Mafiascum.net

In post 1569, MariaR wrote:

In post 1547, Priscila wrote:I would prefer to just leave the dance today to be honest. I have no ability to care about this game from the start and even now. The only reason I can think of to stay is for mariar but she is not here and I can cheer her on from the dead thread if I want and she will probably be there soon anyway too.

YOU'RE NOT ALLOWED TO LEAVE MEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

Oh. OK. Tell me what to do?

In post 1575, Priscila wrote:

In post 1569, MariaR wrote:

In post 1547, Priscila wrote:I would prefer to just leave the dance today to be honest. I have no ability to care about this game from the start and even now. The only reason I can think of to stay is for mariar but she is not here and I can cheer her on from the dead thread if I want and she will probably be there soon anyway too.

YOU'RE NOT ALLOWED TO LEAVE MEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

Oh. OK. Tell me what to do?

Stop pushing us

Can I pull you instead?

:oops:

oops, I turned off my smilies

whatever

Whatever yourself

Actually, I think I know who I want to pair with most now.



I will tell you why I chose you when we get our neighbourhood if you accept.

Can you prod LLD just to ensure she's playing?

GBT pair with me
Vecna should be with Hebi

In post 1583, keyenpeydee wrote:Can you prod LLD just to ensure she's playing?

In post 1575, Priscila wrote:

In post 1569, MariaR wrote:

In post 1547, Priscila wrote:I would prefer to just leave the dance today to be honest. I have no ability to care about this game from the start and even now. The only reason I can think of to stay is for mariar but she is not here and I can cheer her on from the dead thread if I want and she will probably be there soon anyway too.

YOU'RE NOT ALLOWED TO LEAVE MEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

Oh. OK. Tell me what to do?

pair with mint berry crunch

In post 1584, keyenpeydee wrote:GBT pair with me
Vecna should be with Hebi

no

In post 1559, Mint Berry Crunch wrote:

In post 1558, keyenpeydee wrote:

In post 1556, Mint Berry Crunch wrote:If my choice is Dan or Key, I'm not dancing.

Then don't. It could benefit town.

That's what I'm thinking.
It takes 3 more doubtful slots out and I think there's a very strong chance of either 1 of you being Scum.

i dont see how this benefits town - when there's a choice to take out a slot via lynch or by force i'd always want to take the lynch so you can get a votecount and force scum to interact with the "easy" push (which will always be different based on whether it's s/t or t/t or even s/s)

keyen, to me, has been a really strong townread because i dont think i've ever seen him play this level of a scumgame. i'll try to address alisae's points but if you try to read him like you would read most players it's not working out well. i think thinking of him like creature was a really good point i brought up earlier.

like this is the most genuinely invested he's been, the most self-aware i've seen him (he's willing to leave himself out of the dance like) - i dont think this comes from his scum play.

vecna i want to double check but as it stands i want hebi/key, me/you, pris/mint, but if hebi refuses to take key then i will dance with him. i dont see the merit of not taking my top townread to the dance anymore.

In post 1588, gigabyteTroubadour wrote:hebi/key, me/you, pris/mint,

Sounds a great plan!



I love hoods and we can talk to each other there.

if this tip-toe'ing around is gonna lead to me being left out due to time constraints my suspicious natire is ordering everyone to lynch your pair first.

you've been asking around for concensus on who should be left out. from what i can see the overwhelming majority is saying that you should pair me and that key should be left out.

you agree me and hebi will result in a guaranteed kill during the intermission, and thus is not a very optimal pairing.

yet youre still holding off on pairing. youve been saying the entire game youd prefer me over key, but now hes suddenly your strongest townread? and youre trying to force keyen to stay in even though the majority seems to want him out?

i might not know him, but this seems really iffy.

something strange is going on here and my tingle-bone is now interested.

In post 1590, Vecna wrote:if this tip-toe'ing around is gonna lead to me being left out due to time constraints my suspicious natire is ordering everyone to lynch your pair first.

you've been asking around for concensus on who should be left out. from what i can see the overwhelming majority is saying that you should pair me and that key should be left out.

you agree me and hebi will result in a guaranteed kill during the intermission, and thus is not a very optimal pairing.

yet youre still holding off on pairing. youve been saying the entire game youd prefer me over key, but now hes suddenly your strongest townread? and youre trying to force keyen to stay in even though the majority seems to want him out?

i might not know him, but this seems really iffy.

TL;DR, Giga is scum, yeah.

In post 1588, gigabyteTroubadour wrote:ike this is the most genuinely invested he's been, the most self-aware i've seen him (he's willing to leave himself out of the dance like) - i dont think this comes from his scum play.

Unless he is blind, it's obvious you were there to accept him with open arms. He isn't in danger and priscila effectively forced one or me/Vecna to get the boot with pairing with MBC. I'm pretty sure she knows that too.

I never put any stock into "Oh woe is me, I should leave the dance" because, hmm, when push comes to shove, look who's asking. That's happened with Priscila and now Key. Something like this isn't hard to fake as scum, and it's something anyone should read somebody as town for, no matter who they are. If there are independent reasons for reading them as town, go for it, but not this. You'll get burned.

Maxous, why do you think GBT is scum? Key may be which will leave that pairing as a ? for the rest of the game, but please explain the GBT scum read.

The easiest way to summarise is that I think her reads over the game are too vague/cautious and appeasing.

In post 1571, Cabd wrote:(expired on 2017-07-30 08:58:49)

^Live timer.

In post 1596, Maxous wrote:The easiest way to summarise is that I think her reads over the game are too vague/cautious and appeasing.

Why the insistence on keeping Key in though? You think giga would be this blatant over protecting a potential scumbuddy?

no?
Key is town