Aegor did, even though the question was directed at him.

If anyone strongly believes that Mac or AJ is town, please make your case. At this point,

I fail to see any reason whatsoever to let two slots that have produced nothing of substance

(or, in Mac's case, a defense of scum and nothing else except unexplained flip-flopping on the Day 1 HS)

by Day 3 live

.

This suggests that my interpretation of Aegor's Aj-scumread is accurate, doesn't it?

[Aegor]

These are the posts where you vote Aj and suggest that he is scum. No reason is given until 1402, where you seem to be saying that you suspect Aj because he hasn't done anything town. So now that we know he was inactive because of RL stuff, why do you still read that slot as scum?

I do not

know

anything other than AJ replaced out for what I assume are RL reasons. That tells me nothing about the reason for his inactivity earlier in the game. Moreover, I see no reason to wait this long if RL has been preventing activity since the start of the game. Finally, one can be generally inactive and yet still post constructively, which AJ has not done.

[Aegor]

aegor -

I don't see anything pro-town from AJ's slot

, but I don't see anything overy scummy either. What is your case on him?

Voilà.

[Jake from State Farm]

Well using that logic you, hkc, AJ, Mac, and zmuffin are all scum

Damn we are fucked guys

[Aegor]

Mod, please see the post above this one and clarify whether posting bitchy and sarcastic remarks constitutes a breach of respect.

[Jake from State Farm]

lol if sarcasm is a breach of respect replace me now

[Jake from State Farm]

Btw that actually wasn't sarcasm. I'm dead serious about using your logic for AJ means all those people I named would be scum. None of those people have done anything I perceive as pro-town

[borkjerfkin]

I am really losing patience here. Please play the game without getting me involved (edit: with behavioral issues) except as a last resort.

[Aegor]

Btw that actually wasn't sarcasm. I'm dead serious about using your logic for AJ means all those people I named would be scum. None of those people have done anything I perceive as pro-town

Well, I do not give a shit about your perceptions because your entire play has been real fucking shitty and you are negative utility and I am tempted to excise you from this game like the malignant tumor you are. So I would recommend that you shut the fuck up.

[Jake from State Farm]

My play has been shitty but I handed people scum on a silver platter. That's more than I can say about anyone else's contributions this game.

I ask you for a case on AJ cause your push looks like a policy lynch and you essentially confirm that it is a policy lynch and then have the audacity to insult me?

Have a nice life.

[Antihero]

guys

stop

[Antihero]

UNVOTE:

for a second

[Aegor]

My play has been shitty but I handed people scum on a silver platter.

YOU DID NO SUCH THING

I do not know what the fuck is causing this delusion to persist; but I still do not even know what you posted about SMP. Yet I voted him in the middle of Day 1 based on my own independent suspicions. Your statement amounts to an assertion that anyone who says someone is scum at any point for any reason whatsoever is "handing people scum on a silver platter," regardless of how many other people already believe that person is scum.

I ask you for a case on AJ cause your push looks like a policy lynch and you essentially confirm that it is a policy lynch and then have the audacity to insult me?

The case is that he has not posted anything pro-town and it is Day 3. That is my case. If you want to call that a policy lynch, fine. I do not give a shit what you call it.

[Jake from State Farm]

@ anti - Don't worry. I won't be responding to a singe thing they post for the remainder of the game.

[Antihero]

alright, so here's my persisting issue with AJ's slot

this post yesterday

so, the first part of his post strongly implies he suspects SMP, but no votes follow from that.

the second part of the post calls my claim into question, but he approaches it from an "antihero is fakeclaiming a guilty

as town

", not that i'm fakeclaiming scum 1v1ing a claimed town PR. i don't have a meta of doing this, so that's a really weird way of approaching the claims. it's like he already knows the alignments.

[BROseidon]

Trying to read this game is the worst :/

[Squirrel Girl]

is this what your scum game looks like, squirrel girl

Well, I try to make my scum game look like my town game, so - yes, basically this is what my scum game would look like, because I'd try and do what I'd do as town. I think I, mostly, succeed.

and since the new girl already saw what I was seeing and is voting zmuffin

vote: zmuffin

Yayz!
Though, honestly, the sudden defense on HKC has my head a'swim again. Though I guess that could make her town and him just naughty still. I really ought to read Day 2 too. I'm still not sure where all the negativity about the game is coming from and no one bothered to try to answer that question either.

alright, so here's my persisting issue with AJ's slot

this post yesterday

so, the first part of his post strongly implies he suspects SMP, but no votes follow from that.

the second part of the post calls my claim into question, but he approaches it from an "antihero is fakeclaiming a guilty

as town

", not that i'm fakeclaiming scum 1v1ing a claimed town PR. i don't have a meta of doing this, so that's a really weird way of approaching the claims. it's like he already knows the alignments.

I guess since I'm AJ it's up to me to try and defend what he was thinking here. In reading the linked post I think you're overblowing his reaction both times.

The first part expresses an issue with SMP's claimed role and chosen actions.
The second part expresses an issue with your claimed role and chosen actions.

I think what the post shows is AJ trying to figure out stuff and pressing on both of you to see what he learns. I think if he/I were scum and he wanted to express doubt he'd...y'know, actually back it up if he was being serious. Instead he's advancing a thought and seeing how SMP reacts to it - aka, scumhunting. The same was with you, he thought your claimed actions didn't fully line up with what he would expect from you, and was pressing you to defend your choice - again, scumhunting. I don't think that post reflects what you claim to see from it at all. Do you think I'm nutty?

[magenta_thegreat]

but not really, because the point of distancing is to look better after a flip. any scum that distances needs to be fully prepared to bus or there is no point in distancing in the first place.

which is why i said i suppose it's possible hkc is just not a very good scum player, but otherwise it doesn't make a lot of sense

but this seems to be an argument for another day since you don't seem to be a suggesting a hkc lynch atm so whatevs - if mac and aj-slot are scum, this is a pointless discussion

Don't even try to go down this route, just don't. There's more than enough evidence that I'm a pretty powerful scum player, and I'm pretty damn tired of having my game being talked down upon, ESPECIALLY this game

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

but not really, because the point of distancing is to look better after a flip. any scum that distances needs to be fully prepared to bus or there is no point in distancing in the first place.

which is why i said i suppose it's possible hkc is just not a very good scum player, but otherwise it doesn't make a lot of sense

but this seems to be an argument for another day since you don't seem to be a suggesting a hkc lynch atm so whatevs - if mac and aj-slot are scum, this is a pointless discussion

Don't even try to go down this route, just don't. There's more than enough evidence that I'm a pretty powerful scum player, and I'm pretty damn tired of having my game being talked down upon, ESPECIALLY this game

and, tbh it would have been a whole lot better to actually distance than to make a pseudo-defense of SMP. It would have been a whole lot better to just pretend I didn't catch PHDscars PR soft (which evidently was wrong, but w/e), and it would have been ridiculously stupid to not not kill said soft but ask my "scumpartner" to investigate him, instead. It would also be incredibly stupid of me to not kill jake when I had a chance to, but rather, kill AD.