Posted: Thu Sep 10, 2020 4:50 pm
Vote Count D1-1 (Second Elimination)
With 13 players alive, it will take 7 votes to eliminate a player.
Phase Page Usage: 15/60
Day one will end in: 7 days, 23 hours, 9 minutes
It is now.In post 1524, Servant Avenger wrote:Town can be wrong, but the shielder wagon was not led by scum.
it is now led by scum?In post 1527, Servant Foreigner wrote:It is now.In post 1524, Servant Avenger wrote:Town can be wrong, but the shielder wagon was not led by scum.
VOTE: Shielder
Town don't think this.In post 1513, Servant Shielder wrote:some of you may have noticed that i was not on the archer wagon. i could have been on the archer wagon, but had i been those of you inclined to think im scum would have thought i was simply bussing.I dont think there was much to be learned from me being on the wagon, so i sat it out (despite it being on someone i stated a scumread on pretty early). whats interesting is who else was off-wagon. i think the elim was kinda inevitable so scum could easily have bussed, yet most of my scumreads were off-wagon. interesting.
Oh.In post 1526, Servant Shielder wrote:i feel like i wasnt ever very good at town, so apologies since it seems that hasnt changed since playing mafia again. please do message me postgame and offer coaching. advice, feedback, and criticism will be well-received. well i think my reads are generally ok, but most people strongly scumread me when i play town.
LIKE DUHIn post 1534, Servant Avenger wrote:Oh.In post 1526, Servant Shielder wrote:i feel like i wasnt ever very good at town, so apologies since it seems that hasnt changed since playing mafia again. please do message me postgame and offer coaching. advice, feedback, and criticism will be well-received. well i think my reads are generally ok, but most people strongly scumread me when i play town.
You're self aware.
town dont think strategically? it didnt matter one iota whether or not i was on that wagon. i dont see why me explaining my reasoning should suddenly make it scummy either.In post 1532, Servant Foreigner wrote:Town don't think this.In post 1513, Servant Shielder wrote:some of you may have noticed that i was not on the archer wagon. i could have been on the archer wagon, but had i been those of you inclined to think im scum would have thought i was simply bussing.I dont think there was much to be learned from me being on the wagon, so i sat it out (despite it being on someone i stated a scumread on pretty early). whats interesting is who else was off-wagon. i think the elim was kinda inevitable so scum could easily have bussed, yet most of my scumreads were off-wagon. interesting.
actually this is only true as town. i generally play better when im being widely scumread anywayIn post 1537, Servant Berserker wrote:LIKE DUHIn post 1534, Servant Avenger wrote:Oh.In post 1526, Servant Shielder wrote:i feel like i wasnt ever very good at town, so apologies since it seems that hasnt changed since playing mafia again. please do message me postgame and offer coaching. advice, feedback, and criticism will be well-received. well i think my reads are generally ok, but most people strongly scumread me when i play town.
You're self aware.
THEY HAVE 0 FILTER.
HOW OBVIOUS IS THIS?
You make me want to pay you on the head and say "Oh honey..." In a reassuring motherly voice everytime you post.In post 1535, Servant Shielder wrote:day 0 i felt strongly that caster was scum. day 1 i felt kinda weakly that caster might be town. im not sure how i feel about placing a vote on caster atm. definitely not my first choice, id prefer to go for someone like rider.
In post 1535, Servant Shielder wrote:day 0 i felt strongly that caster was scum. day 1 i felt kinda weakly that caster might be town. im not sure how i feel about placing a vote on caster atm. definitely not my first choice, id prefer to go for someone like rider.
well you'd be right if the archer elim wasnt inevitable. if we were in the scumhunting phase then my vote should be on scummy people. but archer was getting elimed there 100%. so it doesnt really matter whether i vote there or not.In post 1539, Servant Foreigner wrote:Adding multiple levels of self awareness doesn't magically make it townie. Scum bait out experience levels all the time on anon accounts, and I feel the only argument in his favor is his scummy actions are a result of a lack of experience.
If it was a stupid thought process that bad players actually think, sure why not. But no one goes "haha time to not vote my scum read because it won't breed good information".
You don't think the non-confident townie who is super worried about fucking up isn't constantly thinking about how to not look scummy, and then bringing it up asking if that was okay to do!?!In post 1539, Servant Foreigner wrote:Adding multiple levels of self awareness doesn't magically make it townie. Scum bait out experience levels all the time on anon accounts, and I feel the only argument in his favor is his scummy actions are a result of a lack of experience.
If it was a stupid thought process that bad players actually think, sure why not. But no one goes "haha time to not vote my scum read because it won't breed good information".
What was the gain?In post 1538, Servant Shielder wrote:town dont think strategically? it didnt matter one iota whether or not i was on that wagon. i dont see why me explaining my reasoning should suddenly make it scummy either.
omg you UNDERSTANDIn post 1541, Servant Beast wrote:You make me want to pay you on the head and say "Oh honey..." In a reassuring motherly voice everytime you post.In post 1535, Servant Shielder wrote:day 0 i felt strongly that caster was scum. day 1 i felt kinda weakly that caster might be town. im not sure how i feel about placing a vote on caster atm. definitely not my first choice, id prefer to go for someone like rider.
Just join your counter wagon like a good puppy
Sure, there are other scum to find.In post 1536, Servant Berserker wrote:Shielder was setup as a defacto vote for Day 1 through the entire master voting phase. That setup was done by scum. Archer participated in it.
WE ARE NEVER DOING SHIELDER TODAY NO MATTER HOW BAD THEY LOOK.
Shielder is not a vote we even begin to CONSIDER until after Day 2. After Day 3, even, depending on how many scum we murder.
I think Caster-Archer interactions are exactly what I expect from this scum team. I've been thinking it since yesterday and I really think there's some distancing going on and I justIn post 1547, Servant Avenger wrote:Sure, there are other scum to find.In post 1536, Servant Berserker wrote:Shielder was setup as a defacto vote for Day 1 through the entire master voting phase. That setup was done by scum. Archer participated in it.
WE ARE NEVER DOING SHIELDER TODAY NO MATTER HOW BAD THEY LOOK.
Shielder is not a vote we even begin to CONSIDER until after Day 2. After Day 3, even, depending on how many scum we murder.
I don't think the scum team are team players tbh. Archer was pretty much left to rot.
I mean it wasn't about looking scummy it was about gaining "information". And I am not sure what information they were trying to gain.In post 1544, Servant Berserker wrote:You don't think the non-confident townie who is super worried about fucking up isn't constantly thinking about how to not look scummy, and then bringing it up asking if that was okay to do!?!
YOU THINK THAT PATTERN MATCHES WRONG? YOU THINK THAT'S SCUM, REALLY?
God.