Mafiascum.net

If it comes down to Frog or BCG, I am Team Frog all the way.

I guess if Save is a villager I'd raise an eyebrow a tad but if he's a wolf the likelihood of them both being a wolf goes down a lot. Maybe I should come to a better answer on Save's alignment, sure I'll put that on my todo list.
pedit: that's nice Titus

In post 1549, MariaR wrote:Basically, I think Frog has a higher chance of flipping scum than BCG.

For them to be partners, they had to stage an entirely pointless argument that only made both of them look worse, and I suppose if you want to argue they have a big enough ego to do that, sure. What am I missing about BCG because it seems like you're confident on that to some degree.

From what I have gone through so far in the game town seemed to consolidate on BGC yet the Alisae/Greeting slot was elimmed and Kitty slot (who suspected BGC died)

Most towns tend to reflect back on failed wagons D2 and that didn’t happen

So I asked why in my opening and the responses were weird.

Frog linked me to his reads and BGC was “kill it with fire”

Yet Frog never votes BGC and wants to “test” BGC with an StD elim.

Granted I haven’t gotten to the fight you’re alluding to but I am still shocked if they did fight why won’t they vote each other.

Like I will compromise on Frog if we can’t do BGC but this must resistance on someone not playing is odd

In post 1552, MathBlade wrote:

In post 1549, MariaR wrote:Basically, I think Frog has a higher chance of flipping scum than BCG.

For them to be partners, they had to stage an entirely pointless argument that only made both of them look worse, and I suppose if you want to argue they have a big enough ego to do that, sure. What am I missing about BCG because it seems like you're confident on that to some degree.

From what I have gone through so far in the game town seemed to consolidate on BGC yet the Alisae/Greeting slot was elimmed and Kitty slot (who suspected BGC died)

Most towns tend to reflect back on failed wagons D2 and that didn’t happen

So I asked why in my opening and the responses were weird.

Frog linked me to his reads and BGC was “kill it with fire”

Yet Frog never votes BGC and wants to “test” BGC with an StD elim.

Granted I haven’t gotten to the fight you’re alluding to but I am still shocked if they did fight why won’t they vote each other.

I see what you're selling and consider me nodding along. Guess that means the vote should be in Save/BGC/Frog wow, that was easy.

Anyone who thinks Enchant is town I would be surprised if they're townreading Titus given how badly the former slot was (yes 5 posts blah blah) do I think Enchant is town? Meh. Do I think Titus is town? Meh part 2

Could I convince people there's a wolf in BGC/Frog because there 100% probably is? Don't know, it'd probably be easier to vote Save and see where that leads but I'll go the hard route for now.

I'm still not seeing scum Frog, their play is really erratic here but feels townie erratic. I don't know, the frustration with BCG D1 felt more like town hyperfocusing on a specific slot for reasons which were going beyond the game itself. I'm aware scum isn't always robotic and sensible but I feel like scum would be more likely to rein it in a bit.

BCG I'd be content with eliminating though. Have had some doubts on the slot (mainly due to Kitty's elimination) but their responses since returning to the game haven't been townie in the slightest. Given their activity D1 feels like they're not contributing much in the hope we'll just forget them and opt for someone else.

In post 1556, MalcolmTucker wrote:I'm still not seeing scum Frog, their play is really erratic here but feels townie erratic. I don't know, the frustration with BCG D1 felt more like town hyperfocusing on a specific slot for reasons which were going beyond the game itself. I'm aware scum isn't always robotic and sensible but I feel like scum would be more likely to rein it in a bit.

Even with the slight nod at how your theory is a little meh it's still way too black and white for how a game of mafia works. You can get angry at a slot and still be a wolf, it is such an easy emotion to generate. Why would a wolf need to rein it in to begin with when Frog has been trying to play town leader and half the people here bowed down and said "yes master" Day 1? There's 0 reason to do any of what you're saying.

