Mafiascum.net

In post 1545, NorwegianboyEE wrote:

In post 1540, androgybee wrote:so i think bell is very likely town. uhh. norway is still probably town.

sorry we've been so bad this game. both of us just kind of got demotivated and yeah. we'll use our ability soon. it extends the day 24 hours, btw. do people have thoughts on who we should target?

~Nahdia

If mafia kills by instantly giving 3 corruption, then maybe your target will essentially become bulletproof?
Either way, just don’t give any scum this ability.

If Bee is truthful this basically throws out the 3 corruption kill theory imo

fair enough. if im shooting for town, i probably target Bell here.

i dont think starbuck should be allowed to be on EOD wagons.

~nahdia

In post 1550, BananaCucho wrote:

In post 1545, NorwegianboyEE wrote:

In post 1540, androgybee wrote:so i think bell is very likely town. uhh. norway is still probably town.

sorry we've been so bad this game. both of us just kind of got demotivated and yeah. we'll use our ability soon. it extends the day 24 hours, btw. do people have thoughts on who we should target?

~Nahdia

If mafia kills by instantly giving 3 corruption, then maybe your target will essentially become bulletproof?
Either way, just don’t give any scum this ability.

If Bee is truthful this basically throws out the 3 corruption kill theory imo

Why Banana?

In post 1552, NorwegianboyEE wrote:

In post 1550, BananaCucho wrote:

In post 1545, NorwegianboyEE wrote:

In post 1540, androgybee wrote:so i think bell is very likely town. uhh. norway is still probably town.

sorry we've been so bad this game. both of us just kind of got demotivated and yeah. we'll use our ability soon. it extends the day 24 hours, btw. do people have thoughts on who we should target?

~Nahdia

If mafia kills by instantly giving 3 corruption, then maybe your target will essentially become bulletproof?
Either way, just don’t give any scum this ability.

If Bee is truthful this basically throws out the 3 corruption kill theory imo

Why Banana?

Bees ability makes a player immune to any night kill whatsoever? Seems... broken?

UNVOTE:

Bee go ahead imo, no need to wait longer

But they suicide. Shouldn’t a town ability that kills the player be at least somewhat powerful? If they die to make player X corruption free and then nafia just immediately kill player X then what’s the point of their role? From a setup perspective it’s just a stupid role.

beeboy agrees with me that starbuck is scum. their catchups have been uninspiring and frankly, easy. they vote us, then unvote after our claim and say they'll re-evaluate (they dont), then accuse us of being convenient and revote when a wagon starts to form. didnt like them admitting theyre speculating on banana being a 3p, that feels like scum-mindset since town is more concerned with finding scum.

D&D still a townlean, but /shrug. havent really paid close attention there since d1
porkens claim is a little weird and seems to not fit into the rest of the setup. how many visiting roles have been claimed? at any rate, it should be tested: porkens should target a known visiting role tonight and confirm their target before that player claims tomorrow.

i havent liked jackel today either. it seems like they're just trying to be way outside the consensus in order to appear like "wrong town" but ultimately it just reads as their reads are unlikely to be real.

catboi and reatea, no idea lol.

~nahdia

ive got errands to run in like an hour. i'll suicide before i go unless beeboy yells at me not to. is it worth me reading catboi and redtea's d2? when i flip town, will you listen to anything spicy i may or may not say on them?

If you say they are scum maybe i’ll reconsider but otherwise i’ve got them both as town and will continue to do so unless i learn i’m wrong about any of Porkens/Jackel/Starbuck being scum.

The thing about Porkens claim tho is that scum can have that role, testing them means nothing probably since it doesn't confirm their alignment

I don't know that I can be convinced to vote elsewhere at this point

In post 1557, androgybee wrote:ive got errands to run in like an hour. i'll suicide before i go unless beeboy yells at me not to. is it worth me reading catboi and redtea's d2? when i flip town, will you listen to anything spicy i may or may not say on them?

I will consider your reads when you flip town, yeah
Just as we have considered Joeys reads

Tbh, i don’t even think Androgybee needs to suicide at this point. I’m fine with them living until we’ve played hangman with Porkens.

In post 1561, NorwegianboyEE wrote:Tbh, i don’t even think Androgybee needs to suicide at this point. I’m fine with them living until we’ve played hangman with Porkens.

