Mafiascum.net

In post 1521, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:r u really giving me shit for not analyzing a survey that half the fucking game didnt even bother to fill out

What do you think of the people who did fill it out? Do you think not filling it out was scum-indicative? Is anyone's list particularly suspicious to you?

I thought Pooky would do something with the list as well.

VOTE: Taro

I'm not seeing anything redeeming here.

In post 1519, NDMath wrote:

In post 1508, Morning Tweet wrote:what's a GtH?

Yeah Pooky is unreadable he could be scum but if not I heavily lean towards ND cause Pooky is plausible enough

i do kind of echo the sentiment that Pooky hasnt really added anything to the analysis, at least today. The most interesting thing he did was adjust his reads in order to counter scum!Skybird

Gun to Head is where you force everyone to call a small number of players scum and everyone else town, which is fundamentally very similar to what pooky did. It's followed up with an analysis of what the results, not just a list.
I think town!pooky would be more readable than he is right now.

In post 1513, Almost50 wrote:

In post 1506, NDMath wrote:VOTE: Pooky
ISO is half a poor attempt at running a GtH with IioA on results, and most of the rest is fluff.

I'd forget everything I said all game and vote YOU for this one.

Idk, I guess I'm just frustrated at this point. I also don't understand what the townreads on him are for.

Maybe. I'm not really sure what the secret sauce to reading Pooky is, at least when he's not playing much like in this game. I don't know why he's townread either to be fair

In post 1521, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:r u really giving me shit for not analyzing a survey that half the fucking game didnt even bother to fill out

i meannnnnnn is it invalid because 5 responses were missing? Perhaps you could draw a conclusion on the gamestate from that?

Mine would have to be that scum doesn't give a fuck about anything right now and aren't pushing anything to be honest. i know that at least 75% but prolly more of the wagons yesterday were town, i was incorrectly scumbinned, probably more. Scum just has to be like "Yeah that one's cool" for the rest of the game and it's whatever to them. thats my working theory

Which, granted, could be wrong but its the best i have and if my townreads are scum then my scumreads i feel haven't given me enough to be able to overturn that

RR has a good point that Tarou claiming after the fact that "Why didn't we kill Ari it was so obvious" was really bad

i'm interested in hearing more from ppl who aren't playing who they prefer to be wagoned. Cause that's like... the game.. but yeah

Also we're probably running low on time so like if you're town maybe just throw your thoughts into the mix

i mean its useful to do analysis on things that matter

im not sure this even matters cuz half tbe game didnt even take it seriously

which means the people who filled it out might not take it seriously

so im not going to waste time analyzing sometbing that could just be a pile of garbage that nobody took seriously

also not really feeling motivated to try much in a game where half the players wont fill out a simple preference survey

that was like our attempt at getting ppl who weren't playing to play and even that failed for some players

that in of itself can be useful even if not as much as it could be

I suppose i'm surprised you haven't bothered to give an opinion on anyone, u usually tunnel on like one scumread or something

i did and i got yelled at by skybird

~.~

I know I'm part of the problem cause I didn't fill out a preference list but... I stated at least a lim pref

In post 1533, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:i did and i got yelled at by skybird

well maybe it's because you based your entire readslist as a counter to hers

or at least that's how i interpreted it

unofficial VC

NDmath (4) : Morning Tweet ; Titus ; Gamma Emerald ; Radical Rat
Titus (3) : Yuki Takeya ; Taroumaru ; Almost50
PookyTheMagicalBear (1) : NDmath
Dwlee99 (1) : Hated
Taroumaru (1) : Skybird

Not Voting (4) : Aristophanes ; Enchant ; PookyTheMagicalBear ; Dwlee99

7 to execute

(also there's 3 days left)

please just vote one of ND/Tarou i guarantee at least one is scum and if town is inactive and scum manipulates it so the town one dies ill figure it out just help me

ill probly sheep you if you want me to

not in the mood rn

In post 1533, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:i did and i got yelled at by skybird

Sorry Pooky. If you need to tunnel me to get back in the game go ahead.

I think we have to look at who didn't turn a list in especially if they haven't said anything about it.

id honestly rather elim in the people who did turn in a list because i dont think scum are as likely to give up agency as town are

im not so sure scum cares who dies

So either they'd submit a list without putting a care in, or they dont send a list at all

in any case im starting to lose interest and i just want to kill people who aren't playing much who are also more likely to be scum

I'm resenting the implication that people not submitting a list is a problem. I would a) not rank because reads are fluid and b) even if I did I would want more data and c) I'm not involved enough.

@Tweet, if we feel scum don't care, then a speed wagon on a vapid posting lurker may be ideal.

In post 1543, Morning Tweet wrote:im not so sure scum cares who dies

So either they'd submit a list without putting a care in, or they dont send a list at all

in any case im starting to lose interest and i just want to kill people who aren't playing much who are also more likely to be scum

This is why I was looking to lim people who weren't active earlier.

In post 1524, Radical Rat wrote:VOTE: NDMath
E-2 but E-1 counting Dwlee

Actually only E-3, I didn't actually count and just saw that the official VC said Exe-3 before I voted. Which I assume was a mistake unless NDMath is also somehow hated?

VOTE: NDMath

I don't even like this but I'm just sheeping tweetie

honestly we'd probly get better odds just randomly flashwagonning someone else

why dont you like