In post 1556, MalcolmTucker wrote:I'm still not seeing scum Frog, their play is really erratic here but feels townie erratic. I don't know, the frustration with BCG D1 felt more like town hyperfocusing on a specific slot for reasons which were going beyond the game itself. I'm aware scum isn't always robotic and sensible but I feel like scum would be more likely to rein it in a bit.

BCG I'd be content with eliminating though. Have had some doubts on the slot (mainly due to Kitty's elimination) but their responses since returning to the game haven't been townie in the slightest. Given their activity D1 feels like they're not contributing much in the hope we'll just forget them and opt for someone else.

Can you answer my damn questions instead of going back and forth with the bitter low PoE slots who spam "kill frog"over and over again?

Town doesn't need chaos and lone wolves right now it needs organization.

I am looking at a BCG Frog Titus world atm

Titus just isn’t giving any solve or block or anything

And when I started poking at BGC Frog she voted me because “gasoline”?

She’s put more effort into not giving reads

In post 1558, Frogsterking wrote:

In post 1556, MalcolmTucker wrote:I'm still not seeing scum Frog, their play is really erratic here but feels townie erratic. I don't know, the frustration with BCG D1 felt more like town hyperfocusing on a specific slot for reasons which were going beyond the game itself. I'm aware scum isn't always robotic and sensible but I feel like scum would be more likely to rein it in a bit.

BCG I'd be content with eliminating though. Have had some doubts on the slot (mainly due to Kitty's elimination) but their responses since returning to the game haven't been townie in the slightest. Given their activity D1 feels like they're not contributing much in the hope we'll just forget them and opt for someone else.

Can you answer my damn questions instead of going back and forth with the bitter low PoE slots who spam "kill frog"over and over again?

Town doesn't need chaos and lone wolves right now it needs organization.

You have to realize on some level right now that it's in scum interest to spam the thread up by whatever means necessary and prevent us from consolidating a Town core.

If I rolled my eyes any harder they're fall out of my skull.
pedit: I'm okay with that world tbh

In post 1555, MariaR wrote:Could I convince people there's a wolf in BGC/Frog because there 100% probably is? Don't know, it'd probably be easier to vote Save and see where that leads but I'll go the hard route for now.

I’d do Titus over Save.

Save is just eww imho based on Frogs play.

Frog, who are we voting?

We're not getting the face today. I'd rather eliminate boring but less risky scum in Malcom but I'd settle for a PoE lim.

In post 1560, Frogsterking wrote:

In post 1558, Frogsterking wrote:

In post 1556, MalcolmTucker wrote:I'm still not seeing scum Frog, their play is really erratic here but feels townie erratic. I don't know, the frustration with BCG D1 felt more like town hyperfocusing on a specific slot for reasons which were going beyond the game itself. I'm aware scum isn't always robotic and sensible but I feel like scum would be more likely to rein it in a bit.

BCG I'd be content with eliminating though. Have had some doubts on the slot (mainly due to Kitty's elimination) but their responses since returning to the game haven't been townie in the slightest. Given their activity D1 feels like they're not contributing much in the hope we'll just forget them and opt for someone else.

Can you answer my damn questions instead of going back and forth with the bitter low PoE slots who spam "kill frog"over and over again?

Town doesn't need chaos and lone wolves right now it needs organization.

You have to realize on some level right now that it's in scum interest to spam the thread up by whatever means necessary and prevent us from consolidating a Town core.

I am building a town block. You’re just not in it.

In post 1562, MathBlade wrote:

In post 1555, MariaR wrote:Could I convince people there's a wolf in BGC/Frog because there 100% probably is? Don't know, it'd probably be easier to vote Save and see where that leads but I'll go the hard route for now.

I’d do Titus over Save.

Save is just eww imho based on Frogs play.

If we could bet, I'd bet your entire pool is town.

