In post 1523, Gamma Emerald wrote:I think you, Lucky, MT and Wake are Town, our of these I feel least strongly on Wake just because it’s pretty much just because of the role
I don’t have any leads on who is scum but I can probably figure it out through a mix of PoE and scumhunting at this point
I just need to actually do that
It doesn't have to be a dissertation, you can be objective in your impressions of who is potentially scum from your point of view.
Posted: Mon May 04, 2020 2:52 pm
by clidd
In post 1524, Morning Tweet wrote:
This is where i'm at rn. This + Gamma's claim makes me think we have it PoE'd
great likelihood of a scum bussing tictac-Chem + The d2 pivot to Aaron-Creature + Gamma's claim!! causes me to feel very strongly feel gamma is scum here, both readswise and mechanically
Gamma's recent posting causes me paranoia that i could have the setup balance wrong here though
Watcher + Babysitter + Rolecop + Neighbourizer + Neighbourizer Enabler fits as far as i know. Babysitter explains how watcher and a protective can coexist. Dave's role completed the setup in a way that seems like it wouldve been hard to come up with
If instead Wake or dave-Lucky IS actually scum in the PRs, i'd say dave because Wake's gambit makes 0 sense for a scum player to do outside of WIFOM. But i find this unlikely because of dave's anger and his weird stance on
being unlynchable solely on the grounds that he is a protective. My prior townread on Wake was pretty huge from d1
Gamma's sudden reaction to Lucky still concerns me. AtE is something im not strong reading
Gamma Emerald wrote:I think you, Lucky, MT and Wake are Town, our of these I feel least strongly on Wake just because it’s pretty much just because of the role
I don’t have any leads on who is scum but I can probably figure it out through a mix of PoE and scumhunting at this point
I just need to actually do that
Please do, it'd be really helpful
I fully agree on the worsening situation of Gamma's slot due to the events that occurred between D1 and D3. Regarding the roles, I don't have enough technical knowledge to say if the composition(setup) that the game state suggests is, in fact, one hundred percent true. However, Wake's mechanical observation may have been accidentally enlightening to reveal TPRs ahead of normal time, which possibly simplifies the game's solution in the systematic VTs lynch depending on the Gamma flip. In the {Dave/Wake} context, I also believe that Dave is more likely to be town due to the progressive irritation (Hectic commented on post 1404) that he presented, something difficult to emulate as scum.
I feel that Gamma's AtE is not comparable to Dave's AtE in terms of chemical reaction, and is probably connected to the FoS on his slot that we currently share, not something that arose long before and was accumulating like a snowball, so there are more expressive chances of being fake. At the moment, it is better for him and for us to avoid the emotional sphere, as we need to understand the slot better in logical terms before we proceed (although I am convinced that this is, evidently, the best lynch for today) .
Posted: Mon May 04, 2020 3:08 pm
by clidd
That's all, I guess. Waiting for the summary, Gamma.
Posted: Mon May 04, 2020 3:24 pm
by Gamma Emerald
Starting off with
Adorable
The Read
This is the only slot within my current PoE that has been replaced so I’ll be going over two players here. Despite the overall lack of posts I get a general town vibe from this slot, based on Adorable’s solving and sorting efforts, and CSF’s interactions with tictac/Chemist.
Questions For The Subject
In post 907, Adorable wrote:Gamma's iso is lacking content and some of his posts looked like he was agreeing with players.
What point were you trying to make here? You seem to indicate this is a reason to scumread me but there’s not much to explain why from what you’ve said.
My plan is to break this up across a few days, tomorrow I will do profii and Bob, and the next day I will do Hectic. I’m doing this so I don’t have a burnout.
Posted: Tue May 05, 2020 2:19 am
by LuckyLuciano
@Gamma, was there supposed to be a follow-up to 1529 ?
In post 1529, Gamma Emerald wrote:My plan is to break this up across a few days, tomorrow I will do profii and Bob, and the next day I will do Hectic. I’m doing this so I don’t have a burnout.
Posted: Tue May 05, 2020 3:12 am
by LuckyLuciano
I meant, is 1529 his complete breakdown of his Adorable read. I don't see how making a 2-sentence read on a player, and asking a single question would lead to burnout if done for 4 players at the same time. It feels like he either doesn't want to play the game anymore or he's stalling.
