In post 1506, Toogeloo wrote:I think Galron is afraid of doing something scummy.
One of Taly's earlier posts struck me that way too.
Mind sharing which post struck you so? I'm really curious tbh
Spoiler:
In post 1308, Taly wrote:Phoneposting on break with what feels to be another migraine coming in - or sinus infection? No fever yet though.
Quick thoughts
Ceph's frustration about being at the bottom of the reading totem pole rings genuine but I don't know if that is AI or what the alignment would be yet.
First impulse is that scum doesn't openly admit that they're very low effort by justifying how and why the game is stale. Doubly so for the sincerity of their vote on Gamma since there was no half asked excuse that they are definitively scum.. If Galron was scum, why go against my wishes about hammering intention?
If Galron is who I think he is, he is a very competent player. But I don't think a pre-emptive BoP based on questionable alt hunting skills is the next step for me to approach the slot. So I don't feel compelled to vote there.
Peta and skitter feel good to townbin.
I don't follow Pooky's read progression of Gamma.
Dwlee flip sounds increasingly attractive but not quite feeling the drive to push that.
Dunn quickwagon pinged.
Gamma looks better but I wish he would engage with my points about him being scum. It feels like an admission of guilt to let my suspicion go unresolved since he townreads me with such confidence.
Terms like, "first impulse," usually signify an attempt to be delicate in tone, as if you don't want to make a firm statement.
In post 986, Taly wrote:I keep forgetting peta is in this game. Hiding!
How'd you forget, you asked me about my vote on them like 10 posts up from this one, lol.
@Pooky... Is it fair to say the only way to tell if you are town or scum is to cut you open and see if there is white fuzzy stuffing, or a hollow empty shell?
A chaotic attention span, like just now seeing this post in your ISO!
Toogeloo wrote:Wait. Now I feel like I'm playing Mafia... /ugh
That's the idea, panda.
Posted: Tue Oct 05, 2021 3:26 pm
by ulyana
In post 1537, Taly wrote:A chaotic attention span, like just now seeing this post in your ISO!
hm, why were you looking at toogeloo's iso?
Posted: Tue Oct 05, 2021 3:27 pm
by ulyana
this kinda what i meant by out of time by the way
Posted: Tue Oct 05, 2021 3:32 pm
by Taly
I usually look at ISOs on a whim or if I'm trying to scroll and see peoples posts easier or ones I may have missed. It helps me when I want to post link or double check if what I read matches with what I interpreted at the time.
In post 1261, Saber wrote:Toog - His uncaring play is more likely to be town, doesn't give the feeling he cares about how his posts will look every time he pops in. An example would be the vote on Prism.
fwiw the fact that nearly everyone is townreading toog for being too scummy to be scum is a little weird
i don't think it's nearly everyone, fwiw, at least when i was expressing it it was as a reaction against like cakez/ceph calling his votes terrible or whatever
maybe the wind has shifted but i'm not really sure what that means
i would have to concur that the day feels like it's getting a bit long in the tooth now although i recognize that a few people are doing work still
basically nothing galron has said makes me want to unvote. wouldn't put the highest confidence on it being a hit but as i said i don't have a ton of strong scumreads this game
if this day goes a little longer i might reread and try to put my thoughts into a coherent readslist form but i don't think there's anything i want to do particularly
Posted: Tue Oct 05, 2021 3:48 pm
by Dwlee99
I'm either voting all with scum or like mostly town
Posted: Tue Oct 05, 2021 4:09 pm
by PookyTheMagicalBear
In post 1541, petapan wrote:i told him i'm hard shielding him this game to subvert my "meta", it's gonna throw you for a loop
peta-scum would be cheeky enough to say this to my face