Calvin and Hobbes Mafia(GAME OVER! Grownups Mafia Wins!)

[T S O]

ns pls

you're town

so I don't feel like defending a player as good as you

gameface on, ja?

[Metal Sonic]

what was that^



meanwhile its pretty obvious tip died lol dont hate the penguin

[Dante]

By my count...TheIrishPope and EddieFenix are the only two not to post. Have to think TheIrishPope was the other killed.

[Dante]

I have some sketchily out-of-game reasons to think TIP was scum that I actually talked to Varsoons about. Is it possible that TIP could be scum and and has a role that hides his flip to prevent association tells?

At this point I'm thinking TheIrishPope was probably the NK target...he claimed Tracker...you trying to suggest he was scum comes across a bit sketchy...did you ever state your reasons why you thought he was scum?

[TiphaineDeath]

His 1562, my wagon was just starting up and had a little bit of momentum, he could have jumped on really easily, removing a threat to himself and working hard towards another town mislynch. He would have been 3 or 4 on the wagon and not really paid much attention to, especially with some semi-bullshit reasoning. It probably would have been a really good scum move even if I called him out on it it would have been easy to say my call out was "omgus cries of a desperate scum." He didn't jump on me though. I must therefor conclude he is-
A) Bad
B) Town
C) Really Good

B seems most likely right now X_x.

[Varsoon]

TD, that's exactly the gambit the he's running. Curry town favor after hard-lurking for three days?
If you're intelligent enough to deduce that it'd be a good scum move for him to be on your wagon, then you've got to be able to figure that it'd also be an -even better scum move- to avoid doing something so transparently scummy.

[TiphaineDeath]

My point, is that it wouldn't have been that scummy. He might have gotten a scum point or two, but with ok reasoning he wouldn't have hardpinged on anyone's scumdar.

[TiphaineDeath]

Cept mine, but he was already there so why the fuck does he care. Besides I'm known for tunneling, it's easy to pass off additional points from me as such.

[Psyche]

hi, some life has gotten in the way of my activity this game

I'm going to

unvote

Guys,

Varsoons is town and if he isn't you will know by tomorrow.

Promise.

Time to fulfill a promise.

Don't you think?

Nope. Take my word for it for now.

I have some sketchily out-of-game reasons to think TIP was scum that I actually talked to Varsoons about. Is it possible that TIP could be scum and and has a role that hides his flip to prevent association tells?

At this point I'm thinking TheIrishPope was probably the NK target...he claimed Tracker...you trying to suggest he was scum comes across a bit sketchy...did you ever state your reasons why you thought he was scum?

Yes I Did.

[Psyche]

Psyche
Varsoon
penguin_alien
Rubicon
Skullduggery
Metal Sonic
T S O
TiphaineDeath
EddieFenix
Nobody Special
Dante

10 players, 4(?) scum. If we mislynch today we are terrible.

I and Varsoon are town, leaving 8; so it's 50/50.

Analysis of vote counts will probably find us one more scum, but after that it gets tricky. We have a lot of lurkers, and multiball means playing a leading role in a scum lynch is not a towntell. But for now we should focus on finding that last slimy girl, who incidentally will be the easiest to find because of association trails.

Today is pretty critical; if the other scumteam is 3p, a mislynch today means we lose our majority. I'm not sure how to get started without re-reading the thread...

[Rubicon]

His 1562, my wagon was just starting up and had a little bit of momentum, he could have jumped on really easily, removing a threat to himself and working hard towards another town mislynch. He would have been 3 or 4 on the wagon and not really paid much attention to, especially with some semi-bullshit reasoning. It probably would have been a really good scum move even if I called him out on it it would have been easy to say my call out was "omgus cries of a desperate scum." He didn't jump on me though. I must therefor conclude he is-
A) Bad
B) Town
C) Really Good

B seems most likely right now X_x.

You, PA, Nobody Special, Psyche and Dante have all done this to some degree. Are all those names town?

also why the fuck is Varsoon scum. I don't get it.

[Rubicon]

Analysis of vote counts will probably find us one more scum, but after that it gets tricky. We have a lot of lurkers, and multiball means playing a leading role in a scum lynch is not a towntell. But for now we should focus on finding that last slimy girl, who incidentally will be the easiest to find because of association trails.

This is an interesting post

[Psyche]

I'm going to point out that doing that is incredibly easy as any alliance and wonderful for getting suspicious scumhunters off of your back.

[Psyche]

Analysis of vote counts will probably find us one more scum, but after that it gets tricky. We have a lot of lurkers, and multiball means playing a leading role in a scum lynch is not a towntell. But for now we should focus on finding that last slimy girl, who incidentally will be the easiest to find because of association trails.

This is an interesting post

aw shucks thx

I wish I had my program. I've been dreaming of using it to discover association tells for a long time.

[Rubicon]

Who are your scum & town reads, Psyche?

[Psyche]

I don't have any idea atm. I will have to put in a lot of work to develop them with enough rigor.

Oh but NS is scum.

[Rubicon]

D4 and you don't have any reads.

Telling us to focus on finding the last slimy girl and ignore the opposing faction.

Not posting much in your neighbor QT, even about your only scum read.

Trying to convince us TIP is scum, which could possibly be the motive for hiding his flip. (Which also doesn't jibe with asking us to find the last slimy girl, since by your own logic, he might be dead.)

Doing a kind of IIOI with the list of names you keep posting.

Emphasizing that we have to lynch correctly today, but also pushing a Nobody Special wagon even though you clearly don't have a case on him and you haven't even mentioned him in your neighbor QT.

That last one is probably enough to lynch you on its own.

VOTE: Psyche

let's lynch TD tomorrow

[Rubicon]

Also, your play in the first 10 pages was scummy as hell. TIP towntelling? Uh huh, sure.

[TiphaineDeath]

Me and PA are town, I think NS is too, Psyche's last post is horrible, and I still have no read on dante cause I haven't read shit yet.

Irl is still topsy turvy for me.

[Psyche]

you're an idiot rubicon

[Rubicon]

you're an idiot rubicon

yay, so I'm right?

I think this ^ is how you deflect criticism as scum.

[Rubicon]

actually respond to my points or you're getting lynched.

[Psyche]

Damnit.

I don't talk to Varsoons mich because it isn't very interesting. I've already produced a case on NS. TIP did towntell. I had good reason to suspect TIP as being scum with his site chat statement, and then good reason to think otherwise when you mentioned his wiki. I use that ist to organize my rhoughts. I am repudiating any of my inclinations about any players until I re-read the thread.

You're just silly and don't know what scumtells look like.
.

[Psyche]

actually respond to my points or you're getting lynched.

What's so annoying is that it should be obvious that I'm never getting lynched.

[Psyche]

you're an idiot rubicon

yay, so I'm right?

I think this ^ is how you deflect criticism as scum.

That is how I deflect criticism from idiots.