Mafiascum.net

In post 695, Enchant wrote:

In post 687, Ythan wrote:

In post 685, Enchant wrote:

In post 683, Ythan wrote:Look for scum or I'll hang you later.

I catched more scums than you already.

Each post like this make that more likely.

You want scare me or what?

Stuff like this just doesn’t add up from Scum. See if this behavior had been only targeted at me while trying to discredit my read, that would be one thing. But it’s more generalized and this is never a particularly successful strategy as Scum because it engenders no sympathy from others if you start getting pushed. Let’s be honest - people are less inclined to want to vote players they like. But actively trying to get people to like you means you’re not doing what Town is supposed to do - probe and find Scum.

In post 705, Enchant wrote:

In post 704, DrippingGoofball wrote:I dunno. I feel like being a contrarian isn't the best scum strategy, and Enchant's antics are distracting us from actual scum.

I have been able to correctly town read him when everyone else wanted to eliminate him.

I can't say that I find him townie enough in this game to defend him.

VOTE: Enchant

Ok white knight.

See ya in hell.


P.S. no really most ppl who really protected me in previous games turned scum.
Yes again OMGUS, "most common scumtell" or whatever.

More of it here.

Now, there are some players that do this as Scum. But it typically has to do with the fact that it’s an approximation of how they go about playing Town, so they try and keep the aggressive style going as Scum. I don’t have tremendous experience with Enchant, but I don’t recall this being the style they adopted when I faced them as Scum. They seemed less confrontational. Instead, they tried to look more lost.

But again, it’s just my feel for it. I don’t know that I have a good grasp of who to trust in this game just yet.

In post 1573, Andresvmb wrote:

In post 1534, geraintm wrote:I think my town lean pile is Andres and GrandpaMo.

Talk to me about GMo because I’m really struggling there.

gut feeling that scum wouldnt have blundered so badly the entire game. if they are scum, they won't be allowed to live to the end game. they relly don't need to be the focus today

In post 1579, Not Known 15 wrote:Not Voting(6)geraintm;Ythan;DrippingGoofball;GrandpaMo;Enchant;Dwlee99;

I find it kind of depressing how Andres said he wants more discussion, but almost nothing is happening. That vote count is just sad.

@DGB, do you have any other thoughts other than those two being Town? You said you were gonna do ISOs yesterday, how's that looking?

I'm thinking back to Andres' 1459. I'm going to assume Andres is Town, and I'm going to assume that I'm not wrong on Kazyan being Town. If those two are the case, then I think it points at Ythan being Scum. I'm not sure if it would make sense for there to be an all-Town wagon on Kazyan, with both Scum deciding to pile on a lurker who was much more likely to be a VT. There's going to be natural skepticism towards those on the wagon, and I don't think Alice was a huge threat to the Scumteam. So at least one Scum off their wagon, likely on the counter.

I guess the above is assuming geraintm is Town too, but with a decent amount of other people giving me bad vibes, and knowing there's only town Scum in that game, that might be an okay assumption for now. Or Kazyan's just Scum and I'm being stupid.

Does anyone in the game Townread Ythan? If so, I do wanna hear why.

I'm also curious where did GrandpaMo's Scumread of Enchant go. Once he saw Titus was dead, he said he thinks Enchant is Scum if Titus isn't, and Today it's been just role talk and not much else. Not saying I'd expect him to blindly vote Enchant and do nothing else, but. It's weird there was no mention of it at all.

In post 145, Dwlee99 wrote:So admittedly I saw a lot of words from ythan and blanked, but I want to know why they are posting here whereas my last two games with them they lurked out p much

In post 163, Dwlee99 wrote:

In post 158, Ythan wrote:

In post 145, Dwlee99 wrote:So admittedly I saw a lot of words from ythan and blanked, but I want to know why they are posting here whereas my last two games with them they lurked out p much

Receipts please.

LN 234 + TTTT. The former you lurked out a lurker spot and got mislimmed (partially my fault) and then in TTTT you didn't post in a conftown slot. Glad to see you'll be playing this game though? It looks like?

I think I was wrong that Ythan was going to play this game

I've been super busy and am literally still at work again as I type this. I need to look at isos and stuff not just skim along and I'm gonna do that as soon as I have more than the briefest respite from that.

Sorry

In post 1580, Nathann wrote:You said you were gonna do ISOs yesterday, how's that looking?

I did iso and wrote my conclusions.

DrippingGoofball
Kazyan
Andresvmb


geraintm
Nathann
Dwlee99
YthanJacksonVirgo
EnchantMargotRosa

GrandpaMo

(7);GrandpaMo;;Dwlee99;Nathann;Enchant;;
(4);;Ythan;;

(6);;Nathann;;GrandpaMo;

Could Nathann be scum?

I'm not seeing scum!Nathan on iso, though.

In post 1585, Dwlee99 wrote:Sorry

It's fine I didn't mean that to sound snappy.

Digging the new avatar DGB.

In post 1590, Ythan wrote:Digging the new avatar DGB.

I'm monkeying GiF & unwnd... I don't even know what it is!

In post 1591, DrippingGoofball wrote:

In post 1590, Ythan wrote:Digging the new avatar DGB.

I'm monkeying GiF & unwnd... I don't even know what it is!

I'm pretty confident it's a girl named Madotsuki from a game called Yume Nikki.

Oh! Cool!

In post 1588, DrippingGoofball wrote:I'm not seeing scum!Nathan on iso, though.

Nobody is seeing anything on ISO though, votes are actually actions.

Hey look, naked vote.

VOTE: Ythan

In post 1587, DrippingGoofball wrote:

TOWN

DrippingGoofball
Kazyan
Andresvmb

NOT SURE

geraintm
Nathann
Dwlee99
YthanJacksonVirgo
EnchantMargotRosa

SCUM

GrandpaMo

AliceK

(7)

Titus

;GrandpaMo;

Kazyan

;Dwlee99;Nathann;Enchant;

Jolyne

;

Kazyan

(4)

ssbm_Kyouko

;

Andresvmb

;Ythan;

DrippingGoofball

;

TitusNixie

(6)

ssbm_Kyouko

;

Andresvmb

;Nathann;

Kazyan

;

DrippingGoofball

GrandpaMo;

Could Nathann be scum?

k we are on day 2 /3 and you only have 1 scum while literally 3 townreads and null on 5 people with no explanation at all. all you have done is sheep the majority consensus from day 1 till now, and now is calling nathann pausable scum, sheeping that read from andre as well.

im down to vote this. you haven't contributed shit day 1 and now just continue to like you are by posting your reads whom are already thought about by every player.

everyone is just scared to push you because they might think u are town who is just meming but come on

VOTE: DrippingGoofball

I'm just reconsidering everything from scratch. I have a sinking feeling I was laboring under wrong assumptions. I took a step back.

My position is still that we tear through {DGB, Ythan, GMo, (a roll of tin foil with which to make a hat), Andre}, basically in that order unless we get some important new info. I didn't expect that DGB's reaction today to be just calling me town and being unbothered by my push, but I need to see DGB saying more than one reasonable thing before it goes down my list. If DGB somehow flips green, we can sort of maybe consider putting Nathann in the PoE bucket.

This interaction makes me confident that GMo should be at the end of that list of three, not the middle. In the current gamestate, scum are kind of boxed-in with the size of the PoE and they really need to it, not it, i.e. try to convince us that Nathan is scummy rather than charging into battle with DGB. I guess it wouldn't be 100% awful to bus your partner in this situation, but, like, still 80% awful.