No its needed 110% they cant live after that claim

that team makes sense to me i guess, it's just one of those things where it feels too simple and im assuming i've got something wrong, you know?

~this has all been Nahdia still, ive just gotten lazy about signing all my posts.

BananaCucho wrote:The thing about Porkens claim tho is that scum can have that role, testing them means nothing probably since it doesn't confirm their alignment

I don't know that I can be convinced to vote elsewhere at this point

oh right u might just execute him today. that's fine too i guess? scum could have that role sure but like, what does it actually look for? im not looking at the claims list but i dont remember that many visiting roles. bell, the two clerics i guess, and uh.... anything else?

NorwegianboyEE wrote:Tbh, i don’t even think Androgybee needs to suicide at this point. I’m fine with them living until we’ve played hangman with Porkens.

well we're in evens so a daykill is favorable i think?

If they are scum thats the type of pass they were fishing for with that claim

In post 1557, androgybee wrote:ive got errands to run in like an hour. i'll suicide before i go unless beeboy yells at me not to. is it worth me reading catboi and redtea's d2? when i flip town, will you listen to anything spicy i may or may not say on them?

Read us if you want. I don't think redtea is that likely to be scum anymore. I don't think porkens's claim makes a difference because I think he's just scum regardless and it doesn't fit with the amount of power already claimed.

In post 1562, BananaCucho wrote:

In post 1561, NorwegianboyEE wrote:Tbh, i don’t even think Androgybee needs to suicide at this point. I’m fine with them living until we’ve played hangman with Porkens.

No its needed 110% they cant live after that claim

Their catchup has been town as fuck. Is an unnecesarry death that limits town votes in the game further just to ease your concience really worth it?

In post 1563, androgybee wrote:that team makes sense to me i guess, it's just one of those things where it feels too simple and im assuming i've got something wrong, you know?

~this has all been Nahdia still, ive just gotten lazy about signing all my posts.

BananaCucho wrote:The thing about Porkens claim tho is that scum can have that role, testing them means nothing probably since it doesn't confirm their alignment

I don't know that I can be convinced to vote elsewhere at this point

oh right u might just execute him today. that's fine too i guess? scum could have that role sure but like, what does it actually look for? im not looking at the claims list but i dont remember that many visiting roles. bell, the two clerics i guess, and uh.... anything else?

NorwegianboyEE wrote:Tbh, i don’t even think Androgybee needs to suicide at this point. I’m fine with them living until we’ve played hangman with Porkens.

well we're in evens so a daykill is favorable i think?

Saintess too, and fruit vendor

In post 1566, NorwegianboyEE wrote:

In post 1562, BananaCucho wrote:

In post 1561, NorwegianboyEE wrote:Tbh, i don’t even think Androgybee needs to suicide at this point. I’m fine with them living until we’ve played hangman with Porkens.

No its needed 110% they cant live after that claim

Their catchup has been town as fuck. Is an unnecesarry death that limits town votes in the game further just to ease your concience really worth it?

Yes.

Scum doesn’t make this kinda suicide gambit, they just don’t.

i dont wanna play outguess the mod with redtea/norway having the same role. i think it's very unlikely BOTH of them are scum, but aside from that, the role is null. redtea claiming to target no one did ping me quite a bit though.

I mean, i won’t cry if they suicide right now. But to me it’s unnecesarry when obvscum Porkens is still alive.

In post 1570, androgybee wrote:i dont wanna play outguess the mod with redtea/norway having the same role. i think it's very unlikely BOTH of them are scum, but aside from that, the role is null. redtea claiming to target no one did ping me quite a bit though.

It's likely something that will hopefully self resolve

I agree that I doubt both are scum but 1 absolutely could be

also like I said earlier, porkens check on redtea doesn't make any sense from a town POV. Tbh I wouldn't mind just bopping him today although I'm a little worried about the situation the kills will leave us in. (^・ω・^ )

In post 1573, catboi wrote:also like I said earlier, porkens check on redtea doesn't make any sense from a town POV. Tbh I wouldn't mind just bopping him today although I'm a little worried about the situation the kills will leave us in. (^・ω・^ )

I think he's caught scum, its not 100% but it feels really sure and we need a scum flip today

With that role claim he seems likely mafia vs 3p but its anyones guess who the 3p is