Mafiascum.net

The whole Boon thing regarding the mastina wagon is wildly fallacious and I'm not entirely sure where he's pulled it from but it feels like the conclusions are arriving before the premises

In post 1524, jjh927 wrote:I'm not sure it's worth arguing with Boon

I’m not. I’m pushing the scumcase on him.

I’m compromising on Mastina at deadline, but he’s the lynch I want.

Why does he try to switch from Mastina as scum though?

I feel like he's genuinely trying to solve the game, but doing a bad job of it. He's not consciously attempting to lead us all off a cliff

In post 1523, Pine wrote:

In post 1520, Flavor Leaf wrote:Like scum are clearly okay with mastina lynch going through or else it wouldn’t be going through.

It also explains the pacing of the lynch whilst still looking like it was gonna happen.

Wildly false premise.

For starters, it hasn’t gone through yet

For another, most of us, by definition, are still Town. Scum can slow a lynch by not participating in it, but they can’t stop it. By your alleged logic, no lynch would ever go through without scum approval, and that’s demonstrably preposterous

Disagree.

Y’all must have incredibly surface level scum play then.

I’m conftown at this point. That’s just basic mafia. Post game we’ll see if I’m the individual who is the only one on the right track or way off.

I’ve had it both ways, but the games that I’m way off at one point i usually end up hard solving because I adapt unlike most players.

I don’t want the Mastina lynch or the BS lynch.

Let’s power somewhere.

I’m not wanting Jjh really either anymore.

UNVOTE: JJH

Mastina’s a mislynch.

Even if where I’m currently at is poor, I have games that show I end up going the right way. It’s a flipless Day 2 game. Nobody should be certain of anything.

If people are dense enough to think otherwise, they’re just bad at mafia.

And if you can accurately town read me, that’s a good chunk of my job as town right there.

Which actively spits in the face of anyone saying otherwise.

I could be wrong. I’m not dense enough like some people to think I’m 100% correct. But like L in death note, it’s good to move on like you are 100% correct until something has plausible deniability other than just singular WIFOM cases. Add the chain of actions up.

I'll vote Chemist if you promise not to say surface level any more in this game

In post 1531, Flavor Leaf wrote:I’m conftown at this point. That’s just basic mafia.

VOTE: chemist

what are the odds of a Pine CFD?

Problem I'm having with Boon is he's saying 3 scummy things for every townie thing he says. But he has said townie things, which is generally more townie things than he says in a scum game. If that makes sense. But yeah he has spewed a lot of dumb stuff this dayphase and it's legitimately distracting me. I still don't think he's today's lynch though.

I'd say I'm masons with JJH but I'm not mastina



Pine CFD isn't off limits, might take that over a chemist lynch even though I think my chemist read is not hydra-consensus... in fact I think Harley is fine with Chemist and Poison Ivy is fine with Chemist if my PT notes are up to date. So if we need to do chemist we can but, Katwoman isn't super in love with Chemist going today. In fact Harley specifically wanted Chemist over Pine ughh... annoying having Harley be out of town at EoD.

Right now we all agree we don't want mastina to be today's lynch though. BS is fine. Chemist is fine for several of our heads. Pine is fine for some of our heads. Poison Ivy started townreading Chickadee but most of our heads are still okay with that too. Obviously one is town out of that group.

We do however need a lynch in the next 12 hours and I'm not okay with it being mastina. If we can't get a better lynch than Binary Star, then we should lynch Binary Star.

-Kat

Boon why is Chemist better than BS for today if he is?

-Kat

What is CFD?

It's a slightly racist shorthand for 'end of day speedwagon'

'chinese fire drill'

Honestly, be my guest. I'd love to be out of this clusterfuck.

Mastina or Boon are my only choices.

In post 1409, Pine wrote:+I could see {Pine, Chemist, Cheeky, chicks} being a solve

Not sure I remember the context here but how many of these (not including yourself) do you think could be scum rn?

-Kat

The context was JJH being bad at math, and giving a scum solution set of five people (those four plus DEB).

The only one of those four I'm inclined to look deeper at is Chemist, because I think that {DEB, Boon} is 2/3 of the scumteam. The third is probably in {Mastina, Chemist, JJH}, but I'm not prepared to case any of those three. I'm only open to Mastina as a deadline compromise.

VOTE: Pine I can switch to chemist at EoD

Birthday shenanigans are winding down. I'll be going to bed soon. I'm not sure I'll be able to check in again before deadline. I'll be around for the next 20 minutes or so. We need to do something.

Vote someone that isn't mastina

-Kat

Mastina is still currently the biggest wagon. Other people don't seem to be around. That's kind of my point. I want to know WHO we're consolidating on. Going with "someone that isn't Mastina" isn't helpful.