Mafiascum.net

thor i dont get this aggressiveness towards me
is it because ive caught your buddies?

Actually if anybody has a town or scum case in wisdom I'd like the key points on it.

I only remember playing 3 games with him and though I've had some success in reading him before I feel it's too early to tell here.

Tone seems townie but then there's the misquoting posts he claims he hasn't read fully which is very odd.

In post 1552, BuJaber wrote:Actually if anybody has a town or scum case in wisdom I'd like the key points on it.

I only remember playing 3 games with him and though I've had some success in reading him before I feel it's too early to tell here.

Tone seems townie but then there's the misquoting posts he claims he hasn't read fully which is very odd.

I think Wisdom is not being as gamesolvey as I remember him, but as I said long ago, I felt the same way until D3 when we played together. Even if I thought that Wisdom could be scum (which I do), I would leave that for later. Maybe I'll be dead before having to decide. So in conclusion, I'd be impressed if anyone in here had a hard case on Wisdom, either as town or scum, and I would think that the person hard reading Wisdom would be most likely trying to push an agenda ("Wisdom is town because..." could be pocketing, "Wisdom is scum because..." could be taking out a strong player on D1)

There's much more players who are being easily read and I'm starting to see some convergence between my townreads, so it's time to start pushing the correct wagons.

In post 1550, Wisdom wrote:thor i dont get this aggressiveness towards me
is it because ive caught your buddies?

How am I being more aggressive towards you than you are towards me?
Is it because you're scared I'll catch your buddies after I catch you?

votecount

With 26 alive it takes 14 to lynch.

Majiffy (6):	Wisdom (1078),	BuJaber (1222),	Gamma Emerald (1231),	DrewVa (1344),	CheekyTeeky (1446),	Alonzo (1542),
DrippingGoofball (4):	davesaz (56),	BrightEyedFish (1089),	RCEnigma (1098),	Amzela (1150),
BuJaber (4):	DrippingGoofball (609),	profii (1142),	Thor665 (1438),	Varsoon (1452),
Chickadee (3):	Fortian (830),	Creature (1540),	pinturicchio (1551),
Creature (2):	Majiffy (1314),	hebichan (1320),
BrightEyedFish (1):	Alchemist21 (386),
RCEnigma (1):	Tails (477),
profii (1):	Reasonably Rational (893),
Flavor Leaf (1):	Malakitty (1178),
Not voting (3):	Toogeloo,	Flavor Leaf (416),	Chickadee (1442),

(expired on 2018-12-04 02:30:00) remain.

In post 1546, BuJaber wrote:Mala's ISO is pretty empty, but hebichan is even worse. There's barely any analysis here. Even when posting a case she seems to give herself an out by offering an argument for why they could be wrong.

This is probably the best reason to scumread her and is exactly how Varsoon pegged my scumgame. Gives a convenient defense when X flips as a mislynch when they can point back to a post the argued the counterpoints in.

Could you post a few examples from where you got that read?
Also I don't mind flipping Majiffy either he's practically a DGB copy at this point with more sarcasm peppered in.

The only thing stopping me from flipping wagons is that I agree with Majiffy, Chickadee has scum equity. If DGB flips scum chickadee probably does too.

In post 1552, BuJaber wrote:Tone seems townie but then there's the misquoting posts he claims he hasn't read fully which is very odd.

what
it sounds like you didnt understand anything about whats happened

In post 1555, Thor665 wrote:

In post 1550, Wisdom wrote:thor i dont get this aggressiveness towards me
is it because ive caught your buddies?

How am I being more aggressive towards you than you are towards me?
Is it because you're scared I'll catch your buddies after I catch you?

Im not aggressive? I just called your reads and vote awful
Meanwhile you take personal stabs at me

If you agree that suggesting reads are awful is fine then what personal stabs did I take at you?

your whole 1544 felt like you had the need to discredit me

@RCE:

In post 419, hebichan wrote:

In post 408, Flavor Leaf wrote:

In post 379, Wisdom wrote:

In post 376, Varsoon wrote:Dude is now on wisdom, who I am pretty sure is town

that buddying tho

Looks like Wisdom/Varsoon buddies.

Everyone has a buddy yet? If you don’t have a buddy raise your hand.

There should be 13 pairs. Let’s lynch within the pair that gels the least.

Hebichan/Flavor are gelling the most for the Fun Fact I posted about the Snivy thing a few pages back.

We also both live on the west coast.


Not sure I like Profii's response there. I've used the same line as scum a lot. Then again, I have genuinely lost my train of thought as town.

In post 503, hebichan wrote:I just don't like the strongman attitude from tails here. Could be in his range, I guess. But I've seen a lot of things like "earned the right to live today" come from scum trying to position themselves as strong town voices.

In post 703, hebichan wrote:I feel a bit bad now because I looked at my past games and I don't think I've played with scum!wisdom looking back...

At the same time this still feels a bit off from wisdom's town voice, but I'm not as certain now.

In post 1558, Wisdom wrote:

In post 1552, BuJaber wrote:Tone seems townie but then there's the misquoting posts he claims he hasn't read fully which is very odd.

what
it sounds like you didnt understand anything about whats happened

How so?

RR accused you of misrepresenting his post regarding creature. You claimed it was because you didn't read the whole post and misunderstood the part you did read.

yes and the odd part about that is...?

It's hard to believe

i don't get it
sounds like you misunderstood

what is hard to believe
I saw cerb saying creature should wall post and i lt instantly triggered me

and why is this even a point of discussion
Why would i lie about this

In post 1564, BuJaber wrote:It's hard to believe

That I couldn’t see
That you were always there beside me

Ah, is Mala still on me for my “joking personality” even though she’s met me in person and played multiple games with me, and knows how I am. Alright. Let me ISO dive her

I feel like I’m just her scapegoat vote, a step past RVS. I don’t know if I think it’s coming from scumher, but I don’t like it. It’s a lazy read.

Failed boldening.

I also feel like Wisdom’s town. Back during the Wisdom vs Nancy, I legit agreed with the cases they were making, and Wisdomms been at the forefront since then. He’s not trying to hide, and with being in a 1v1 like that it set him up to be a potential shot, and I don’t think scum does that in this kind of game. I feel we’d get more of a sense of Wisdom having political reads if he were scum, if that makes sense.

I’ll do a more in-depth catchup after I get home tomorrow night.

In post 1493, Reasonably Rational wrote:

In post 1491, Wisdom wrote:Cerb youre still misunderstanding
You said "Make quote walls and people should read them because text game"
Im saying "Then let him post like he is doing now, people should read them because text game"
More clear now?

In post 1490, Reasonably Rational wrote:Just to make this clear for those who may have difficulty with reading the intent of my posts:

I think Creature's way of catching up is perfectly fine

,while also feeling that there are ways to accomplish the same goal without making lots of posts. *shrug*

-Cerb

Wisdom is finding fault with your posts wrt Creature posting, where none exists.

~Nancy

Hi