Posted: Tue May 05, 2020 10:10 am
by clidd
Hum, Gamma, I would like your opinion about this game:
You were replaced at the end of D3, but your posting frequency (85) is very similar to the number of posts here (92). The progression is basically the same: slow, with few reads and apathetic involvement with the game. Your successor was lynched on the D4, revealed as
Mafia Tracker
. The scum behavior you showed in that game is perfectly aligned with what you have shown so far here, should I consider it a coincidence ?
This is the only slot within my current PoE that has been replaced so I’ll be going over two players here. Despite the overall lack of posts I get a general town vibe from this slot, based on Adorable’s solving and sorting efforts, and CSF’s interactions with tictac/Chemist.
Questions For The Subject
In post 907, Adorable wrote:Gamma's iso is lacking content and some of his posts looked like he was agreeing with players.
What point were you trying to make here? You seem to indicate this is a reason to scumread me but there’s not much to explain why from what you’ve said.
Most of your posts on day 1 were short single sentences and I wasn't able to get much out of them. I often find myself scum reading players who make too many short single sentences.
Posted: Wed May 06, 2020 4:21 am
by profii
The more this game goes nowhere I dwell on the thought of 'wtf, ascetic town, lol no'
I said to myself I'd tunnel Wake for most of the day and my continued survival would be a sign that scum want me to continue to do so and I'm wrong but I'm already bored of that strategy.
VOTE: Gamma
Posted: Wed May 06, 2020 8:35 am
by bob3141
Ive seen it in my last game.
Was assetic town plus tracker/follower , roleblocker, rolestopper and cop. vs scum doc (assetic power) and another scum role 2 shot i think it was
Posted: Wed May 06, 2020 8:52 am
by Morning Tweet
It's less "Ascetic town doesn't exist", more "There is not an ascetic town in this game"
Posted: Wed May 06, 2020 8:58 am
by clidd
I'm back, any news from Gamma ?
Posted: Wed May 06, 2020 11:56 am
by clidd
Posted: Wed May 06, 2020 12:07 pm
by Klick
Hectic has been prodded.
Posted: Wed May 06, 2020 12:21 pm
by Hectic
wHoOpS. I was occupied with Misty's hat. It's just so fashionable, I can't help but spend all my time wearing it. I'm no multitasker, so I can't play mafia while wearing the hat at the same time, but I've taken it off for this special occasion.
Gamma is still scum.
Bobman should be questioned more since he's next in the running; I'll try to do that at some point.
Adorable isn't doing enough, is it possible if we could get a readslist from you, Puff?
Profii suggesting he was going to tunnel Wake and see if scum would leave both him and Wake alive or kill him was kinda towny.
Posted: Wed May 06, 2020 12:21 pm
by Hectic
In post 1536, profii wrote:The more this game goes nowhere I dwell on the thought of 'wtf, ascetic town, lol no'
Why? The modifier on it's own isn't really that AI; ascetic townies are a thing.
Posted: Wed May 06, 2020 12:22 pm
by Hectic
Btw, clidd: I'm not sure if I've already mentioned this but I absolutely adore the Sherlock GiFs/RP. Keep doing that for as long as possible please.
Posted: Wed May 06, 2020 2:03 pm
by clidd
In post 1544, Hectic wrote:Btw, clidd: I'm not sure if I've already mentioned this but I absolutely adore the Sherlock GiFs/RP. Keep doing that for as long as possible please.
Thank you, Hectic. You brightened my night (or day, depending on your time zone)
Spoiler:
Posted: Wed May 06, 2020 2:29 pm
by clidd
Ok, we're lynching Gamma. He's L-2 right now, I need one more vote on him and I will hammer.
Posted: Wed May 06, 2020 2:49 pm
by Morning Tweet
Gamma where'd you go ;(
Posted: Wed May 06, 2020 3:37 pm
by Gamma Emerald
My apologies, yesterday and today have been a mess, because my dad will not turn down his damn music speaker or use headphones when I’m trying to sleep at night and he’s doing things close by so my sleep has been kinda fucked
Posted: Wed May 06, 2020 3:40 pm
by Gamma Emerald
In post 1534, clidd wrote:Hum, Gamma, I would like your opinion about this game:
You were replaced at the end of D3, but your posting frequency (85) is very similar to the number of posts here (92). The progression is basically the same: slow, with few reads and apathetic involvement with the game. Your successor was lynched on the D4, revealed as
Mafia Tracker
. The scum behavior you showed in that game is perfectly aligned with what you have shown so far here, should I consider it a coincidence ?
I hardly fucking remember that game dude how the hell am I gonna tell what is and isn’t coincidence