In post 1560, Frogsterking wrote:

In post 1558, Frogsterking wrote:

In post 1556, MalcolmTucker wrote:I'm still not seeing scum Frog, their play is really erratic here but feels townie erratic. I don't know, the frustration with BCG D1 felt more like town hyperfocusing on a specific slot for reasons which were going beyond the game itself. I'm aware scum isn't always robotic and sensible but I feel like scum would be more likely to rein it in a bit.

BCG I'd be content with eliminating though. Have had some doubts on the slot (mainly due to Kitty's elimination) but their responses since returning to the game haven't been townie in the slightest. Given their activity D1 feels like they're not contributing much in the hope we'll just forget them and opt for someone else.

Can you answer my damn questions instead of going back and forth with the bitter low PoE slots who spam "kill frog"over and over again?

Town doesn't need chaos and lone wolves right now it needs organization.

You have to realize on some level right now that it's in scum interest to spam the thread up by whatever means necessary and prevent us from consolidating a Town core.

I agree with you scum love to spam up the thread and fill it with nonse-

oh . . .

In post 1562, MathBlade wrote:

In post 1555, MariaR wrote:Could I convince people there's a wolf in BGC/Frog because there 100% probably is? Don't know, it'd probably be easier to vote Save and see where that leads but I'll go the hard route for now.

I’d do Titus over Save.

Save is just eww imho based on Frogs play.

I'm not entirely convinced on Titus scum tbh, could just be misguided villager following Frog who knows. I'm not against Save going over because I think it'd at least wake people up to more scummy slots instead of trying to come up with this false world that's never existed

In post 1565, Titus wrote:

In post 1562, MathBlade wrote:

In post 1555, MariaR wrote:Could I convince people there's a wolf in BGC/Frog because there 100% probably is? Don't know, it'd probably be easier to vote Save and see where that leads but I'll go the hard route for now.

I’d do Titus over Save.

Save is just eww imho based on Frogs play.

If we could bet, I'd bet your entire pool is town.

Oooh it’s actual reads.

Got any town block yet?

Mines Maria Marci Cape Std Enchant and Me

Oh forgot furtive whoops they’re in the town block

In post 1560, Frogsterking wrote:You have to realize on some level right now that it's in scum interest to spam the thread up by whatever means necessary and prevent us from consolidating a Town core.

Math scum does this, which is why PookyTheMagicalBear townreading Math based on post quantity makes no sense. PookyTheMagicalBear also said MathBlade wasn't avoiding him but they had no memorable interactions.

I'm actually coming around to town Math because of how dense and wrong he is.

And if anything he should know my accuracy and ability to read Frogster based on the last anon game.

Yet people not playing his way doesn't fit in his worldview regardless of his alignment so it gets discarded.

In post 1569, MathBlade wrote:Oh forgot furtive whoops they’re in the town block

I can agree on Furtive town.

The rest I don't have TRs on.

Back to the pool for me. Goated lists keep it up
pedit: You both could be a villagers tbh I'm not putting that world out.
Pooky is just a wolf but meh

In post 1567, MariaR wrote:

In post 1562, MathBlade wrote:

In post 1555, MariaR wrote:Could I convince people there's a wolf in BGC/Frog because there 100% probably is? Don't know, it'd probably be easier to vote Save and see where that leads but I'll go the hard route for now.

I’d do Titus over Save.

Save is just eww imho based on Frogs play.

I'm not entirely convinced on Titus scum tbh, could just be misguided villager following Frog who knows. I'm not against Save going over because I think it'd at least wake people up to more scummy slots instead of trying to come up with this false world that's never existed

Ok scratch this. MariaR can be town.

In post 1572, MariaR wrote:Back to the pool for me. Goated lists keep it up
pedit: You both could be a villagers tbh I'm not putting that world out.
Pooky is just a wolf but meh

Pooky I leave to others
He never makes sense to me
His voting pattern seemed odd

I am down for if any of the above are wrong Pooky is always fine