NY 151: Playground Mafia (Game Over-Mafia Win!)

[DeasVail]

So you think scum don't replace out?

No.

There are, however, reasons for which town are more likely to replace out than scum (in my opinion).

[Nero Cain]

And I've heard this theory before...I actually agree with it to an extent...scum replace out too though and there are 16 original players left in the game. Are we all scum since we didn't replace out? That's why this is null to me. I'm not willing to give an auto town read based on a replace out. I rather base it on SC's actions/words. So you think the other 3 slots are town BWO replacement too?

[DeasVail]

The other "replace-outs" were not revealing as the alignment of any of the slots. The fact that you would ask that means you are either scum or didn't understand my point to begin with.

[Nero Cain]

nope, same thing. They obviously didn't care enough about this game to stay in it. That's no less apathetic than GI was.

[DeasVail]

They didn't replace out right after someone said a "bad word". I realise that I didn't properly express my reasoning for thinking GreyIce town. I have replaced into scum slots, so I obviously know that scum replace out too, but I don't think someone such as GreyIce would have RedFF's "word" be the turning point nor do I think he would have justified his replace out in such a way that I could easily relate to as scum.

[redFF]

Oh yeah I have a townread on that slot solely from GreyICE replacing out.

[Junpei]

Are we all scum since we didn't replace out?

Mafia theory 100: The opposite of a tell does not indicate the opposite alignment necessarily.

[Code_X]

Is drmyshottyizsik usually this useless?

[Kublai Khan]

null, though he gets some scumpoints for his crappy vig kill theory. Though I wasn't accusing you of being scum. I was simply stating what his theory was. This is still not the town Jun I'm used to and Kdowns is lurking horribly so perhaps Mastin was on the right track afterall.

Alright, I was just making sure you're being consistent. If you're buying into the 2 3-scum teams theory that mastin2 pushed, then redFF should be anywhere on your townlist.

Also, calling kdowns a lurker is a little premature as there is a lot of reading to get caught up. However he should check in soon and let us know how he's progressing.

KK:

I hereby accuse you of being scum. I hope you're feeling better now.

Nero Cain:

I can easily relate to GreyIce's feeling of apathy toward this game as town. I'd expect scum to be much more motivated in this game considering they're part of a team and things had obviously been going quite well for them. I also don't see scum having Red (unless scumbuddies with him) influence their decision to replace out.

I'll take it as a compliment that the same guy who thinks apathy is a towntell thinks that I'm scum in this game. Your theory of "town are more likely to replace out" is so horrible and wrong that it actually hurts town. Flaking or replacing out is

always

a null-tell. The only reason that it seems like more town replace out than scum is because there are more town then scum players in the game. So quit with the crap logic and actually make a case on someone who you think is scummy.

[redFF]

Is drmyshottyizsik usually this useless?

Is Code_X usually this useless?

[Code_X]

You going to back that statement up with facts.

[Code_X]

Vote: Mastin2

[redFF]

You going to back that statement up with facts.

You going to back up yours?

[Nero Cain]

Is drmyshottyizsik usually this useless?

yes

null, though he gets some scumpoints for his crappy vig kill theory. Though I wasn't accusing you of being scum. I was simply stating what his theory was. This is still not the town Jun I'm used to and Kdowns is lurking horribly so perhaps Mastin was on the right track afterall.

Alright, I was just making sure you're being consistent. If you're buying into the 2 3-scum teams theory that mastin2 pushed, then redFF should be anywhere on your townlist.

Also, calling kdowns a lurker is a little premature as there is a lot of reading to get caught up. However he should check in soon and let us know how he's progressing.

3 man scum teams seem all the rage these days so its believable. Am I correct in assuming that you meant "then redFF should

NOT?

be anywhere on your townlist."

I can see your point about Kdowns but on the flipside none of codeX, AH, GI, SC or fakegod spent time posting around the rest of the site before getting active here. That said fakegod has still yet to catch up and needs to do so and post meaningful content here asap.

[Benmage]

Lib, mastin seems alot more plausible right now. But I'd love to switch.

[Code_X]

You going to back that statement up with facts.

You going to back up yours?

Yeah sure.

In 65 pages he's voted Nero and yourself. He's yet to comment on 75% of the players. He's yet to contribute anything of note and yet to actively give a proper opinion on anyone. Though he's not the only one by any means.

Just curious really whether he is usually like this so I know if the votes on him are with merit or purely just picking on an easy target.

[Nero Cain]

He's usually useless and unreadable like this.

[HezLucky]

He's usually useless and unreadable like this.

Are we talking about Benmage? He does have a scummy award, after all ...

You people need to lynch Junpei. (Although tbh we're really just cycling between 3 and 4 targets, all of whom are fine, but Junpei seems like the strongest scumread here)

I also want to hear from people who aren't uber-active.

[Nero Cain]

no, we were talking about Shotty though Ben is being pretty useless this game.

[PeregrineV]

To make it easier to find in ISO.

Vote Count 2-5

(as of Post 1549)

mastin2 (5)

- Pine, Junpei, DeasVail, StrangerCoug, Benmage

Junpei (3)

- mastin2, HezLucky, Kublai Kahn

Pine (2)

- Maxous, scooby

redFF (2)

- drmyshottyizsik

drmyshottyizsik (2)

- The Mini-Librarian, Lady Lambdadelta

The Mini-Librarian (1)

- Nero Cain

Firestarter (1)

- redFF

DeasVail (1)

- Psyche

Not Voting (5)

- Firestarter, FakeGod, kdowns, Code_X, drmyshotgun

With 21 alive, it takes 11 to lynch

Deadline:

Thursday, May 11, 2012 3pm CST

Replacing:

Firestarter

Prods:

V/LAs:

PeregrineV May 6

EDIT: Woops. I think I fixed this.

[PeregrineV]

Vote Count 2-6

(as of Post 1619)

mastin2 (6)

- Pine, Junpei, DeasVail, StrangerCoug, Benmage, Code_X

Junpei (4)

- mastin2, HezLucky, Kublai Kahn, Lady Lambdadelta

Pine (2)

- Maxous, scooby

redFF (1)

- drmyshottyizsik

drmyshottyizsik (1)

- The Mini-Librarian

The Mini-Librarian (1)

- Nero Cain

Firestarter (1)

- redFF

DeasVail (1)

- Psyche

Not Voting (5)

- Firestarter, FakeGod, kdowns, drmyshotgun

With 21 alive, it takes 11 to lynch

Deadline:

Thursday, May 11, 2012 3pm CST

Replacing:

Firestarter

Prods:

Maxous
Pine
kdowns
scooby

V/LAs:

Mastin May 9

[Pine]

/prodded

Finals

[drmyshotgun]

I've seen like the entire scum team replacing out. And that was my second completed game. So, Deasvail's Scums =/= Replace Out theory, is invalid.

VOTE: Pine

[Junpei]

We need to vote someone... if we don't get a majority we get no lynch. All aboard Mastin.

pedit: ...shotgun can you just vote Mastin?

[drmyshotgun]

But Mastin contributes more than Pine, no?

I'll see later on.

Unvote