↑ Paschendale wrote:↑ Shiny Hydreigon wrote:scum reads dont have to be explained, nor understood. She scumreads bulba, and thats it.
If you can't justify a scumread, I have no reason whatsoever to think that you aren't lying about it. If I think you're lying about it, I certainly won't vote along with you, and will vote for you instead. If you don't justify a read, there's no reason to think you're right, and no one should vote along with you, and so you aren't actually pushing to get your suspects lynched. That means you aren't actually trying to help town win the game. Therefore, you're scum and should be lynched. Don't like it? Then justify your fucking positions.
↑ Shiny Hydreigon wrote:uhm... what? gut reads are a thing.
No. Gut reads are impressions based on someone's tone and the inability to articulate that. Once you have actual content to go by and are past page 5, you should be done with such shallow reasons and should have better ones to justify a scumread. Like the fact that there is absolutely no reason to believe a single word you or your partners have said this whole game, because the only justification you seem to be able to give is to shout louder than other people.
When town allows lynches to be chosen by people based on bluster, there is only one outcome - scum victories.
You need to Shut. The. Fuck. Up. All you are doing is helping scum win.
and you need to actually read and piece context into stuff before you respond and learn that mafia isn't black and white.