Mafiascum.net

Can you read PYP: HoS_S and tell me what you think of Rnchant’s scumplay there

This seems weird to me, but this whole setup is necessarily going to be weird, so idk how to feel about it. It seems like this cleric role could be used to limit/detect fakeclaims, but isn't terribly helpful as a cop on its own because non-magical Scum or death-related Town are both plausible enough to make the results meaningless unless it directly contradicts a claim.
I'm... Not really confident this flips scum anymore, but... I don't know.

Can we do Tarou instead?
VOTE: Taroumaru

In post 652, Enchant wrote:Thor is more passive and not funny as maf (i saw his town and mafia in one game).
Helay and Haley because of townie reaction on "You are Vig" and overall decent game.

shout out to this read enchant had in this game that made me laugh

"Thor is town because he's not funny as mafia"

Looks like enchant does short posts, doesnt explain reads, has a lot of "Why are you voting me", seems to focus on factual stuff and chimes in on stuff but never about his own opinion. Looks like he occasionally gives reads but not really much in the way of explaining

To be honest i didnt notice any posts that had deeper analysis beyond "This person is town" in PyP.

skimming Enchant's iso there is some of the same but like 1346, 1361, 1490 seem to be examples of engaging with the game at least on a somewhat deeper level.

Also I'm not entirely sure Enchant forgets about the game if he's scum. But i could be off-base. I got the impression he enjoyed scum from dark witches alternate reality or whatever it was called. He kinda ended up carrying at the end.

I certainly go Tarou over him in any case. would rather just hear more and judge him as i go

VOTE: TarouMaru
meh

I think there's a chance this is a case of letting up the gas too early but the claim makes me lean towards Tarou yeah

letting up the gas? Letting off the gas? What's the phrase?

My point being that i am easily swayed by X-1 claims. Like that could just be a mod fakeclaim. But I lean that Ari is a town miller to the claim so that gives it some credibility.

unless it was made up as a response to Ari's role which would be quite smart

In post 1561, NDMath wrote:

In post 1521, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:r u really giving me shit for not analyzing a survey that half the fucking game didnt even bother to fill out

When you put it that way you have a point.
-

I am a 'Purely Cleric'.
Each night I investigate if a player can use dark magic, defined as magic involving the dead, curses, or controlled by antitown.
N1 I checked Taroumaru because they seemed to be a universal nullread and got that they couldn't.

I have a slight problem with this as I slightly conflict but with the two nerfs I have, I can't be sure I CC directly.

I'm not sure what you mean by conflict exactly. Your role implies NDMath's is a lie somehow? I assume by being too similar. but why would the mod give scum a fakeclaim that doesnt work

In post 1584, Morning Tweet wrote:I'm not sure what you mean by conflict exactly. Your role implies NDMath's is a lie somehow? I assume by being too similar. but why would the mod give scum a fakeclaim that doesnt work

Yes, too similar. It's a gray area because of nerfs existing. There could be scum who don't use magic that bypass NDMath. People can be framed with mine once I get going.

I don't really know if they're incompatible but it makes me pause.

So you unvote NDmath who said Taro can't use bad magic and wagon Taro instead?

I don't know what fraction we are against, but if this claim is true, i expect some magical guild or coven against us (or mod trickery). Atleast, if NDmath is from kingdom, it imploy Taro is also innocent, unless i am not understanding something.

All we know is that Tarou doesn't use dark magic

Town can use dark magic and scum can just not use it. I'm not really sure if it's helpful for anything except boxing in fakeclaims

On further thought Idk what that role would even accomplish
It sounds like based on that the scum flavor might be centered around magic, which they’d probably be aware of and have planned claims around accordingly

regardless it being helpful or not isn't really my point so much as that it's believable given Ari's role

I didn't really think about the scum faction being magic-flavoured though. I guess that could make a magic-cop fakeclaim kind of a no-brainer in that case

I don't really like the assumption that scum has mod-assigned fakeclaims. I don't really understand why you'd think that's the case, unless you were scum and given one. But I townread you for basically everything else, so... What's the deal here?

In post 1586, Enchant wrote:So you unvote NDmath who said Taro can't use bad magic and wagon Taro instead?

I don't know what fraction we are against, but if this claim is true, i expect some magical guild or coven against us (or mod trickery). Atleast, if NDmath is from kingdom, it imploy Taro is also innocent, unless i am not understanding something.

We already have an example of a Town role that could feasibly fall under "dark magic" with Meg's "Shadow of the Nightmare Lord" flip. It stands to reason that if there can be Town who do use dark magic, there can be scum who don't.
Further, the two nightkills means we have either two scumteams, an SK, a Vig, or some combination of some or all of those. It's possible one scumteam is magic flavored while the other, or the SK, is not.

I have been voted at last., figures from my activity but fellow friends, I am not scum.

@mod

aristophanes hasnt posted in 8+ days

believe ND's claim? If you do,

If you don't. why are you moving off him??

This post was initially supposed to be addressing MT, but I saw a bunch of players sheeping her unto Tarou. What the fuck is your rational there?

Idk if I believe it
It’s also not a hard clear

OK.. not a HARD clear, bur still a CLEAR. Why not tackle another slot that has NOT been checked at all? Why is it hard for you to voter Titus? Or Enchant for that matter? Still: What's the rational there?

(Let me give you an example: A Tracker says X didn't go anywhere last night. That's OBVIOUSLY not a "hard clear", but why do we vote off X on that same day still?

If Almost50 starts making sense, you know you fucked up.

In post 1594, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:@mod

aristophanes hasnt posted in 8+ days

he's also getting replaced yes